Thursday August 04, 2011 10:41:32 PM, IANS

New Delhi: The anti-graft Lokpal bill was introduced in parliament Thursday amid vehement protests from the opposition. Civil society activists, led by Gandhian Anna Hazare, too criticised the government draft. Here are the key points of disagreement between the government and the civil society on the bill:

Prime Minister: The civil society wants the prime minister to be under the Lokpal's ambit. The government has kept the prime minister out of the Lokpal's purview, but he/she can be probed after demitting office. Opposition parties too are opposed to keeping the prime minister out of the Lokpal's ambit.

Higher judiciary: The civil society wants the Lokpal to have powers to probe the higher judiciary, including judges of the Supreme Court. The government has kept the higher judiciary out.

MPs: The government has excluded the acts of MPs inside parliament and in parliamentary committees outside the Lokpal's purview, which the civil society has opposed.

Lower bureaucracy: According to the government draft, only officers of joint secretary level and above are covered under the Lokpal. The civil society wants the entire bureaucracy to come within the Lokpal's purview.

CBI and CVC: The government has struck down civil society's proposal to merge the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) with the Lokpal.

Punishment: The civil society has proposed minimum one year rigorous imprisonment and maximum of life imprisonment for the corrupt. The government has capped the maximum punishment at 10 years.

Lokayukta: The civil society wants the appointment of Lokayuktas, the ombudsmen in states, to be overseen by the Lokpal, which the government has struck down.



 

Home | Top of the Page

Top Stories

Lokpal Bill introduced in parliament amid protests from opposition

The Lokpal Bill which seeks to combat corruption was Thursday introduced in parliament amid strong protests from the opposition. Minister of State in the Prime Minister's Office   »

Mukherjee assures steps to tame inflation, Opp motion defeated

Curb inflation or 'go', opposition slams government

  Most Read

Ramazan in Sri Lanka: A Sri Lankan teenage-boy's recollection

The Sri Lankan Muslims form a small minority community of around 1.5 to 2 million people or around 9% of Sri Lanka’s population. As such Ramazan fasting, the fourth pillar of Islam  »

India-led UNSC seeks political solution in Syria

The UN Security Council under India's presidency has called on Syrian authorities to cease the use of force, saying an inclusive and Syrian-led political process is the only solution to the crisis there. Such a process should aim at "effectively addressing the legitimate aspirations and concerns of the   »

  News Pick

Swamy’s anti- Muslim article: Court seeks police report

Even as the National Minority Commission contemplates legal actio against Janata Party president Subramanian Swamy for allegedly making   »

Indian engineers who worked on a silk production project in Ghana have been asked to return as the machines had been lying idle for over seven years for lack of trained local engineers  »

NHRC takes up Kashmir custodial death case

The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) Thursday said it has taken cognizance of a complaint about the death of a 28-year-old man in police custody in the Jammu and Kashmir's Sopore town. According  »

Apex court reserves verdict on right to education

The Supreme Court Wednesday reserved its verdict on a batch of petitions by private schools challenging the right to education law that mandates them to earmark 25 percent seat for poor students. The apex court   »

Picture of the Day

Muslims go to Makkah al Mukarrema in Saudi Arabia for Umrah entire year other than Haj times. However, during Ramadan, number of Umrah visitors increases manifold. According to a rough estimate, over 2.5 million Muslims come from across the world to Makkah al Mukarrema for Umrah during Ramadan.

(Photo: ummid.com)