Ummid Assistant

Applications open for Manmohan scholarship at Cambridge

Opportunities for Indian students in US

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home Views & Analysis

India's universities crying for better leadership

Wednesday February 13, 2013 01:05:59 PM, Arun Nigavekar, IANS


India's higher and professional education system is passing through a phase that is turbulent, non-directional and unsustainable.

It is turbulent because it is being pulled and pushed by several stakeholders who have different aspirations and hence varied demands.
It is non-directional because there is no comprehensive policy on governance and role of education in the growth of a nation. The system is simply drifting.

The states are struggling to find their way to meet challenge of numbers in a revenue-cost squeeze, including rising costs of faculty, technology and administrative burden.

The central government is clueless as regards creating a national consensus on larger and broader legal framework to address burning issues such as protecting merits and cost of education while retaining access and equity.

This certainly is unsustainable. It is because of such a scenario that we do not have 'winning universities'.

I use the term winning in the sense that the graduates from universities become useful driving force in knowledge-linked economy and also are talented brains that generate new knowledge.

In developed economies, winning universities are a force to reckon with. In a way, we have predominantly 'losing universities' -- universities that are performing duties of research and education as a ritual with no commitment to accountability.

Today, we do not have competitive leadership at various levels of higher education institutions. It is true for vice chancellors (VCs). It is equally true in case of academic deans and heads of departments.

What is worst is that it is true for various advisers at the policy-making level. They work with a narrow vision guided by personal likes and dislikes and try to serve narrower political causes rather than looking at global challenges.

The last statement is true when one looks at the various difficulties the Ministry of Human Resource Development is facing in the initiation of reforms based on various reports and legal framework created by the advisers with the help of internal bureaucrats who unfortunately have no feel for ground realities.

The concept of winning is more common in the corporate world. It is linked with capital markets and their profit and loss accounts.

But for universities, the test is whether they are growing and improving their use of assets. Their primary assets are faculty. The other assets are academic and support infrastructure that makes environment of the universities vibrant for learning and research. The success of winning universities is linked to the type of leadership at the helm of affairs.

In the case of universities, it is the VC who is first an academic leader and then an administrative head. At its core, leadership is the capacity to release and engage human potential in the pursuit of common cause.

With these expectations, we need VCs who act with a purpose and a vision, a focus, and an end in mind that empowers colleagues to align their initiatives with the vision of the VC, and who believe that there is mutual benefit in individual commitments in turning common vision into reality.

Leadership is not high individual performance. It is not solo virtuosity, although leaders often are high individual performers. Leadership is something that happens only between people in relationships. It is about evoking high individual performance in others. The individuals with these attributes take the university to a higher level of success and make it a vibrant academic institution.

There is one more important and critical component in winning universities. They have VCs who nurture the development of other faculty with a potential for leadership at all levels.

Hence, there are two ultimate tests for identification of a successful VC -- first is to find whether the university, by producing the right human power, has become an engine of socio-economic growth and the other is to check whether a chain of leaders is created in the system that can sustain its success even when the VC is not around.

Where does India stand in respect of choosing right leadership for creating winning universities? Indeed, nowhere.

In our country, which has a predominance of public universities, good and visionary VCs are appointed by sheer accident. The entire process of picking VCs has a strong edge of socio-political background. When one reads the interviews of education ministers and chief ministers, they unequivocally claim they would not like to interfere in the selection process.

But the fact remains that in state universities, barring a few chancellors, the rest do communicate with the government and chief ministers and education ministers do play a role of endorsement before the final selection.

In central universities, the human resource development minister also plays a role.

Just before elections for the present parliament, the human resource development minister steam-rolled the appointments of VCs for 15 new central universities.

One really wonders what these VCs are doing at present with scanty funds to new central universities. Only the passage of time would reflect whether we have added a few more losing universities in the long list of universities that have wrong leadership.

It will be interesting to visualise what line of action a VC should follow to keep the university vibrant.

