Education Scholarships

Direct link to the various education scholarships offered by the Government of India

List of Private NGOs offering education scholarships

Ummid Assistant

Application form for OBC & Domicile Certificate Certificates (Urdu)

Admission to UPSC Coaching Centre run by Dr Ambedkar Competitive Exam Centre (ACEC), Pune

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » Views & Analysis

Astha of a secular democratic country

Saturday, October 09, 2010 06:10:27 PM, M. Burhanuddin Qasmi

Related Article

Ayodhya appeal may throw up faith-fact issue: Sibal

"Can faith be the basis of a fact?" This fundamental issue may arise in the Supreme Court if it is moved by any litigant against the Allahabad High Court's Ayodhya verdict, Human Resource Development Minister Kapil Sibal has said.   »

Ayodhya verdict: Okay to Ram temple, land to Muslims too

Factsheet: Timeline of the Ayodhya Dispute

No temple was demolished for mosque: Justice S.U. Khan

Force of faith trumps law and reason in Ayodhya case

Indians have moved on, now leaders must: Indian media

Peace without justice can never be enduring. It would be rather a time bound compromise by the weaker side. The brief before the Allahabad High Court verdict on 30th September was that of a title suit on Babri Masjid and Ramjanam Bhumi dispute.

The honourable three bench judges, comprising Justice Dharam Veer Sharma, Justice Sudhir Agarwal and Justice SU Khan, converted themselves into some kind of arbitration panel and provided a new twist in the modern Indian history. They have opened a new Pandora’s Box causing a never ending debate on Astha – belief versus secular democratic constitutional ethics. And it is all done in the name of justice and peace.

It would be shortsighted to accept their convoluted verdict and feel that they have helped reducing the tension between Hindus and Muslims by any degree. To me the verdict has rather made the issue more complicated and took it further from any amicable solution in near future.

A mature secular democracy is a country which stands by its own constitution only and remains peaceful without going by the majority or minority Astha – feelings. For the first instance the Ayudhya title verdict was largely delivered on the majority basis and that is too on the basis of Hindu belief. Out of three, two judges of the honourable High Court have gone with the majority Astha thus the dispute was decided according to majority judges’ verdicts.

Justice DV Sharma and Justice Sudhir Agarwal are agreed on two major points with slight textual differences in their judgment. The very crucial issues which should be considered as benchmark for all succeeding judgments are (a) the disputed structure – Babri Masjid, is the birthplace of Lord Rama “as per faith and belief of Hindus”. And (b) the disputed building – Babri Masjid was constructed ‘over’ or ‘after demolishing a Temple’ according to Archeological Survey of India.

Justice SU Khan, the minority judge, though did not base his judgment on Astha or any belief yet his findings are unconvincing for many Indians. An NRI living in the USA Mr. Kaleem Kawaja argues:
Justice Khan acknowledges in his finding No. 6 ‘That the Babri Masjid was built a long time ago and was used as a mosque for prayers by Muslims until 1949. He also acknowledges that the Hindus started to use the space outside the mosque building but within the compound of the mosque in about 1855. Thus Muslims used the building of the mosque for about 350 years. Hindus put the idols of Rama at night between 22n and 23rd December 1949 inside the mosque building. Thus Justice Khan acknowledges that the mosque (disputed) structure was not used by Hindus until about 60 years go when idols of Rama were installed there surreptitiously.

But in his finding No 11 he directs that the land that was earlier under the central dome of the erstwhile Babri Masjid be given to Hindus only. According to Mr. Kawaja finding No 11 of Justice Khan which is the order of the learned judge contradicts his own finding No 6 where he says that the mosque building was not used by Hindus for prayers until the Lord Rama’s idols were installed there 60 years ago.

Mr. Ghulam Mohammad, a Mumbai based scholar, say that ‘the Muslim claim on Babri Masjid is akin to their claim on their own Indian identity. All secular people should not succumb to the Sangh Parivar pressure and rogue tactics and try to find solution in the mirage of a court judgment flawed so thoroughly as to be a blot on the name of justice.’

Mr. Kashiful Huda, the editor of popular observes that the thinking is near unanimous among Muslims; Babri Masjid verdict should be appealed in the Supreme Court. Indeed, the case should go to India’s highest judiciary body and all arguments should be made and heard because Allahabad High Court’s faith-based ruling has implications for not only Muslims but India as a whole. For this, the pleading group in the Supreme Court doesn’t need to be a Muslim group only.

The verdict delivered by the Honorable Allahabad High Court on the Babri Masjid Ramjanam Bhumi title dispute, many believe, sets a serious precedent and it has implications beyond this case. Tomorrow some goons may put idols inside the Taj Mahal, Qutab Minar or Delh’s Jama Masjid and keep them there by force for a while to substantiate their claim on the basis of ‘place of birth is a juristic person and is a deity’ according to Hindu belief.

