Ummid Assistant

Samsung sets up fund for poor kids' education

US varsity offers doctorate for education professionals

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » Views & Analysis

Can Siachen be an 'ice breaker' for India and Pakistan?

Sunday April 29, 2012 11:58:54 AM, Ravi M. Khanna, IANS

Related Articles

India, Pakistan plan Siachen, Sir Creek talks

Building upon discussions during President Asif Ali Zardari's Sunday visit to New Delhi, India and Pakistan are looking to step up the dialogue process by seeking to set dates for talks on the disputed Siachen glacier and Sir Creek marshland.  »

Pakistani President Asif Ali Zardari is taking a huge risk in trying to hype up public opinion, within Pakistan and on an international level, in favour of resolving the Siachen glacier problem with India.

The Siachen glacier suddenly made the news headlines earlier this month when Zardari came to India for one day to visit Ajmer Sharif and on the eve of the visit, an avalanche on the glacier killed more than one hundred Pakistani soldiers. It again hit the headlines the next day as one of the issues Zardari discussed with Singh when he hosted the Pakistani leader for lunch before his trip to Ajmer.

According to Pakistani sources, the sudden visit by Zardari soon after Pakistan granted the much awaited MFN status to India was to convince Singh that the Zardari government genuinely wants to improve relations with India. According to the sources, Zardari urged Singh that India should now reciprocate by taking a meaningful step to please the Pakistanis who really want their government to improve relations with their neighbour through trade and other exchanges. Zardari assured Singh that his talks in Pakistan could be turned into a historic visit if the two sides can sign an agreement on the Siachen Glacier. That, he said, would genuinely build tremendous goodwill for India among the Pakistani people as well as with the Army. What he did not say, but was obvious, was that this would also help Zardari win the next elections and improve his relations with the Army Chief.

But the problem is that India has too much to lose if it agrees to the Pakistani formula to resolve the dispute and it may even be accused of compromising India's security to accommodate Pakistan's compulsion.

Siachen glacier , in fact, is part of the UN sponsored LoC agreement between the two sides on Kashmir. And the roots of the conflict over Siachen lie in the non-demarcation on the western side on the LoC map beyond Grid Point NJ 9842. Since it was left unmarked and both sides had their own interpretation of the direction of the LoC beyond that grid point, it eventually led to a conflict.

The dispute started in 1984, when the Indian Army captured the two key northern passes in the Saltoro Range. Pakistan tried a few times to dislodge the Indian troops from their posts but found it too difficult because the heights it was holding were lower than the ones under India's control.

But the defeat on the glacier was never forgotten by the Pakistani Army. So in 1999, then Army Chief General Pervez Musharraf tried to avenge the defeat by quietly sending forces to occupy Indian positions in the Kargil heights that were left unmanned by India during dangerously cold snowy winters. Pakistan's adventure in Kargil was aimed at cutting off Indian supply routes to Ladakh and thus secure Siachen indirectly. The attempt failed but brought the two rivals close to a fourth war, with both sides suffering heavy casualties. The Pakistani move in Kargil is etched permanently in the Indian psyche.

Now Pakistan wants that Indian troops in Siachen glacier should just withdraw to the positions they held prior to 1984. But the problem for India is that in 1963, Pakistan unilaterally and illegally conceded the Shaksgam area, north of Siachen, to China. So now if India withdraws to the positions it held prior to 1984, it would mean removing the only bulwark to prevent Pakistan and China from linking up militarily on the glacier, a move that will be a losing proposition for the Indian Army.

Even if they are authenticated and marked before the troops are withdrawn, as India had proposed, it will take third-party neutral observers to monitor the situation. Pakistan, so far, has refused even to accept India's demand of authentication of the positions, and India sees the refusal as a hidden agenda of Pakistan of occupying them at some future date.

The hurdles are so gigantic that any sudden hype about an agreement between the two rivals on this dispute might boomerang against both governments, unless, of course, they find a solution that will not be perceived in India as a "sellout", and is seen as a "win-win" solution of the dispute for both.


Ravi M. Khanna is a long-time South Asia observer. He has headed the South Asia Desk in Voice of America Newsroom in Washington and published a book, 'TV News Writing Made Easy for Newcomers'. He can be reached at




Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS






Top Stories

Unite to oppose gay marriage: Pope's envoy asks Muslims, Jews

The pope's representative in Britain has urged Roman Catholics to form a "united front" with Muslims and Jews to oppose gay marriage, a media  »

Dead Sea can help Govt. take a wise decision on Gay Sex

Church activists protest Moscow gay film fest


  Most Read

Third Gandhi visits Maharashtra, but drought continues...

As Congress general secretary Rahul Gandhi began his one-day tour of drought-hit areas of Maharashtra's Satara district Saturday, he became the third Gandhi after his late father  »

Kashmir's Barelvi, Ahle Hadith leaders deny sectarian tension

Amid talk of tension between Kashmir Valley's predominant Barelvi Muslims and the fast spreading Ahle Hadith school of thought, their leaders have dismissed it as "false propaganda"  »

Mirwaiz Umer condemns efforts to trigger sectarian strife


  News Pick

Israel leaders misleading public on Iran: Ex-security chief

The former chief of Israel's domestic intelligence agency has accused the country's leadership of "misleading" the public on the merits of a possible military strike on Iran, BBC reported. Former Shin Bet chief Yuval  »

Jaffar Sharief, Dhawan for governor's posts?

The Congress leadership is considering some senior leaders and retired officials for appointment as governors in view of Raj Bhavan vacancies in some states, party sources said Saturday. The sources said former  »

Bangaru Laxman sentenced to four years' jail

A Delhi Court Saturday awarded four years' rigorous imprisonment to former Bharaitya Janata Party (BJP) president Bangaru Laxman for accepting a bribe »


Picture of the Day

Ban Ki-Moon, secretary-general, United Nations, conferred with 'Doctor of Letters'by Jamia Chancellor Lt.Gen.(Retd) M.A. Zaki and Vice-Chancellor Najeeb Jung, at a special convocation at Jamia Millia University.

(Photo: IANS)



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us




    Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

© 2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.