Ummid Assistant

IDB scholarship forms available at Bhopal's Companion School

IGNOU's preparatory course for students desiring higher education

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » Views & Analysis

Armed forces' grievances need urgent attention

Sunday August 12, 2012 11:43:19 PM, C. Uday Bhaskar, IANS

The suicide of a soldier, V. Arun, from Kerala in Jammu and Kashmir was raised in parliament. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh urged MPs not to have a discussion. "This is a very small incident, which is being blown out of proportion. It is not good for the morale of our armed forces."

While his statement was clinical and accurate, the choice of words may not have been politically the most appropriate -- no death of a citizen can be dismissed as "small" by the leader of a democratic country.

One presumes the prime minister was not keen on an open discussion on the subject since it pertains to an in-house matter - discipline within a military unit - that falls within the organizational purview of the Indian Army.

For a one million strong army, this suicide, while tragic in a relatively minor empirical occurrence, an in-house inquiry into the internal cohesion and professionalism is imperative.

From the ignominy of the ketchup colonel, the booze briagdier and the 'dal' general and more recently the Sukhna and Adarsh real estate scandals, the Indian Army has been convulsed with varied transgressions and a lowering of its ethical and professional standards.

In 2012, there were two cases of serious breakdown in officer-soldier relations in units tasked with low-intensity-conflict duties. The recent suicide is indicative of the internal stress and tension the Indian Army has to address.

These are matters the army needs to review in an objective and candid way. There may be a case for an independent commission to empathetically review as to what ails the Indian Army.

The status accorded to the military varies from country to country and is a complex derivative of the history of the nation, its political character and the manner in which valour is perceived.

In authoritarian regimes, the military has a special status. In Pakistan, it has subsumed the state for decades.

Democracies have a more complex relationship with their military. The soldier and the patriotism and gallantry inherent in the profession is recognized by the state and society. In India, the military has a curious and ambivalent status apropos the state structure and society at large.

Since 1947, the Indian military as an institution has been kept outside of the formal structure of the state due to Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru's distaste for the profession of arms. Successive prime ministers kept the military aloof. Consequently the 'fauj' occupies a twilight zone, where it is neither fish nor fowl.

While the elected political representative aree the new ruler in India, the civilian bureaucracy have become astute mediators of the pursuit and consolidation of power and status in the world's largest democracy.

The progressive denigration of the armed forces by the state and society has led to a steady erosion of military morale - a danger the prime minister alluded to in parliament. The apathy of the Indian state is best illustrated by the manner in which the Manmohan Singh government has dealt with pay and allowances for the soldiers.

An objective review of the manner in which the pay, allowances and status of the military have been lowered over the last two decades reveals some startling facts. The military is the outcaste in the Indian state matrix, but lacks a Gandhi or an Ambedkar to take up their cause.

The average 'fauji' retires at a much younger age than the civilian counterpart who serves up to age 60. An empathetic state would have ensured that the inter se fixing of pay, allowances and pension would be equitable. Alas, this is not the case. Many anomalies abound.

Pay commissions do not have a military representative. Review committees have the same pattern. The military remains invisible and their grievances ignored.

Things have come to such a pass that the three serving chiefs have expressed their dismay over how pay and pensions for serving and retired military personnel are being addressed.

Minister A.K. Antony in turn has cautioned the prime minister that if not redressed, this issue could take "a bad turn".

The UPA had a rare opportunity to address and redress the long festering inequities regarding the military and the larger issue of rewiring the security establishment. But Manmohan Singh and his cabinet chose not to pick up the gauntlet - till the last lap of UPA II when the Naresh Chandra Task Force was set up to review the post Kargil security sector reforms.

Manmohan Singh's Aug 15 address will be closely monitored for the policy initiatives he will hopefully unveil to assuage the bruised morale of the military - and avoid the 'bad turn' which otherwise seems inevitable.

(C. Uday Bhaskar is a leading strategic affairs analyst. He can be contacted at


Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS




More Headlines

Expanding circle of influence: Importance of mentoring in the business world

Israel tests missile alert system

CPI-M slams UPA's idea of 'Har Hath Mein Phone'

Olympic wrestling: Sushil wins silver, first to win back-to-back medals

Manmohan set for high-wire diplomacy in Iran: Oil, trade, Syria on agenda

Input costs, lack of reforms hit India Inc. business confidence

Ramdev to continue fast, gives Monday deadline to PM

Ban on Jan Myrdal’s India visit undemocratic

Who needs a Modi apology?

Probe agriculture ministry's role in clearing Bt Cotton: Parliament panel

Iran quake toll up: 250 killed, 1,800 injured

This Hyderabad mosque is more than a place of worship


Top Stories

Police say they prevented 'holocaust' in Mumbai

A top police official branded Saturday's violence in Mumbai as "pre-planned" and said there may have been an "holocaust" but for the extreme restraint his force exercised.  »

Raza Academy, Muslim groups apologize for violence

Mumbai calm but police remain on guard

Community leaders condemn Mumbai violence, appeal for calm

Two dead in Mumbai protests against Assam riots, Myanmar killings


  Most Read

Who needs a Modi apology?

The Muslims need justice, not a convoluted apology from the architect of Gujarat 2002

Of late though one descries a growing desperation in the Gujarat leader as he eyes the Delhi throne  »

1250 years later, Baghdad is a far cry from past glories

Baghdad was once the capital of an empire and the center of the Islamic world, but at 1,250 years old, the Iraqi city is a far cry from its past glories after being ravaged by years of war and sanctions, according to an AFP report. Construction of the city on the bank of the Tigris River began  »


  News Pick

Wrestler Yogeshwar gets India Olympic bronze after hockey embarrassment

Wrestler Yogeshwar Dutt gave India lot to cheer about by winning the bronze medal on a day when the hockey team, eight-time Olympic champions, ended their  »

This Hyderabad mosque is more than a place of worship

In this historic city where minarets of hundreds of mosques dot the sky, one mosque stands out as more than a mere place of worship. Besides the five-time prayers a day, the mosque is playing a significant role in addressing  »

I'll welcome Rahul Gandhi to UPA government: Manmohan Singh

With Congress general secretary Rahul Gandhi agreeing to take a more proactive role, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh  »

Can Rahul Gandhi grow beyond cameo roles?

Iran quake toll up: 250 killed, 1,800 injured

At least 250 people were killed and over 1,800 injured as two powerful earthquakes rocked northwestern Iran, Fars news agency reported Sunday. A quake measuring 6.2 on the Richter scale struck Ahar city in  »


Picture of the Day

President Pranab Mukherjee administering the oath of Office of Vice President to Mohd. Hamid Ansari at a Swearing-in-Ceremony at Rashtrapati Bhavan, in New Delhi on August 11, 2012.



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us




    Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

© 2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.