This argument can not be undone saying that it is just a hypothesis to create fear psychosis among Indians. Rather the thesis got some rational even before the Ayudhya verdict which the verdict has changed in to a real concern for the secular democracy of India. To confirm this concern one may visit Qutab Minar today and find small idols kept or curved with in the premises and are in abandoned! Visit the Taj Mahal and buy cheaply available ‘Taj Mahal ki Itihas’ in Hindi with book vendors out of the premises and enjoy reading an entirely different and extraordinarily fabricated history of the standing love symbol—the Taj Mahal. Similarly if one can just do rewind a few of the audio visuals produced by the RSS and VHP during nineties and know about their stand on various historic masjids including the Jama Masjid of Delhi.

So it is the turn of the highest court of the country – the Supreme Court to make history – decide where does actually stand the Astha of a secular democratic country? By all means Muslim would and should not come to the street even if they lose whole of Babri property. Let the court only make a difference between faith and facts.


M. Burhanuddin Qasmi is director of Mumbai based Markazul Ma'arif Education and Research Centre and editor of Eastern Crescent magazine. He can be contacted at







  Bookmark and Share

Home | Top of the Page

Comment on this article

E-mail Address:
Write here...

News Pick

Dalai Lama to open World Peace Festival in Pune

Retired super cop and social activist Kiran Bedi and some of the eminent scientists and educationists will participate in the World Peace Festival here Oct 10, which Tibetan spiritual leader Dalai Lama will inaugurate  »

Chinese activist Liu Xiaobo wins Nobel Peace Prize

Jailed Chinese dissident and writer Liu Xiaobo has been awarded this year's Nobel Peace Prize, the Norwegian Nobel Committee   »

Nigeria calls for Indian assistance in ailing textile industry

Nigeria has sought Indian assistance to boost the country's ailing textile industry. "The areas of assistance are pretty obvious. We are proud of your textile industry and are committed »

AMU Off-campus Centers: Plea against university decision dismissed

The Allahabad High Court has dismissed a writ petition against the Aligarh Muslim University (AMU) decision to set up two new centres at Malappuram in Kerala and Murshidabad in West »

Pakistani Minister: Tell me, where there is no corruption

A minister has made a candid admission in Pakistan's National Assembly -- coruption is everywhere, "the question is where it is not." Federal Minister for Railways Ghulam Ahmad Bilour said: "I don't say  »

Five killed in Mumbai building collapse

At least five people were killed and 27 injured when a portion of an old building collapsed following a gas cylinder blast in south Mumbai Thursday afternoon, officials said. A portion of the Dwarkadas building in Chor Bazaar area  »

More Headlines

Notification for NRIs' voting rights out: Minister

‘Slumdog’ movie star turns defiant Palestinian girl

Middle East Talks: Arab League supports Palestinians stand

RSS, SIMI two sides of same coin: Jaiswal

UN rights chief welcomes Nobel for Chinese dissident

Free education for CWG medal winning students

Omar trying to internationalise Kashmir issue: BJP

Angry China insists Nobel winner is a 'criminal'

Chinese activist Liu Xiaobo wins Nobel Peace Prize

Dalai Lama to open World Peace Festival in Pune

US energy firm to invest $2.4 bn for solar power plants

AMU Off-campus Centers: Plea against university decision dismissed

Campaign in Goa: Buy a cow, save the tiger


Top Stories

CWG Tennis: Sania, Somdev in finals, Paes-Bhupathi out

India's Somdev Devvarman was at his fluent best on way to the men's singles final while Sania Mirza took time to come on top in the women's singles semi-final of the tennis   »

'Delhi Games will be rated among the best'

India's CWG tally at 33 as shooters, archers, wrestlers, shine


Picture of the Day

Prasanta Karmakar on October 06, created history by becoming the first Indian para-swimmer to get a medal when he claimed bronze in the 50m freestyle event at Dr. SPM Acquatics Complex in New Delhu. Clocking his personal best of 27.48s, Karmakar finished behind Simon Miller of England (26.70). Matthew Cowdrey of Australia bettered his own timing to create a world record in the same event.

(Photo: PTI)


  Most Read

‘Slumdog’ movie star turns defiant Palestinian girl

The Indian actress who starred in the award winning blockbuster “Slumdog Millionaire” has moved from the slums of Mumbai to the squalid refugee camps of the West Bank in a new film: the story of a defiant Palestinian girl who wants to fight against Israel   »

Ayodhya verdict has complicated Bihar poll scene

Since Bihar is the first state which will go to the polls in the aftermath of the Ayodhya verdict, the impact of the controversial judgment is bound to be seen in the results. Intriguingly, the expectations of the two ruling allies - the Janata Dal-United (JD-U) and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)   »



RSS  |  Contact us

| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant






About us




Government Schemes





Universities at a Glance






Contact us





      Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.