Outspoken PM wins no new friends

New Delhi: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh Thursday appeared to have won no new friends following a rare media interaction where he expressed frustration that his government was being dubbed the country's most corrupt.

His candid answers Wednesday to several questions -- and wavering replies to some -- only sparked more criticism from an increasingly aggressive opposition, particularly the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP).

"There was nothing new in the interaction," BJP spokesperson Nirmala Sitharaman told IANS, a day after the prime minister met select editors. "We get the impression of a defensive prime minister, evading responsibility for major issues like the 2G scam."

Her reference was to the second general spectrum allocation scandal that has badly dented the Congress-led government's image and sent a key MP and a former cabinet minister from an ally to prison.

The BJP pulled up Manmohan Singh for evading the role of Textiles Minister Dayanidhi Maran in the scam.

Sitharaman accused Manmohan Singh of trying to put the blame on the opposition for his government's failure to reach an agreement with the civil society on framing a strong Lokpal to battle corruption.

"And his comments on the economy are contrary to what the ordinary people experience -- steep price rise and inflation," she said.

With a slew of corruption scandals enveloping his government, Manmohan Singh insisted that the cases of graft involving his party and its allies were aberrations.

He admitted that corruption had emerged as a big issue but argued that the bulk of civil servants were honest.

The prime minister also promised to work towards a national consensus on the Lokpal bill and added that he had no objection to being covered within its ambit -- although his cabinet colleagues held a different view.

S. Ramachandran Pillai of the Communist Party of India-Marxist (CPI-M) felt that the prime minister's aim behind meeting select editors Wednesday was to "wriggle out of the internal dissent and difficulties he is facing in the party".

"His explanations and justifications about the ommissions and commissions of the government will not carry any credibility," he added.

"The ground reality is that the government has utterly failed to tackle the major problems like corruption, prise rise and agrarian crisis."

Analyst N. Bhaskar Rao of the Centre for Media Studies (CMS) appeared to agree.

"The prime minister must have been more forthcoming," Rao said. "The proactive angle expected from a PM was not there. He tried to avoid tough answers."

Rao felt that Manmohan Singh, who personally enjoys a reputation of a honest politician, could have earned brownie points had be promised to axe those ministers facing corruption charges.

"His criticism of the media was unexpected," he added. "The prime minister should have rather thanked the media (for exposing corruption).

"If people are talking about corruption, the credit goes to media."

In an unusual criticism of the fourth estate, the otherwise soft-spoken prime minister accused the Indian media of being the accuser, prosecutor and judge.

Anil Bariwal of the think tank National Election Watch-Association of Democratic Reforms also faulted the prime minister for not giving "clear answers".

"There was hardly anything new or substantial that could be derived from what the prime Minister said. The people expect concrete action.

"It was more of an image makeover exercise, but the fact is that the image will be taken care of if the real issues are addressed."

Congress spokesperson Manish Tewari disagreed.

"This was not an effort to repair the image of Manmohan Singh. His image has been always clean and his integrity unquestioned," Tewari told IANS.

"His statements clearly show that the government was taking important steps to ensure economic growth, curb inflation and implement pro-people schemes."

Home | Top of the Page

Top Stories

Manmohan says he is doing his best, flays media

A frustrated Prime Minister Manmohan Singh Wednesday denied "a growing perception" that his coalition government was under siege and  »

Not a lameduck PM: Manmohan Singh

Ready to be under Lokpal, but cabinet must agree: PM

  Most Read

Narendra Modi slammed for destroying 2002 riot documents

The Congress said Thursday that the Gujarat government had deliberately destroyed intelligence records related to the 2002 riots in the state. "It is astounding that vital documents  »

Telangana movement set to enter crucial phase

After a four-month lull, the movement for statehood to the Telangana region of Andhra Pradesh is set to enter a crucial phase with the major players, hopeful of achieving their goal, gearing up to  »

  News Pick

Organization of Islamic Cooperation sets up own rights panel

In an interesting development, the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) has decided to establish a human rights »

Maoists abduct US varsity researcher

An American university researcher was abducted along with a local in Bihar's Jamui district by suspected Maoists, police said Thursday. Juhi Tyagi, in her mid 20s, a sociology research fellow at Stony Brook University in New  »

Two DU staffers held for supplying fake caste certificates

Two Delhi University (DU) employees have been arrested for supplying fake caste certificates to students for admission to colleges, police said Thursday. Neeraj Sharma and Sanjit Mahajan are both permanent employees of  »

Court acquits six accused of gangraping US national

Acquitting six students of the charge of gangraping a US national, the Bombay High Court Wednesday dismissed the Maharashtra government challenge to a trial court verdict in their favour, a lawyer said.  »

Picture of the Day

They are not high-profile celebrities, but at least 33 wildlife lovers have adopted animals at Bhopal's Van Vihar National Park here under their unique guardianship scheme. Others can also do the same. A board is put outside the enclosure with the name of the sponsor.

(Photo: IANS)