Nearly 50 years ago, at the time he launched his transforming relationship with Japanese industry, W. Edwards Deming drew systemic relationships that typically exist among the enterprise, its customers and its suppliers.

Michael R. Moore and Michael A. Diamond have adapted some of the relationships we believe are critical to an academic institution's commitment to continuous improvement and the processes that are essential to making that commitment operational.

It looks at the links between research and teaching and service processes associated with them. It defines inter-linkage and inter-forces that are the major pushing factors between various stakeholders of the education institution.

The good leader necessarily needs to have qualities to understand and manage these flow processes effectively. The prime task is to achieve and sustain continuous improvement, which requires an appreciation of systems thinking, including the notion that the success of any educational institution is connected in very real ways to its relationships with and the success of all the stakeholders.

The model of 'Academic Leadership: Turning Vision in to Reality' as presented by Moore and Diamond emphasises the need for taking cognizance of following critical elements for cultivating a successful leader. They include launching a strategic planning process, change management, open, interactive communications, assessment and measurement systems, continuous improvement based on periodic reassessment of the mission and distinctive capabilities and finally, mutually beneficial relationships among the stakeholders in the institution's mission.


Arun Nigavekar is a Raja Ramanna Fellow in Science and Technology Park at University of Pune and former chairman of the University Grants Commission. The views expressed are personal. He can be reached at





Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS


More Headlines

Global outrage against North Korea nuclear test

Afzal's family says no to Tihar visit, wants body back

SC fumes over sex tests, female foeticide

Italian chopper deal: India orders probe after CEO's arrest

10 killed in police firing in Assam panchayat polls

Why Sir Syed loses and Allama Iqbal wins in Pakistan

As Tripura goes to polls, spotlight on 'poorest CM'

Clarify whether RTE Act applies to nursery admissions: Delhi Court

Nalanda University to get special funds in budget: Khurshid

Mumbai to host philanthropy week


Top Stories

Italian chopper deal: India orders probe after CEO's arrest

India Tuesday ordered a probe into the $750 million deal for 12 VVIP AgustaWestland helicopters following the arrest of the chief of its parent company - Italy's Finmeccanica on corruption charges in the contract.  

Antony seeks report on pay-off in Italian chopper deal


  Most Read

North Korea conducts third n-test

North Korea said Tuesday that it had successfully conducted a third nuclear test to safeguard its national security against hostile US policy, a move that prompted South Korea to put its military on high alert. The  

Cop shot dead in Kolkata students' clash

A police sub-inspector was shot dead and another man injured in firing by miscreants during a clash between student activists of the Trinamool Congress and the Congress at a college here Tuesday, police said. Two accused were arrested. Tapas Chowdhury, a sub-inspector attached to the city police's Special Branch, was 


  News Pick

Scared for my children: Iftikhar Gilani

Two days after he was detained by police along with his family following the execution of Afzal Guru, senior journalist Iftikhar Gilani Monday said his children were still scared, and he was scared for them too. Gilani and his 

Two Kerala cardinals among those voting for new Pope

Two cardinals from Kerala are among the four from the country to leave for Vatican to cast their vote in elections for a new pope to replace Pope Benedict XVI, the leader of the Catholic 

Pope Benedict to resign

Scientists brace for a close peek at asteroid

Indian scientists will join their counterparts globally for a rare celestial event scheduled for the night of Feb 15-16 -- the passing of an asteroid very close to Earth, around 28,000 km away, and visible with ordinary  

Britain census shows 37% rise in Muslim population

The exact figure of Muslim immigration living in Britain has been revealed in new census figures. According to the census, in the past seven years the number of Muslims living in the UK has risen  


Picture of the Day

Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh presenting the award to the District Collector, Visakapatanam V. Seshadri for promoting social equity in MGNREGA implementation, at the 8th Mahatma Gandhi NREGA Divas Sammelan, in New Delhi on February 02, 2013.


Recommend the story to your friends



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us


The Funny Side

Education & Career Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.