Ummid Assistant

Exploring Ramadan: A complete guide in video with English translation

IGNOU trains teachers to develop online courses

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » Views & Analysis

Activists divided: For and against Hazare

Tuesday August 16, 2011 06:26:58 PM, IANS

Related Article

Anna Hazare in Judicial custody, sent to Tihar Jail

Social activist Anna Hazare was sent to seven days judicial custody in Tihar Jail, hours after he was detained Tuesday ahead of his fast-unto-death for   »

Anna detention: Both houses of Parliament adjourned for day

Hazare arrested for defying police orders: Chidambaram

New Delhi: Social activists are deeply divided over the anti-corruption movement led by Anna Hazare. While human rights activist Swami Agnivesh says the movement has a groundswell of popular support, activist and columnist Shabnam Hashmi feels Hazare has adopted an authoritarian attitude and is supported by right-wing groups.

'Hazare arrest repressive, anti-democratic'
By Swami Agnivesh

The arrest of Anna Hazare is anti-democratic and repressive. The government's authoritarian act will cost it dearly.

Government should not stand on false prestige. It should gauge the public mood and the aspirations of the youth, students and the ordinary people.

The government should realise that the proposed Lokpal bill draft falls much short of the people's aspirations. Instead of sitting on technicalities that the bill is the property of the parliament and so on, the government should immediately rectify the bill and make it an effective legislation.

Parliament should be respected, but the supreme parliament - people - should get higher respect.

There is a groundswell of support for the movement against corruption. I and other colleagues in the India Against Corruption movement, personally felt it during Hazare's fast in April. Despite all gloomy predictions, hundreds of people came out to back him today also. There have been demonstrations in various states and even outside India. The movement is irresistible now.

Public sentiment is against corruption. Now, nobody can stop this yearning for transparency and accountability. Among individuals and groups, families and communities, the talk narrows down to one point: Corruption and the mounting corruption in the country.

The government should not invent arguments for delaying and evading an effective Lokpal bill. Every day delayed will recoil on the government. It will have to pay a huge political price.

'Hazare movement linked to right-wing'
By Shabnam Hashmi

I don't support Anna's movement at all, neither does he represent me any way. He has adopted an authoritarian attitude in his fight against corruption and is affiliated to right-wing Hindu groups.

I have myself been fighting the government pressing for some legislations like the communal violence bill. But that doesn't mean you can undermine the existing democratic institutions of India.

Framing laws need deep engagements, holistic consultations. Bills aren't Maggie noodles that you cook for two minutes and are ready to eat.

What Anna is proposing is an anti-democratic Lokpal. It would take away all the power from existing institutions and suddenly we will have an over-arching and super-power like institution.

I myself don't agree with the government on various issues. The prime minister should come under the ambit of any anti-corruption institution.

There is nothing that the proposed Lokpal will bring to bear in the form of greater sense of transparency and accountability in the system than what the existing institutions have achieved or not achieved.

For that, a necessary condition is the creation of a social consciousness which would decisively disapprove and reject the culture of favouritism and nepotism.

You also need to define corruption. Are you only worried about the monetary corruption? What about the suppression of poor in the name of development. Land is being grabbed from poor farmers. Look what is happening to minorities in Gujarat.

Does your Lokpal cover all that? Or you are ignoring morally corrupt behaviour of people?

And then there is the issue of covert support by right-wing Hindu activists to the Hazare movement.

Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) and Akhil Bharatiya Vidhyarthi Parishad (ABVP) activists have been participating in the movement. And Anna likes to stand with Chief Minister Narendra Modi. Is his movement really that clean?






Bookmark and Share

Home | Top of the Page



Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS




Top Stories

Anna Hazare in Judicial custody, sent to Tihar Jail

Social activist Anna Hazare was sent to seven days judicial custody in Tihar Jail, hours after he was detained Tuesday ahead of his fast-unto-death for a stronger anti   »

Anna detention: Both houses of Parliament adjourned for day

Shutdown in Hazare's village, protests in Pune, Mumbai


  Most Read

Hazare arrested for defying police orders: Chidambaram

Gandhian Anna Hazare was arrested Tuesday for refusing to abide by conditions imposed by police regarding his proposed hunger strike, Home Minister P. Chidambaram said Tuesday. He told  »

Anti-corruption activist shot dead in Madhya Pradesh

An anti-corruption crusader and Right to Information activist, Shehla Masood, was Tuesday shot dead outside her residence here, police said. Masood was in her car in Koh-e-Fiza area when she was shot in the neck, Inspector General of Police Sailendra Srivastava told IANS  »


  News Pick

Malegaon Ka Superman who campaigned against tobacco use suffers from cancer

He earned laurels from international film critics and experts when in his film he campaigned   »

Independent India and 'slave trade'

64 years of Independence, and  we still  celebrate our independence day with full enthusiasm and vigor. The day marks the freedom of our country from the   »

This is not the India we fought for, say freedom fighters

Team Anna versus government: Information warfare hots up

A full-blown information warfare has broken out between Team Anna and the government, with both sides deploying social media tools, SMS and e-mail campaigns to drum up support and run down each other - in what is proving to  »

Palestinian State: Abbas makes Arab aid appeal; sees risk to UN bid

President Mahmoud Abbas on Monday appealed for Arab financial support to help the Palestinians deal with “pressures and threats” from Israel and its allies which he said were a risk to his  »


Picture of the Day

Dignitaries coming out from the Red Fort after Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh addressed to the Nation on the occasion of 65th Independence Day, in Delhi on August 15, 2011.

(Photo: BM Meena)



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant






About us




Government Schemes










Contact us





      Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

© 2010 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.