More on Ummid: International l National Regional l Politics Sports Religion l History l Culture l Education



13-year old Lucknow girl to address UN summit today

Manch says Modi's cross-examination needed to arrive at truth

Millions converge on Makkah for Khatm prayers

One year after shootout, Jamia Nagar demands justice

Ishrat's family moves to SC against HC stay on probe report

AMU commemorates 'Father of the Green Revolution'

Gay Sex - Govt. takes no stand, leaves it to Supreme Court

Scrap Private Hajj Quotas, Kerala Govt. urges the centre


Zakatul Fitr distribution made more effective: In an interesting development, Jamiat Ahle Hadees in Malegaon this year took it upon itself to collect the Zakatul Fitr – the Eid charity and then ..... Read Full

Eid Al Fitr  - A Distinct Moment Worth Experience

Goodbye Ramadan

Sorry state of Wakf lands

Outlook terms wakf misuse as the biggest land scam in Indian history: A vast majority of people in the country believe that if the .... Read Full

Hindu students break madrassa stereotypes


Scrap Private Hajj Quotas, Kerala Govt. urges the centre: The selection of pilgrims for Haj should be made only through the State Haj Committees and priority should be given to persons above.... Read Full

Out of prison, shoe-throwing Iraqi scribe now fears for life: The jailed Iraqi television reporter, Muntadhar Al-Zeidi who grabbed world headlines last year for throwing his shoes.... Read Full

UAE considering full business ownership for foreigners: International companies would be allowed to hold 100 per cent ownership of businesses they set up in .... Read Full

Science, a tool to know the laws of nature and divinity - Dr. Aslam Parvaiz: Stating that Science is taken just as an another subject in our society to be taught in schools....Read Full



Hindu students break madrassa stereotypes: With the word ‘madrassa’ emerge in the mind images of students clad in sectarian attires, complete with a quintessential skull cap on the .... Read Full

Hari Masjid Firing case: Maharashtra Govt. is in line with Gujarat: The storm brewed out of the  Maharashtra government's decision to obtain a stay from the Supreme Court (SC) on the ongoing CBI enquiry into  .... Read Full

Malegaon Blast 3 years on

'Shoot them in public if they are guilty': Frustrated with the slow progress of probe, this is what Dr Nafees Aimi, wife of Dr Salman Farsi, one of the.... Read Full

The unusual hosts at Manmad Junction for Rozedars: The time for Suhur - the pre-dawn meal Muslims take to begin the fast is always hectic. Moreover, if one is traveling it won't be easy to search ..... Read Full



The Men Inspired by Debacles: If one intends to learn “how to invite a trouble and come out of it triumphant”, then one must meet Ashwin Shah aka Lalit Shah of an empire popularly known as Oasis.....Read Full

Skilled Hands converting couplets into portraits: The powerloom factories might have been the only available option for the Malegaonians, the deprived people....Read Full

"I believed, nobody could stop me this time", says Sufiyah Faruquie who not only successfully cracked the UPSC exams but also stood top in the list of the 31 Muslims who made their way to.... Read Full

Malegaonian represents India at International forum with four others: A journalist hailing from Malegaon, the Muslim dominated textile town in North .... Read Full

First Lady MPSC of Malegaon devotes herself to poor people: The First Lady Pediatrician and First Lady MPSC of Malegaon, Dr. Bibi Fatema has now been  appointed as Medical Officer at ....Read Full

Zafar Shaikh-Making Possible The Impossible: While working with Zafar Shaikh at Star Bottling Company in Jalgaon nineteen years ago, the fellow co-workers had never imagined... Read Full


Ishrat Jahan: Murder in Cold Blood

Tuesday, September 22, 2009 10:43:27 AM, Dr. Ram Puniyani

Disgraced ATS officers DG Vanzara (circled, left) and NK Amin (circled, right) examine the alleged encounter site.

(File Photo: Ahmedabad Mirror)

'Ishrat encounter a cold-blooded murder', probe report: In yet another setback to the Narendra Modi government, the Ahmedabad metropolitan magistrate, S.P. Tamang, has ruled that the June 2004 killing of Ishrat Jahan and three others was a case of “fake encounter.”...... Read Full

Ishrat's family moves to SC against HC stay on probe report

Ishrat killing: Central government stands by terror link affidavit

Gujarat rejects report. CPI (M) demands Modi's resignation

Activist wants Home Ministry to apologize for filing affidavit against Ishrat Jahan

Gujrat HC orders probe into Ishrat Jahan encounter case

In the aftermath of Gujarat carnage the then Prime Minister, Atal Bihari Vajpayee subtly reprimanded Modi Governemtn that Raj Dharma should have been followed. The implication was that state should have actively intervened to protect the innocents who were killed during the violence. What will one say if the same state selectively picks up innocent citizens, kills them and presents false stories to save its skin? While taking the oath, while joining the state one is supposed to treat all citizens as equal irrespective of their religion caste and gender. What do we say about the state, which goes on to kill its innocent citizens who happen to belong to minority community?


