Supreme Court slams lapses in medical college admissions

Saturday April 09, 2011 09:48:55 PM, IANS

New Delhi: In an apparent expression of its exasperation over the state of medical education in the country, the Supreme Court slammed the authorities for ignoring the admission procedures and virtually selling the seats.

"The best way for medical test (admission) is to put the seats to auction and whosoever bids successfully should be awarded admission," sarcastically said the apex court bench of Justice B. Sudershan Reddy and Justice S.S. Nijjar Friday.

The court's observations came in a case in which a medical college admitted six Class 12 students without their appearing in a pre-medical test. The students and the college defended the admissions.

Senior counsel K.K. Venugopal, appearing for the students, questioned the Rajasthan High Court's order faulting the students' admission to a medical college affiliated to the Rajasthan University of Health Sciences.

He said, "It is the court that holds force against me", prompting Justice Reddy to say: "We also seem to be suffering from the same syndrome."

"I have great reservations over the state of medical colleges in the country," said Justice Reddy, adding "(It is) not that we discount our (apex court) contribution (in the existing state of medical education)".

When Venugopal argued that after pursuing the course for two-and-half years, the question mark on the admission of the six students may affect their career and leave the six seats vacant, the court said: "Are there no higher principles involved than the argument that let no seat go vacant".

The Jaipur-based medical college admitted the six students against vacant seats for which there were no takers among the candidates who succeeded in the Rajasthan Pre-medical Test (RPMT), a common entrance exam.

These six students did not appear in the RPMT and had merely cleared the Class 12 exam.

Senior counsel Pallav Shishodia claimed that Class 12 was the eligibility criterion for admission to medical courses and not the pre-medical test.

Venugopal said the court "may be satisfied that in this case there was no 'hera pheri' (wrongdoing)".

The court said it wanted to hear the Medical Council of India's counsel before deciding the matter and adjourned the matter.

                                           Home | Top of the Page

Top Stories

Lokpal Bill will be introduced in monsoon session: PM

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh Saturday said the government will introduce the Lokpal Bill in parliament during the monsoon session  »

Anna Hazare to end fast, government bends

 Jantar Mantar in festive mood after 'people's victory'

  Most Read

Pakistan's reciprocity helped peace moves: Pillai

Home Secretary G.K. Pillai says talks with Pakistan were revived and progressed after Islamabad promised cooperation on counter-terror measures, including fast-tracking the  »

Top religious leader killed in Srinagar blast

Prominent religious figure and Chief of Jamiat Ahle Hadees Jammu & Kashmir Maulana Showkat Ahmad Shah was killed on Friday in an improvised explosive device (IED) blast outside a mosque  »

Maulana who opposed stone pelting - and died for it

  News Pick

Imbibe invaluable traits of Maulana Azad in your life: Prof. Rizvi to youths

The towering personality of Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, the first Education Minister of Independent India, was laced with head and heart qualities of a thinker, philosopher, writer  »

NIA takes over probe in Mecca Masjid, Ajmer, Malegaon blast cases

Launching its probe into suspected role of right-wing groups in terror acts, the National Investigation Agency (NIA) has taken over investigation of three blast cases -- Mecca Masjid  »

India-Bangladesh project to dramatise Tagore's prose, poems

A major project jointly launched by India and Bangladesh aims to dramatise some of Nobel laureate Rabindranath    »

  India, Bangladesh announce joint Tagore celebrations

India faces manpower crunch in post-disaster situations

India is least prepared to deal with psycho-social and mental health problems that arise in the aftermath of a natural disaster because of manpower shortage, the National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA) officials  »

Imprisoned Iranian journalist wins UN press freedom prize

An Iranian journalist and civil rights campaigner who has been in jail since his country's disputed presidential elections in mid-2009 has won a top UN press freedom prize. An independent jury of 12 media professionals  »

Picture of the Day

Prof Abbas Rizvi along with Principal of the College of Teacher Education, Bhopal, Prof Mahmood Siddiqui going round the exhibition on the life and work of Maulana Azad. The exhibition had some rare photographs and sketches of Maulana Azad's portraits put up by the students of the B. Ed. college on the occasion.