Follow us on
Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » Regional
Cleric challenges Maharashtra govt. to test Madrasa students
Friday July 3, 2015 0:52 AM, & Agencies

[Jamia Mohammadia Mansoora in Malegaon is considered as a Model Madrasa by experts. (Photo:]

Lodging a strong objection against the Maharashtra government’s decision to dub Madarasas as ‘non-schools’ in its survey to be conducted on July 4, President of All India Milli Council Mahmood Daryabadi on Thursday challenged the state to conduct tests on Madrasa students if it considers them illiterate.

“If the government considers Madarasas as ‘non-schools’ and hence their student as illiterate, it should conduct tests to assess their education level. We are confident that they will perform far better than the students of the government schools”, he said while talking to

“This is not a challenge merely on paper. Universities like Jamia Millia Isalamia New Delhi, Aligarh Muslim University and Usmania University Hyderabad had done similar assessments. They were surprised by the results”, he added.

"The Madrasas impart education to the children belonging to below poverty line families providing them with free meal and lodging facilities. All this without any government aid. The government should be grateful of us”, he said.

Daryabadi also said that, contrary to the propaganda, majority of Madrasas are now teaching modern subjects along with religious education.

"Besides the regular Madrasa curriculum, we also teach Mathematics and Science, and also languages like English, Hindi and Marathi. Most of the Madrasas now also have computer education", he said.

Daryabadi was commenting on the Maharashtra government’s decision to classify madrassas in Maharashtra as non-schools and its direction to the district administrations to declare madrassa students as "out-of-school children".

A letter to this effect has been sent by Jayshree Mukherjee, principal secretary of the minority affairs department, to Nand Kumar, principal secretary, school education and sports department.

The department of school education has planned a massive survey on July 4 to identify out-of-school children in the state and bring them into mainstream education.

Daryabadi also said that the All India Milli Council has formally registered its objection on the decision with the concerned ministry.

Maharashtra has about 1,890 registered Madrasas with Malegaon having maximum number, including Jamia Mohammadia Mansoora - considered as a 'Model Madrasa' by experts.

The move also came in for criticism from state party leaders of both the Congress and the Samajwadi Party.

The move was "diametrically contradictory" to Prime Minister Narendra Modi's declared vision to bring Muslim youths into the national mainstream, said M. Naseem Khan, a Congress leader and a former minister for minority affairs.

"In the 2012 Gujarat assembly elections, modernisation of madrassas was included in the BJP's election manifesto. Modi spoke about this in parliament. In the union budget for 2015-2016, the Centre allocated Rs.100 crore for this noble cause. Now, the
Maharashtra government is talking like this," he said.

"The government has not accorded them recognition; so where's the question of derecognising them? Such statements will have no impact and the good education imparted in madrassas will continue unhindered," said Khan while referring to the alleged move to "derecognise" approximate 1,900 madrassas across the western Indian state.

The ruling BJP-Shiv Sena government has decided to "derecognise" the madrassas in the state as formal schools since they only impart religious education.

Defending the move, state Education Minister Vinod Tawde said the government wants to bring in modern subjects in madrassas without interfering with the religious education.
"How is that anti-Muslim? We want to do this for their betterment... Under the Right to Education, children who aren't taught under National School Curriculum are considered out of school," Tawde said.

The move -- on which Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis has not commented so far -- evoked a sarcastic response from Leader of Opposition Radhakrishna Vikhe-Patil: "Is it a decision taken in haste, or a well thought about decision?"

The move could deprive madrassas of funds for improvisation, unless they get affiliated to a formal board like the Maharashtra education board, Indian Certificate of Secondary Education or Central Board of Secondary Education and include subjects like science, maths and social studies in their curriculum.

"We have never asked for funds from them (government). We run madrassas purely on public charity ... Besides Islamic teachings, we train them to be good human beings who shun all social-political evils to become good citizens of any country they belong to," state Samajwadi Party president Abu Asim Azmi told IANS.

He pointed out that the Uttar Pradesh government recognises madrassa education and also gives them funding wherever required.

"Unfortunately, the BJP government in Maharashtra is attempting to divert public attention from a series of scams involving its ministers and trying to create insecurity in the minds of minorities around the country," Azmi claimed.

Mumbai Congress president Sanjay Nirupam said the Fadnavis government's move was an affront to the rights of the minorities and the party would challenge it in court and take up the issue in the coming state assembly session, while the state Congress has also slammed the move.

Questioning the wisdom behind the move, both -- Khan and Azmi -- pointed out that there were many examples in the country where madrassa-educated youths cracked top competitive exams like those for the civil services, IIT, IIM or other major professional and technical courses.

"During the Congress-NCP rule, we initiated the proposal to modernise madrassa education in the state. Instead of continuing the good work, the present BJP-Shiv Sena government is overturning it," Khan said.

The issue has assumed significance in the backdrop of the demand for job and academic reservations for the Muslims and the recent anti-beef law.

Share this page
 Post Comments
Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of