Ummid Assistant

Hajj committee's IAS coaching cell invites applications for new batch

AMU Centre for Distance Education to add five more study centres

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » Views & Analysis

Harvesting hatred from Norway to India

Saturday July 30, 2011 12:31:48 PM, Aijaz Zaka Syed

Related Articles

Italian leader supports Norwegian attacker's views

An Italian member of the European Parliament has described some ideas of Norway's mass killer Anders Behring Breivik as "good" and in some cases "excellent," the BBC said. Mario Borghezio  »

Minorities panel mulls action against Swamy for anti-Muslim views

Indian Media and the recent Mumbai attacks

Divisive communal politics in India

Are we really living in end times? Every new day brings a new outrage, a new horror. No one seems to be safe anywhere — not even in the serene, scenic Norwegian paradise. But then, as Bible warns, you reap as you sow. And Europe is reaping what its politicians and assorted purveyors of hatred have sowed all these years.

The perpetual demonization and vilification of “the Other” and the endless talk of creeping Shariah and Islamisation of Europe couldn’t have happened in a vacuum. It had to show its results someday on the ground. And it did in Norway this past week.

Still there are many out there who continue to live in denial. Within the first couple of hours, television pundits, from CNN’s Richard Quest to BBC’s security correspondent Frank Gardener, had persuaded themselves that the Norway attacks were the handiwork of “Islamist terrorists.” Soon Rupert Murdoch’s Sun was screaming: “AL QAEDA MASSACRE: NORWAY’S 9/11”.

And then the pundits went on to identify the reasons why Muslims “hated” Norway, the all-embracing Scandinavian paradise. They hated it because of its role in Afghanistan and Libya, they said. They hated it because of its freedoms and liberal society, as George W. Bush revealed long ago. They hated it because some Norwegian newspapers had reproduced the controversial cartoons. But that was years ago, wasn’t it? Well, they nursed their grudge long, didn’t they?

Next morning the whole thing was turned on its head when it turned out that it wasn’t the Muslims after all but Norway’s own homebred, all-white, Christian zealot behind Europe’s biggest mass murder by an individual in recent memory. The wonks were in no hurry to condemn Anders Behring Breivik as a “Christian terrorist” though.

They went to great lengths to paint him as a lone ranger who had turned the guns on his own kind in a fit of rage. He did not represent the peace-loving people of Norway or Europe for that matter, they asserted. Of course, he didn’t. But was he an aberration? Was it a random act of madness? I wouldn’t think so.

Indeed, the more details about the attacks emerge, the clearer it becomes it was no chance act of momentary madness. Breivik is the product of years of hate campaign and propaganda against Muslims. So most tragic as these attacks are, they shouldn’t come as a surprise to anyone, given the madness that has been going on in the name of fighting terror.

And those trying to portray Breivik as a lonely lunatic, an outsider, are not just wrong, they are out of sync with a dangerous reality. They are living in denial of the fast spreading malaise of rabid Islamophobia and intolerance on both sides of the Atlantic and its consequences.

This is not an isolated case of one man going off the bend but represents a growing threat. Breivik’s actions, patiently planned and executed over the past nine years, are entirely consistent with the periodic mass violence European fascists have carried out in recent years. More important, this “madness” was rooted in mainstream right-wing discourse that one even hears from politicians like Sarkozy.

Breivik’s 1,500-page doctrine, put online weeks before the carnage, champions a global apocalyptical crusade against Islam that now supposedly threatens the territory, morals and culture of Western civilization, indeed the whole world. In a June 11 entry, Breivik says: “I explained to God that unless he wanted the certain Islamic takeover of Europe he must ensure the warriors fighting for the preservation of European Christendom prevail.”


And it’s not just the Caucasian Christians that Breivik sought to enlist for his cause, he reached out to both the Zionists of Israel and our own Hindutva friends in India. Indeed, Israel’s policies appear to have inspired our hero. There’s a method in the madness that targeted young Labour Party supporters on Utoya Island. Eskil Pedersen, the youth wing leader of the party, had been increasingly speaking for the Palestinians, calling for an international boycott of Israel.

The intense hatred for Edward Said, the Palestinian author of the seminal Orientalism who had the audacity to hold a mirror to the Empire, is matched by admiration for luminaries like Bernard Lewis, Daniel Pipes and Robert Spencer, all known for their “preoccupation” with Islam and Muslims.

Again it’s not surprising that Breivik sees the Hindutva zealots, who dream of driving all Muslims out to create a Greater India stretching from Afghanistan to Burma, as crucial allies in the global crusade against Islam. He devotes 102 pages to India and the successful Hindutva campaign targeting the common enemy.

