Ummid Assistant

Jamia Millia launches courses on China, Afghanistan

IGNOU launches value education programme for teachers

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » Views & Analysis

Populism is Mamata's Achilles heel

Saturday November 12, 2011 05:13:50 PM, Amulya Ganguli, IANS

A visitor to Kolkata cannot but notice how the city has become livable again, as it was nearly throughout its 300-plus years of history except for the recent period of communist rule.

While the traditionally affluent areas of Ballygunge, Alipore, New Alipore and others have improved further with the new high-rises confirming their prosperity along with the shopping malls - the latest sign of wellness - it is the large numbers of multistoreyed buildings which make emerging localities like Rajarhat look like Gurgaon of the late 1990s.

Notwithstanding the all-round improvements in living conditions - no prolonged load shedding, better traffic management and, above all, the absence of the pervasive fear of falling foul of the Marxist militia - the future remains uncertain because Mamata Banerjee is apparently still some distance away from getting a grip on the situation even if her six months in office is too short a time to make an assessment.

For her, there has been only one positive achievement so far, which is to defuse the Darjeeling issue although it has by no means been resolved. It will be futile to expect the supporters of the demand for a separate state to fade away quietly. But, at least, the tension has subsided, mainly because Mamata has been less arrogant in her dealings with the pro-separation leaders than her customarily haughty predecessors.

Otherwise, her government can be said to be marking time for the present, providing no clear indications about how it intends to move forward. The improvements that have taken place are largely the outcome of a slight tightening of the bureaucracy and the private sector investments in hotels and malls because of a more stable law and order situation. But the government is apparently yet to find its feet.

One reason for the immobility is its focus on what the prime minister called its "unbridled populism" when he rejected the demand of the Trinamool Congress MPs to roll back the petrol price hike. Reports suggest that he "scolded" the MPs as a headmaster does a bunch of school children when he asked them to ponder over the kind of West Bengal which they want to leave to the next generation.

Although Mamata has toned down her earlier threats of withdrawing her ministers from the centre unless the diesel and cooking oil prices are also raised, her populism was evident when she turned down for the seventh time an appeal by the electricity suppliers to raise tariffs although the denial means that these companies will incur a loss of Rs 1,600 crore by the end of the current financial year.

If the consumer paying user charges offends her "socialistic" instincts, her opposition to land acquisition - the agenda which led to her victory in the wake of the Singur and Nandigram agitations - has held up the nuclear power plant at Haripur and scared away the corporate sector. But, aware, like Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee, that farming cannot absorb all the growing population, she has sought industrial investment, but only in the public sector.

This was exactly the advice which the Marxist maverick, Ashok Mitra, gave to Bhattacharjee. But, while such a course of action may marginally increase the state's employment potential, it is unlikely that the traditionally inefficient public sector will boost industrial production or earn profits. Even the jobs will in all likelihood be cornered by Trinamool supporters with the Congress getting crumbs from the table.

But a blinkered economic outlook is not Mamata's only drawback. Her heavy-handed political style is evident from the fact that while, on one hand, she is seeking a gargantuan Rs.20,000 crore economic package from the centre, on the other hand she treats the Congress in West Bengal with barely disguised contempt. It is probably Pranab Mukherjee's patience and the centre's coalitional compulsions which sustain the alliance although there is no love lost between the two partners in the state. However, it is undoubtedly her economic bailout demand which made her retreat on the question of the petrol price hike, her first concession.

While Mamata's uncertain course is evident from all this, her inexplicable blunder over a local issue has shown her in very poor light. This was when she stormed into a police station after several Trinamool activists were arrested for indulging in violence. Not surprisingly, the suspects were soon released, which strengthened the impression of the chief minister's unwarranted interference in a matter of law and order. For most people, the incident is bound to arouse a sense of deją vu, for it was precisely this kind of manipulation of the police for partisan purposes that was the hallmark of the Left's rule. Earlier, Mamata's feckless response to the disturbing number of deaths of children in government hospitals also hurt her image.

It is clear that unless she stresses professionalism in administration and seeks expert advice on economic matters, her government will not have an easy run.


Amulya Ganguli is a political analyst. He can be reached at






Bookmark and Share

Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS







Top Stories

Trial starts in high-profile telecom airwaves case

Over seven months after the first set of charges were framed in the second generation (2G) spectrum case, the trial began Friday despite the prime accused, former telecom minister A. Raja, refusing to query witnesses pending  »

What is the 2G spectrum scam about?

Spectrum of charges against Raja, 13 accused in 2G case


  Most Read

Azad's efforts in shaping the Indian Education Policy

As the Minister for Education he insisted that both the Union and the States must share responsibility in promotion of education. He appointed the University Education Commission in 1948  »

UNESCO creates fund to overcome US-induced shortfall

UNESCO Friday launched an emergency multi-donor fund to overcome a shortfall caused by the US witholding its dues. The African nation of Gabon immediately donated $2 million to the fund »

US halts $60 mn contribution to Unesco over Palestine


  News Pick

UN chief stresses diplomacy to solve Iran N-standoff

UN Secretary-General Ban Ki- moon Thursday expressed deep concern over the possible military-dimension to Iran's nuclear programme, and called for a diplomatic solution to resolve the issue. The secretary-general has expressed  »

Type 2 diabetes rising among kids: Experts

Type 2 diabetes, the most common form of the illness, is on the rise among children under 15-years-old, with altered lifestyles and bad food habits increasing their vulnerability to the ailment, experts say. "Type 2 diabetes which  »

Tougher anti-tobacco rules for TV, films

Henceforth, every time an actor is seen taking a puff on screen, a prominent scroll warning that smoking is injurious to health will run at the bottom. What's more, the actor will personally read out the ill-effects  »


Picture of the Day

More than 2.5mn people from all across the world have gathered in Makkah for Haj which starts November 05, 2011 this year. Haj, the fifth pillar of Islam is a religious journey to the House of Allah in Makkah. This is in response to the call of Prophet Abraham when Allah commanded him to call mankind to perform Haj. Haj is the largest gathering of Muslims as about three million Muslims from all over the world meet to worship their Lord. All barriers including language, color, class and race are broken.

(Photo: Arab News/Ahmad Hashad)



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant






About us




Government Schemes










Contact us





    Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

© 2010 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.