Ummid Assistant

Applications open for Manmohan scholarship at Cambridge

Opportunities for Indian students in US

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » Views & Analysis

Congress needs to overcome trust deficit

Sunday January 20, 2013 07:00:40 PM, Amulya Ganguli, IANS

Before the Congress's Jaipur 'Chintan Shivir' brainstorming camp, there was the Surajkund 'Samvak Baithak' dialogue last November. A feature of the meeting at the Haryana tourist resort was the bus rides taken by the party bigwigs to the site. Jaipur's greater distance from Delhi precluded the adoption of a form of transport associated with the 'aam admi', the common man. So, the focus is on how the party intends to meet its latest challenge - the growing disconnect between it and the urban middle class in the wake of the ghastly gang-rape and death of a young woman last month.

This new threat has come in the wake of the erosion of its "traditional support bases", as Congress president Sonia Gandhi said, which means the Dalits and Muslims. However, there may be greater worry about the loss of touch with the middle class because the latter is more vocal. Its disillusionment is not only with the Congress, but with virtually the entire political class and it first came to the fore during the anti-corruption movement of civil society activists.

Now, it has become even more apparent if only because this time, there are no organizing groups like India Against Corruption (IAC) to bring the hundreds of young men and women out on the streets in Delhi's bitter cold to demand a sense of accountability from a seemingly insensitive political establishment. Without a leader and without even an identifiable ideology, they came out spontaneously to face the police batons and water cannons.

Not surprisingly, Sonia Gandhi referred to the challenge from the middle class in her Jaipur speech, which was otherwise replete with the usual advice to partymen to be disciplined and unostentatious. But, notwithstanding the acknowledgement about the new political reality, what the Congress will be worried about is the political fallout from the anger expressed against the party by such a large group of people and the extensive coverage which it receives from the media.

The Congress's concern may be all the greater because although it has in its ranks quite a few young and articulate MPs and union ministers, led by Rahul Gandhi, they were unable to establish any rapport with the surging crowds. The only person who made an attempt to reach out to them was Delhi Chief Minister Sheila Dikshit, but she had to retreat in a hurry after being booed. In contrast, Rahul Gandhi simply disappeared from the scene for several weeks, an absence which can come to haunt him in course of time.

Because of the gang-rape and death, and the revelations in their wake of the high rate of crimes against women, the 'Chintan Shivir' is bound to emphasise the need for proactive measures to ensure the safety of women. But what the party cannot be unaware of is that mere words have ceased to carry conviction. They have come to be seen as routine homilies, delivered by a privileged group surrounded by armed commandos.

For the Jaipur conclave to be a turning point, therefore, it will have to strive to eliminate the trust deficit that has grown between the party and a sizable section of the people. Otherwise, gatherings such as these will be seen as picnics in a scenic location. A major reason for the trust deficit is that there is no explanation as to why the systemic response to the many critical developments has been inadequate - why sleaze continues to affect the common man, why police stations are regarded as places which are to be avoided, why as many as 274 politicians with a criminal background are MPs.

The political ploy till now was to pacify pesky groups with offers of reservations in government service and educational institutions, or provide free power for agricultural production, or sops like free television and laptops at election time.

The post-liberalisation generation cannot be neutralised through such populism. It is not dependent on a paternalistic "mai-baap sarkar" for jobs or education, let alone television sets and laptops. Armed with their own telecommunication gadgets and global credit cards, the "more aspirational, more impatient, more demanding and better-educated" youths, as Sonia Gandhi said, see themselves as citizens of the world where the rule of law has primacy of place. And the laws of the land will gain precedence if only the bureaucracy, and especially the police, can act professionally and not look over their shoulders at the politicians for guidance.

For a larger part of its 127-year-old history, the Congress has been a modernising force which eschewed casteism, communalism and obscurantism. In the recent past, however, it has been swayed by these very factors, which are practised by its opponents, to encourage caste-based quotas and even consider extending them to minorities. But, if these compromises with its principles haven't helped the Congress to regain its influence over "large parts" of the country, as Sonia Gandhi said, the reason is that the voters do not want it to be a clone of the sectarian-minded regional parties. Unless the Congress rediscovers its original vision, it will continue to be in trouble.


Amulya Ganguli is a political analyst. He can be reached at






Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS



More Headlines

MIM's Akbar Owaisi brought back to jail after hospital visit

All eyes on Rahul. But will he oblige?

Pakistan-bashing has become fashionable in India: Envoy

Gang-rape was turning point for us: Delhi Police commissioner

Lalu Prasad reveals Delhi gang-rape victim's name

Dal-bati but no lal maas at all-veg Congress banquet

Know the new India, Sonia advises party

William Shakespeare goes colourfully 'desi'

Obama should visit India again: US think tank

Cars, bikes too now get on Facebook!

When freedom fighters made Mahatma Gandhi cry

LoC incidents won't affect peace process: Khurshid


Top Stories

Know the new India, Sonia advises party

Congress chief Sonia Gandhi Friday urged party leaders to understand the "new India", not to alienate the middle class while honestly assessing its "strengths and weaknesses" as she set the tone for a three-day   »

All eyes on Rahul. But will he oblige?

Dal-bati but no lal maas at all-veg Congress banquet


  Most Read

LoC incidents won't affect peace process: Khurshid

Welcoming the "positive statements" coming from Pakistan for talks to de-escalate tensions along the border, External Affairs Minister Salman Khurshid Friday said the recent incidents won't affect the  »

Lucknow sectarian clashes continue for second day, former BSP MP booked

Sectarian clashes erupted again in the old city areas Thursday during the funeral procession of a youth killed in Wednesday's violence, police said. A former BSP MP and others were booked for their role in the violence. Soon after the body of Shanu was  »

Four arrested for Lucknow violence

Shia, Sunni clash in Lucknow leaves one dead, many injured


  News Pick

Obama should visit India again: US think tank

As President Barack Obama works on his "big part of my plans" for India in his second term, an influential US think tank has made four concrete proposals to advance »

34 hostages, 15 kidnappers killed in Algeria raid

Algerian army helicopters Thursday fired at a petroleum facility where over 40 Western hostages were being held, leaving at least 34 hostages and 15 kidnappers dead, media reports said. The British Petroleum (BP) natural  »

Trinamool's Arabul held for attack on CPI-M's Rezzak

Former Trinamool Congress legislator Arabul Islam was Thursday arrested for allegedly leading attacks against CPI-M leader Abdur Rezzak Mollah and other Marxist activists, police said. A court sent him to five days police custody.   »

SC stops Gujarat court from ruling on Gulberg carnage closure report

The Supreme Court Thursday asked an Ahmedabad court not to pronounce its orders on the closure report filed by the Special Investigation Team (SIT) into the allegations of inaction by Chief Minister Narendra Modi and senior state officials in the Gulberg Society carnage during the 2002 riots.   »

Ehsan Jafri's widow breaks down as she recalls Gulberg Society carnage

SC lifts stay on Gujarat riot cases, bar Gulberg society


Picture of the Day

President Pranab Mukherjee, Union Minister for Communications and Information Technology Kapil Sibal, Union Minister for Minority Affairs K. Rahman Khan and other dignitaries at the release of the Commemorative Postage Stamp on Shaikhul Hind’s “Silk Letter Movement” & 60th Session of Shaikhul Hind’s Silk Letter Movement Centenary, in New Delhi on January 11, 2013.


Recommend the story to your friends



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us


The Funny Side

Education & Career

    Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

© 2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.