Ummid Assistant

IDB scholarship forms available at Bhopal's Companion School

IGNOU's preparatory course for students desiring higher education

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home Education & Career

Equal varsity reservation for disabled as SC/ST: Court

Monday September 17, 2012 02:14:27 PM, IANS

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court has held that a university here has to provide equal reservation to disabled candidates in admission as available to scheduled caste and scheduled tribe candidates to avoid "discrimination".

The court said it was "discriminatory" on the part of Delhi Technical University (DTU) to provide only five percent relaxation in admission to disabled candidates in comparison to 10 percent reservation to scheduled caste and scheduled tribe candidates and asked the university to also extend this to disabled candidates.

"People suffering from disabilities are equally socially backward, if not more, as those belonging to SC/ST categories and therefore, as per the Constitutional mandates, they are entitled to at least the same benefit of relaxation as given to SC/ST candidates," a division bench consisting of Acting Chief Justice A.K. Sikri and Justice Rajiv Sahai Endlaw observed in a judgment made available only now.

The bench was dealing with the question of law as to the quantum of relaxation in standards to be provided to disabled candidates for admission to engineering college in the reserved quota for persons with disabilities.

The question that arose before the court was whether or not the relaxation provided to SC/ST candidates for B.Tech programmme at DTU, that provides technical courses, was to be extended to disabled candidates.

The court's direction came on a plea filed by one Anamol Bhandari, who is 50 percent physically disabled.

He had challenged the provisions of DTU that has provided 10 percent concession of marks in the minimum eligibility requirements for candidates belonging to SC/ST, but relaxation of only five percent for people with disabilities.

The plea said that Bhandari through AIEEE examination became eligible to be considered for admission in DTU. He secured 52.66 percent (PCM) in Class 12, whereas minimum eligibility for physically challenged candidates in the university is 55 percent, and so he was not being considered for admission for B.Tech computer science course.

"If the relaxation to people with disability candidates is given at par with SC/ST candidates, i.e., to the extent of 10 percent, then he becomes naturally eligible to be considered in DTU," the petition said.

The court, besides directing the university to provide 10 percent relaxation to physically challenged candidates, also asked it to consider Bhandari for admission in B.Tech course and, if found eligible for admission, grant him the same.

"We, therefore, hold that the provision giving only five percent concession in marks to disabled candidates as opposed to 10 percent relaxation provided to SC/ST candidates is discriminatory and people with disability are also entitled to same treatment.

"The mandate is, accordingly, issue direction to DTU to provide 10 percent relaxation. Thus, the minimum eligibility requirement for persons with disability becomes 50 percent in PCM," the order said.

Advocate Rajan Mani, amicus curiae in the case appointed by the court, told IANS: "DTU's admission criteria for general category candidates was 60 percent marks at class 12 level, relaxed by 10 percent for SC/ST candidates (i.e qualifying marks of 50 percent) but only by five percent for disabled candidates (i.e. qualifying marks of 55 percent).

DTU had sufficient seats reserved for persons with disabilities but did not find Bhandari eligible based on the qualifying standard of 55 percent for the disability reservation category, added Mani.

The university, an autonomous one that comes under the technical education department of the Delhi government, however, had told the court it is a policy decision to grant five percent relaxation to disabled students keeping the cut-off entry at 55 percent and these standards are in conformity with the Delhi University where relaxation of five percent marks is given to disabled students.

The court also highlighted the government's decision that was accepted by the Supreme Court that reservation for disabled is called horizontal reservation which cuts across all vertical categories such as SC, ST, OBC and General.

The court opined: "Since people with disabilities belonging to SC/ST categories, i.e., vertical categories enjoyed the relaxation which is provided to SC/ST categories, there is no reason not to give the same benefit/concession to those disabled who are in General Category or Other Backward Class Category as that process only would bring parity among all persons' disparity irrespective of their vertical categories."

"This itself provides for justification to accord same concession, viz., 10 percent concession to people with disabilities as well, in all categories which is extended to those disabled students who fall in the category of SC/ST," the order further added.





Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS




More Headlines

When people turned a blind eye: Story of a Dalit woman

First batch of Indian Hajis leave from Srinagar

Dubai's food, rental prices among world's highest

Iran foundation ups bounty on Salman Rushdie

Ultrasound helps drugs get under your skin

Job stress can lead to a heart attack

One killed, 10 injured in clash outside US consulate in Karachi

Chest pain? A non-surgical, leg massage may help

Anti-Islam film actress says maker duped her into taking role

Al-Azhar Sheikh demands global ban on attacks on Islam

Delhi's monuments will be lit by solar energy


Top Stories

Opposition to Eco Reform:

Mamata gives 72 hour ultimatum to UPA govt.

Cong hits back, says want Mamata in UPA, but no problem if she leaves

The Trinamool Congress Sunday said it would be forced to take a "hard decision" if the UPA government fails  

'FDI in retail to help improve supply chain, boost growth'

Political masterstroke to revive PM's reformer image: Analysts


  Most Read

Al-Azhar Sheikh demands global ban on attacks on Islam

Sheikh Ahmed Al-Tayyeb, grand imam of Al-Azhar, called for an international ban on all forms of attacks against Islam, after a provocative film sparked violent protests in the Middle East and North

Saudi spiritual leader Al Al-Sheikh asks film protesters to stop violence

Saudi Arabia's highest spiritual leader has called on the Muslims to denounce violence in protest of an anti-Islam video made in the US. "If Muslims surrender to anger, they will achieve the objectives  

Man linked to anti-Islam film questioned by officials


  News Pick

Ghaziabad violence: Two intelligence officials suspended

Two intelligence officials of Uttar Pradesh Police have been suspended while another official may face the same fate over 

Violence in Ghaziabad: Six die in police firing

Radical Left party wins three posts in JNUSU poll

Radical Left All India Students Association (AISA) bagged three of the four posts in the Jawaharlal Nehru University Students Union (JNUSU) elections  

Congress' student wing sweeps Delhi University elections

Delhi's monuments will be lit by solar energy

Building on the experience gained over the last three years and keen on promoting the use of environment-friendly solar energy, the Delhi government plans to light up more of the capital's historical sites through cheap and plentiful  

Don't demolish 200-year-old Hindu temple: Pakistani court

A court in Pakistan has restrained authorities in the port city of Karachi from demolishing a Hindu temple believed to have been constructed 200 years ago, a media report said. According to the Dawn


Picture of the Day

Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh and President of the Palestine National Authority Mahmoud Abbas at the delegation level talks, in New Delhi on September 11, 2012.



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us




    Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.