Malegaon tragedy exposes bias of
November 30, 2006, Tanweer Fazal
When a blast claims innocent lives, we, with a fair degree of conviction, point to Islamic militants of whatever ilk, Kashmiri jehadis or desperate groups out to avenge Gujarat. No sooner does an incident takes its toll, the story is laid out threadbare — the organisation and its module that carried out the operation, its link with Pakistan, antecedents of the terrorists involved, their training camp in Jalalabad. Incriminating documents, AK-47s, suspects and their confessional statements are out in double-quick time. We can hardly restrain our pride at the ability of our sleuths to track down the culprits — SIMI, Jaish-e-Mohammad, Lashkar-e-Taiba, teachers and students of madrassas.
The plot and the protagonists remain the same; it is only their
ability to constantly discover one vulnerable site after the other
that grants a novelty to the terrorist strikes. But if so much was
known, why couldn’t the strike have been averted?
We are outraged over racial profiling of Asians (had it been only
Arabs?) in US and in Europe. But religious profiling is what Muslim
youth in India, especially those in the ghettos, live with every
single day. SIMI was an instant suspect in all eyes following the
Mumbai train blasts. The anti-terrorism squad (ATS) of the Mumbai
police, therefore, relinquished all other lines of investigation.
Irrespective of their involvement in the blasts, a witch-hunt for
all ex-activists of this radical Muslim students organisation was
An overzealous superintendent of police in Tripura found the beard
and the cap of the Tablighis too offensive — 11 members of the
Tablighi Jamaat from Mumbai were detained in Tripura for a week on
mere suspicion. Only in April this year, two Bajrang Dal activists
died while making a bomb in Nanded, leaving a trail of evidence —
detonators, timers, remote control devices, costumes associated with
Muslims, maps of the mosques nearby. And indeed, mosques were
bombed, in Parbhani, Purna and in Jalna. But for the Maharashtra
police, this was not worth investigating.
It is not security agencies alone that stand to be blamed. Mohammad
Akram, a madrassa teacher in Gaya, was arrested for his involvement
in Mumbai blasts. While his arrest hit national headlines, his
subsequent release, having been cleared of all charges, failed to
enthuse the media. Perhaps some lessons could be drawn from the
Ghatkopar bomb blast case. The Mumbai police had chargesheeted
around 20 Muslims based on their links with SIMI and Lashkar-e-Taiba,
the police drew confessions, produced documentary evidence,and even
witnesses, but failed to impress the court. The special POTA court
acquitted all of them — but it was too late for Khwaja Yunus, who
was killed in custody.
The script, however, seems to have changed with Malegaon. The ATS is
in no hurry to name the culprits; neither have India’s elite
intelligence agencies pointed the needle of suspicion towards any
outfit, Hindu or Muslim. The foreign office, as of now, has not
given any briefings on Pakistan and its involvement. There is little
frenzied speculation in the media about the identity of the
perpetrators. Also absent are those Muslims, who with placards in
their hands ‘Down with Pakistan’, would come out to display their
loyalty lest anyone doubts it.
This time, they are taking to the streets, in Malegaon, in Akola and
in other parts, to ask certain fundamental questions. Why is the
police so reticent in naming the suspects or the organisation to
which they belong? Why has Malegaon remained so neglected?
Malegaon has a history of communal riots, so newspapers inform us.
But the last big flare-up in 2001 was less a communal clash and more
an instance of state terrorism unleashed on its Muslim residents.
Some local youth were distributing pamphlets after the Friday
prayers. The pamphlet ‘Be Indian, Buy Indian’ made a fervent appeal
to boycott US goods in protest against the American war on
Afghanistan. But the state reserve police posted there tried to stop
distribution of the pamphlets. Indiscriminate police firing left
three dead. If this is not religious profiling at work, what is? Why
must every political move of Muslims be met with suspicion and
Amidst these unanswered questions, there are other pertinent issues.
Malegaon mirrors any other urban locality with a predominantly
Muslim population. It is marred by infrastructural decay — narrow
lanes, open drains, inadequate sewage disposal, frequent power cuts,
madrassas making up for the lack of schools, and no public hospital.
There are many other similar towns — Bhiwandi in Maharashtra and
Murshidabad in West Bengal that reported starvation deaths, Bahraich
in UP with the country’s lowest human development index,
impoverished Mewat abutting the millennium city of Gurgaon, Bihar’s
Kishanganj with the lowest literacy rate, and Muslim-dominated
old-city areas in major metros.
That Malegaon is a town populated by weavers has not helped. Call it
the darker side of globalisation or sheer governmental apathy,
weavers across the country are seeing the dwindling of their
businesses. Most of them happen to be Muslims, Ansaris or Julahas,
as they are called. Dearth of government orders, shortage of yarn,
inadequate marketing and credit facilities, erratic power supply and
stranglehold of Marwaris and banias have contributed to their
impoverishment. It is this everyday brutality of deliberate state
neglect and unrelenting suspicion that violates their dignity and
being — more than three mysterious bombs ripping through the streets
of a sad, desolate and decaying town.
The writer is with the PM’s committee looking into the status of Muslims.
courtesy Times of India
Ummid.com is part of The Awaz Networks providing world news, news analysis, Islamic news, news related to Muslim community, education, health. politics, technology, sports, entertainment, industries etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and condition mentioned.