Applauding Hindu groups that “do not tolerate the current injustice and often riot and attack Muslims” he suggests, “Hindus are suffering from the same persecution as their European cousins. It’s essential the European and Indian resistance movements learn from each other and cooperate.”

So this monster’s manifesto indeed is Mein Kampf of our times, as The Economist puts it, in which Jews are replaced by Muslims as “the Enemy” who must be fought and expunged from the face of the earth.

Breivik’s worldview is a lethal mix of Christian zealotry and extreme Islamophobia. And he isn’t alone. Generations of Europeans and Americans have grown up on a heavy diet of bigotry peddled by politicians like Geert Wilders of Netherlands, who compared the Holy Qur’an to Hitler’s Mein Kempf, and Marine Le Pen of France and Newt Gingrich, Peter King and televangelists like Pat Robertson in the land of the free.

Feeding on the stereotypes and paranoia about Muslims, this new breed of fascism that not surprisingly turns to Israel for inspiration, poses a clear and present danger to our world. The gravest threat we face today comes not from the Islamic world but the radical Christian right and the secular fundamentalists who propagate the bigoted, hateful caricatures of Muslims, as Chris Hedges argues.

Breivik has killed many more people than the four “Muslim” bombers did in the 7/7 London attacks. Indeed, more people may have died in the violence by neo-fascist, radical right groups since the Great War than all the attacks, blamed on Muslims, put together.

Yet Western governments have so far treated such groups with kid gloves. Just as successive governments in India have dealt with the Hindu extremists despite their implication in recent terror attacks and mass violence targeting Muslims. Indeed, police turn on the victims after every such atrocity.

Inaction is a luxury the world cannot afford though, if it is to avoid more mindless carnage and a bigger conflict — in the West or in India. If we continue the way we are going, the confrontation that Samuel Huntington obsessed over all his life cannot for long remain an academic hypothesis. Norway is a wake-up call. Let’s not wait for the next great war to take place between Islam and the West.


Aijaz Zaka Syed is a widely published commentator. Write him at This article first appeared in Arab News.







  Bookmark and Share

Home | Top of the Page



Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS

More Headlines

India-Pakistan ties: More than good looks needed

US warns Indian students about "predatory visa fraud rings"

Quit now or face expulsion, BJP tells Yeddyurappa

Minorities panel mulls action against Swamy for anti-Muslim views

India circulates draft land acquisition bill

US varsity with hundreds of Indian students under scanner

MP announces cultural awards, Iqbal Award goes to Gopichand Narang

Libyan rebels' military chief killed

Kidney cells could help do away with transplants

School kids send 60,000 handmade rakhis to soldiers

Italian leader supports Norwegian attacker's views

Honorarium of teachers appointed on contract doubled in MP





Top Stories

India circulates draft land acquisition bill

The government Friday released a draft land acquisition bill that seeks to put in place a legal framework to not only protect the interests of owners and prospective buyers, but also   »

Highlights of the draft land acquisition bill


  Most Read

Minorities panel mulls action against Swamy for anti-Muslim views

The National Commission for Minorities will Tuesday decide what action if any should be taken against against Janata Party leader Subramanian Swamy  »

US warns Indian students about "predatory visa fraud rings"

As another US university came under the scanner, the United States asked Indian students to be alert to the existence of "predatory visa fraud rings  »

US varsity with hundreds of Indian students under scanner


  News Pick

Quit now or face expulsion, BJP tells Yeddyurappa

On a day of high drama and swift developments, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) high command Friday told scam-hit Karnataka Chief Minister B.S. Yeddyurappa to resign forthwith or face expulsion from the party. "BJP  »

Shariah Portfolio Management Services (PMS) launched in Mumbai

The city based Bonanza Portfolio Ltd in a strategic tie up with Pragmatic Wealth Management Pvt. Ltd. has launched India’s premier Shariah Portfolio Management Services  »

Afghan war has cost Britain 18 bn pounds

he cost of British military operations in Afghanistan was Thursday officially estimated at over 18 billion pounds (around $29 billion), The Guardian reported. The figures released by the House of Commons defence committee   »

Taj Mahal rakes in Rs.19 crore revenue from ticket sales

The seventh wonder of the world, the Taj Mahal, is the top draw in terms of tourism revenue, logging a gate entry income of   »


Picture of the Day

Jamia Millia Vice Chancellor Najeeb Jang conferring the title 'Nishan-e-Azad' on Ambassador of Saudi Arabia Faisal Hasan Trad on July 20, 2011.



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant






About us




Government Schemes










Contact us





      Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

© 2010 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.