|
Don't cross 'Lakshman Rekha' on media curbs,
apex court urged
Wednesday April 11, 2012 09:55:39 PM,
IANS
|
|
|
|
|
New Delhi: While
protecting the rights of an accused to a free and fair trial not
prejudiced by media reporting, the Supreme Court should not cross
the 'Lakshman Rekha' of reasonable restrictions provided in the
constitution, a senior lawyer contended Wednesday.
An apex court constitution bench of Chief Justice S.H. Kapadia,
Justice D.K. Jain, Justice S.S. Nijjar, Justice R.P. Desai and
Justice J.S. Khehar was told by senior counsel Anil Divan that the
restriction on free speech and expression could only be reasonable
and confined to those specified under Article 19(2).
"This is a Lakshman Rekha. You can't go beyond Article 19(2) to
protect the (right guaranteed under) Article 21. This would amount
to undoing the 60 years of jurisprudence done by the Supreme
Court," said Divan, who appeared for The Hindu newspaper.
The court was hearing an application by the Sahara India Real
Estate Corp voicing its grievance over a news channel reporting
its proposal made to the Securities and Exchange Board of India on
securing the money it mopped up from the market.
The court earlier said that it would frame guidelines for
reporting on sub-judice matters.
Divan said that the reasonable restriction specified under Article
19(2) could only be in "relation to sovereignty and integrity of
India, security of the state, friendly relations with foreign
States, public order, decency or morality".
Besides this, restrictions could be imposed in relation to
"contempt of court, defamation or incitement to an offence", he
said.
He said that the guidelines for reporting on sub-judice matters,
if at all they had to come, must not be coercive and binding in
nature.
In a poser to Divan, Chief Justice Kapadia asked: "If a court says
that it wants to protect the rights of an accused (to free and
fair trial) under Article 21, would it amount to restriction on
any other fundamental right under chapter III of the
constitution."
As Divan resisted the attempt to put in place guidelines to
regulate media reporting of the sub-judice matter, the chief
justice said: "If presumption of innocence is the basis of the
rule of law and if a court feels that due to media reporting that
presumption of innocence is breached, thereby infringing upon the
administration of justice, does the court have no powers to put
the restrictive ban or temporary ban on media reporting the court
proceedings."
The senior counsel told the court that it could not frame the
guidelines taking recourse to its inherent powers under Article
142, which empowers the apex court to enlarge the scope of hearing
in a particular matter.
"The inherent powers had to be exercised with great caution" as it
may happen that the exercise of the power, intended to achieve
justice, may end up frustrating the goal, he said.
Chief Justice Kapadia asked if a competitor in business used media
to attack his rival, should there be no guidelines to check them.
"There are cases where they (media) know that they are being paid
by a party to hurt or destroy someone's business rival. What
happens in that situation?" he asked.
Referring to an earlier apex court constitution bench judgment,
Divan said that the proceedings in a pending matter were open to
public and media could not be restrained from reporting it.
He told the court that apex court had already "balanced the
requirement of 'open justice' principle and the 'fair trial'
doctrine…"
Arguing that guidelines could not cure all the ailments in the
world, Divan said "how far we can go. We can't cure all ailments
in the world by guidelines. Where we say thus far and no more".
|
|
Home |
Top of the Page
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Top Stories |
|
 Quake rattles Sumatra, India feels tremors
Many states along India's east coast felt tremors
after an earthquake measuring 8.5 on the Richter scale rocked
Sumatra in Indonesia Wednesday. Disaster management experts said
there was no threat of a tsunami in India, »
India sounds tsunami warning after
Indonesian quake
|
|
|
|
Most Read |
|
India, Pakistan plan Siachen, Sir Creek
talks
Building
upon discussions during President Asif Ali Zardari's Sunday visit
to New Delhi, India and Pakistan are looking to step up the
dialogue process by seeking to set dates for talks on the disputed
Siachen glacier
»
|
|
Battered by father, Bangalore baby dies
Afreen,
the three-month-old Bangalore girl who was battered by her own
father as he wanted a son, died Wednesday after battling for life
for several days, hospital authorities here said. "The baby
suffered cardiac arrest at 10.40 a.m. We tried resuscitation »
Baby girl tortured by father, this
time in Bangalore
|
|
|
|
News Pick |
|
Is India still an uncivilized nation?
Some anti- social elements have
unleashed a trail of events to create communal hatred among
communities in otherwise peaceful city of Hyderabad. There are
reports that PIG FLESH was thrown inside three
»
|
|
Expedite passports for Haj pilgrims, UP urges centre
Uttar
Pradesh has asked the central government to expedite the process
of issuing passports to Muslims seeking to go for Haj pilgrimage
to Makkah.
In a letter written to union External Affairs Minister S.M. »
|
|
Iran busts terror cell linked to Israel
Iran Tuesday
said it has busted a terrorist cell linked to Israel and arrested
a number of its members. The intelligence ministry said, "One of
the terror and sabotage cells of Israel and a number of its
protected cores were identified
»
|
|
|
|
Picture of the Day |
|
 |
|
Emir of the State of Qatar His Highness Sheikh Hamad Bin
Khalifa Al –Thani and Her Highness Sheikha Moza Bint Nasser
being received by Minister of State for Petroleum and Natural
Gas and Corporate Affairs R.P.N. Singh, on their arrival, at
Air Force Palam Airport, in New Delhi on April 08, 2012.
|
|
|
|
|
Comments
|
Quick links