As the Citizen’s Tribunal pointed out in the aftermath of Godhra train burning Gujarat State machinery was told to sit back when the rioters were unleashed to kill and maim, to loot and to rape during the carnage. Now we know that in the same state, police officers have become emboldened enough to pick up minority elements, kill them in cold blood and proclaim that it is an encounter! The repeated cry of terrorists planning to kill Modi has been a favorite ploy of the police officers for killing innocents to please the CM, to seek promotions. It also helps to create a larger than life picture of Modi.


When Ishrat Jahan was killed in the June 2005, along with three others, the police officers boasted of their success that they have ably averted the attack on Modi by killing four terrorists of Lashkar-e-Tayyaba. Forensic and post mortem reports confirm that they were killed in cold blood on 14th June, shot at close range in a police custody and then, taken in a car, then put in a row on the road on the outskirts of Ahmadabad. To show that it was encounter, arms-ammunition was kept on their body. At this point of time National Human Rights Commission asked for magisterial inquiry. Later state Government also confirmed of magisterial inquiry going on. At the same time the police investigation was also started.


Justice Tamang has come out with his report that it was not an encounter and that the four killed in cold blood by police were not having any terrorist links. In response the Gujarat government is leaving no stone unturned to say that Justice Tamang had no business to release his report, the Gujarat high court has brought a stay on the report. But already the contents of the report are known through the media reports and Gujarat Government is finding no place to hide its face, also Supreme Court has seen nothing wrong in what Justice Tamang did. The total lack of remorse on the part of Gujarat Government is not surprising at all!


The officer, D. G.Vanjara, who killed these four, was also the one who had brutally killed Soharabbudin and his wife Kauserbi, and is now behind the bars. There is a section of Gujarat people, who are very appreciative of what Vnajara has done, and the situation which Modi Government has brought in. Now the Gujarat Government asks that when the police inquiry was going on, what is the legality of magisterial inquiry? On the contrary as per the law after the death of a person in police custody, or due to police action of this type, inquest, magisterial inquiry and police inquiry all these have to be done.


It is not that it is the first time that encounter, fake encounter killings, are taking place. The difference here is the total identification and defense of such acts by the political leadership of state. The difference is that a section of people are being made to believe such dastardly acts are needed to make the society safe.

The effort of Gujarat Government is just to show a brave face in the light of exposure of its brutality in killing the innocents. Incidentally Ishrat was wearing her college, Khalsa College Mumbai, Identity Card around her neck when she was killed in cold blood. Legal nuances and nitty gritty apart where are we heading in twenty in Twenty-first Century?


Just slightly an year ago in the face of police arrest of many Muslim youth in the aftermath of bomb blasts citizens tribunals were held in Hyderabad and then in Jaipur. Legal luminaries and social activists formed the jury of these tribunals. Both tribunals pointed out that the attitude of police is very biased and many a Muslim youth are being arrested without any proof whatsoever. Will such actions by state, will such a defense of killing of innocents, not intensify the sense of injustice amongst a section of Indian citizens? 


Where are we heading to? On one hand there are inquiry commission reports showing as to how communal organizations orchestrate crimes and the section of police and part of state administration colludes. On the other plane there is the phenomenon of terrorism, which has many factors contributing to it but it is only Muslims who are blamed for that. We are also witnessing a serious and by now inbuilt discrimination leading to exclusion of minorities from the social facilities. In such an atmosphere what will happen to the psyche of the youth and others from minority community? The social disparities we are creating due to such policies are there for all of us to see. The tragedy is that a section of people have started asserting the correctness of these happenings. The situation which is being created due to all this is further used to blame minorities for it. The Modi-Vanjara duo, which is becoming a law unto them, is the symptom of deeper malaise of Gujarat.





  Bookmark and Share

Home | Top of the Page

  Comment on this article

E-mail Address:
Write here...
 Home | Contact Us | Disclaimer | Terms of Use | About Us | Feedback

Ummid Business: Advertise with us | Careers | Link Exchange is part of Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and condition mentioned.