Ummid Assistant

Applications open for Manmohan scholarship at Cambridge

IIM-Trichy to offer short courses too at Chennai centre

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » National

People of character not joining politics, says SC

Wednesday January 09, 2013 09:24:57 PM, IANS

New Delhi: Painting a none too rosy picture of politics in the country, the Supreme Court Wednesday said people of character and integrity were not attracted to politics.

The apex court noted that the philosopher Plato had the same complaint about ancient Greece.

"We have men of character and integrity, but they don't join politics", said the apex court bench of Justice A.K. Patnaik and Justice Gyan Sudha Misra in the course of hearing a petition assailing sub-section (4) of Section 8 of the Representation of People Act, 1951, as ultra vires of the Constitution.

The judges noted that Plato had said that "Greece's city-states were not electing good people." Plato had penned his celebrated treatise "The Republic", advocating "philosopher-kings" who would have long years of training and exceptional ability.

"Judges will be failures as rulers," said Justice Patnaik, when the petitioner-in-person S.N. Shukla, general secretary of the NGO Lok Prahari, told the court that the legislature and judiciary have failed the country, and now judges should come forward and assume greater responsibility.

"Judges can at least correct rulers," Shukla responded.

Shukla assailed the sub-section (4) of the Section 8 of the Representation of People Act, 1951 saying that while convicted persons were barred from contesting elections, the said Section allowed a sitting member of either parliament or the state assembly to continue to function as such upon conviction, if they file an appeal against the conviction and the sentence.

"There can't be two categories where upon conviction a person is barred from contesting election and other by virtue of being a sitting member continues, and can even contest future elections also," Shukla contended, adding that if, after being convicted of an offence a person cannot contest elections, then a sitting member could not continue to retain his membership of the house.

Justice Misra sought to know if a person upon conviction is stripped of his membership of an elected house and eventually gets acquitted by the appellate court, then what would happen to his right in the intervening period.

She said that a balance had to be struck between the scales of justice.

Addressing the query from the court, senior counsel Fali Nariman said that in most of the cases it is the sentence and not the conviction that is stayed. He said that so long as conviction persists, the disqualification clause would be attracted. This is the law, Nariman told the court, saying that conviction is stayed in extraordinary cases.

Making a distinction between the stay of conviction and stay of sentence, Nariman said that the apex court had stayed the conviction of former cricketer and BJP Lok sabha member Navjot Singh Sidhu in a murder case and in the case of film star Sanjay Dutt's conviction in Bombay serial blast case, his sentence was stayed; not the conviction.

The court was told that the larger public good could not be dwarfed before the statutory rights of an individual.

The court will continue hearing the matter Thursday.





Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS



More Headlines

Owaisi gets jail for 14 days, pulled up by judge

'Nokia changing accounting, business model to avoid taxes'

Train fares hiked across the board after 10 years

Angry India protests as Pakistanis behead Indian soldiers

Petition to remove Owaisi's speeches from YouTube dismissed

Nobel laureate says 'superfoods' may cause cancer

Nepal hands over 12,000 schools to people

Obese moms use TV to quieten fussy infants

NHRC looks into child-labour deaths in Odisha brick kiln

Easy way to protect heart - sip black tea

MNS jolted as legislator quits


Top Stories

Owaisi gets jail for 14 days, pulled up by judge

He also pointed out that secularism was an integral part of Indian democracy and reminded Owaisi that his late father, Sultan Salahuddin Owaisi, had been a MP -- and so was his brother Asaduddin now.  »

Petition to remove Owaisi's speeches from YouTube dismissed

MIM shutdown against Owaisi's arrest hits Adilabad, Nizamabad


  Most Read

Train fares hiked across the board after 10 years

Indian train fares were hiked across the board for the first time in 10 years, with Railway Minister Pawan Kumar Bansal saying this was needed to keep the world's second largest network going. The new fares  »

Indian soldiers killed in 'inhuman' manner: Antony

Pakistani troops killed two Indian soldiers in Jammu and Kashmir in an "inhuman" manner, Defence Minister A.K. Antony said Wednesday. The killings Tuesday were "highly provocative »

Pakistanis kill two Indian soldiers, tension heightens


  News Pick

CBI nabs main accused in Assam riots

Kokrajhar Superintendent of Police Sunil Kumar said the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) team nabbed Moinul Haque from Kokrajhar district for his involvement in killing four Bodo youth July 19 last year, setting off  »

Asaram says rape victim should have 'begged', draws flak

Spiritual leader Asaram Bapu was Monday reported as saying that the Delhi gang-rape victim should have called her attackers "brothers" and recited the Saraswati mantra to avert the tragedy. This provoked both the ruling Congress and the opposition BJP to lash out at the comments as  »

Rape-murder in Noida, four policemen suspended

Four policemen were suspended and another shunted out here after a 22-year-old woman who went missing was founded gang-raped and murdered, police said Sunday. The victim's family alleged that the main accused, Udaivir Singh  »

Upset by son's death in Dhule firing, Dy Tahsildar to resign from post

Disheartened and upset by the death of his son Hafiz Asif allegedly in police firing, Abdul Haleem Ansari, who is posted in Dhule as Naeb (Deputy) Tahsildar  »

Dhule calm but tense; Govt. orders probe

Communal violence in Dhule, three killed


Picture of the Day

Artists performing dance drama based on the ‘Geetgovindam’, by Shri Jayadev, at the inauguration of the 60th Annual Arts Festival, at Kalakshetra, Chennai on December 21, 2012.


Recommend the story to your friends



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us


The Funny Side

Education & Career

    Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

© 2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.