New Delhi: The case in a
Russian court to ban the Bhagavad Gita continued to create an uproar
Tuesday with political parties voicing their concern in parliament
while the government assured that it had taken up the issue at the
"highest levels". Russia's envoy here denounced the "madmen" seeking
to proscribe the sacred text.
As the ongoing case in a court in Tomsk, Siberia, on banning the
Gita on grounds that it was extremist literature, gained centrestage,
MPs cutting across all party lines expressed their consternation in
the two houses.
Stating that it was the work of "misdirected and motivated
individuals", External Affairs Minister S.M. Krishna sought to
clarify the government's position in the Lok Sabha: "The officials
of India in Moscow and our ambassador have been in regular touch
with representatives of Iskcon. We have taken up the matter at
highest levels with the Russian government."
He said he hoped the matter would be resolved keeping in mind
India's civilisational values.
The case, which has been going on since June, seeks a ban on a
Russian translation of the "Bhagavad Gita As It Is" written by A.C.
Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada.
In a last-ditch effort, Hindus in Russia had appealed to the
Siberian court to seek the views of the nation's human rights
commission on the religious text before pronouncing its verdict. The
verdict will now be pronounced Dec 28.
Indians in Moscow, numbering about 15,000, and followers of the
Iskcon movement in Russia have appealed to the Indian government to
intervene to resolve the issue.
As the controversy escalated, Russian ambassador Alexander Kadakin
said here he condemned the "madmen" seeking the ban, and underlined
that Russia was a secular country.
"Russia is a secular and democratic country where all religions
enjoy equal respect… Even more applicable it is to the holy
scriptures of various faiths -- whether it is the Bible, the Holy
Quran, Torah, Avesta and, of course, Bhagvad Gita -- the great
source of wisdom for the people of India and the world.
"I consider it categorically inadmissible when any holy scripture is
taken to the courts. For all believers these texts are sacred," he
The BJP took up the issue in a big way.
In the Lok Sabha, BJP leader Sushma Swaraj demanded that the
government declare the Gita a "national book".
Her demand found resonance with her colleague Tarun Vijay in the
Rajya Sabha. "Can sun be banned, Himalayas be banned...?" he asked.
Hoping to extract political mileage too, Vijay said: "The matter
came up during the prime minister's visit to Russia. Did the prime
minister raise the issue?"
Several members cutting across party lines were furious.
Rajya Sabha deputy chairman K. Rahman Khan said "the entire house
agrees with this and joins in condemning this".
It came to light that the government had advance notice of the move
in the Tomsk court.
As early as Nov 1, in a letter to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's
Principal Secretary Pulok Chatterji, Krishna devotees urged the
government to use "some high-level ministerial visits" to Moscow,
ahead of Manmohan Singh's own trip, to ensure that the sacred text
was not banned.
"As a reason the affidavit quoted an assessment by a panel of expert
stating that Krishna is evil and not compatible with Christian
views," said the letter, written by Iskcon's governing body
commissioner Gopal Krishna Goswami. A copy of the letter is with
Since the letter was written, six Indian ministers and top officials
visited Russia, culminating in Manmohan Singh's visit Dec 15-17 for
a bilateral summit with Russian President Dmitry Medvedev.