More on Ummid: International l National Regional l Politics Business Religion l History l Culture l Education



Muslim groups demand closure of Israeli embassy in India

Jamia Millia invites applications for Civil Services exam coaching

Muslim dominated Malda, Murshidabad send only 31 candidates

Sidelined by the world Israel cries foul, drags India into row

Despite losing legs, she successfully cracked HSC Board

45th time unlucky, Jabbar to sit in Class 10 board exams again

Pune blast probe: ATS fails to arrest 'prime suspect' Samad

Readers recall native language while learning second language

Trinamool Congress sweeps Kolkata Civic Elections


Attack on Freedom Flotilla: Come on Obama, earn your Noble!: When President Barrack Obama ..... Read Full

Israel shows no remorse, says will halt fresh bid to bring aid to Gaza

Muslims in India don’t vote effectively, so are the Muslims in United States: One of the many reasons behind the sufferings ..... Read Full

Country of Immigrants, United States is a WORLD in itself

World not a paradise like Washington: Courtesy, US Foreign Policy


Maharashtra ignores Gafoor, appoints his junior as DGP: Till yesterday Hasan Gafoor was being hinted by none other than state Chief Minister Ashok..... Read Full

Gujarat HC upholds death sentence in Akashardham attack case: The Gujarat High Court on Tuesday upheld the POTA court verdict awarding death sentence .... Read Full

Fed up of militancy: Majority of Kashmiris respond in a survey: Against the prevalent propaganda by the communal forces in  ..... Read Full

'AMU National Centres aimed at providing dignified existence to minorities': Unfolding an elaborate action plan, Aligarh Muslim University   .... Read Full



PM urged to drop P Chidambaram from cabinet : The president of the Indian National League, Mohammed Sualiman, blamed ..... Read Full

Istanbul: A city with skyline specked with minarates and domes: Their impressive minarets and domes dominate the .... Read Full

Majority of Kashmiris against joining Pakistan: Only 2% of residents of Kashmir want to join Pakistan while less than half of them favor independence .... Read Full

Gaza facing a humanitarian disaster: UN expert: Gaza is facing a humanitarian disaster, the spokesman for UN Relief and Works Agency .... Read Full

Demand for Muslim graveyard in Margao remains buried in files: Decade-long demand for an appropriate burial ground in Margao by the Muslim community remains .... Read Full

Sibal, Khurshid differ over minority status to Jamia Milia Islamia: The Ministries of minority affairs and HRD are at loggerheads over .... Read Full


Excommunication of Muslims in Malegaon: Half-baked stories to strengthen stereotype

Friday, June 04, 2010 03:31:31 PM, Ali Imran,

A Masjid, A Mandir and Me: Malegaon, a town in India with more than 70% Muslim population has always been considered as a communally sensitive place....Read Full

Dying Textile Industry: Govt. refusing to lend a helping hand despite repeated pleas: But their demand to delink the subsidy from the bank ....Read Full

Tokenism ruling MMC as people cry for Action: Hence it is not surprising to see the Civic Body resorting to tokenism instead of addressing the real issues....Read Full

Pollution in Malegaon Hazardous emissions no case for MPCB: Blessings though these factories might be for their owners. But for the people living in this part....Read Full

Decisions and Implementations - The GAP widening day by day: Perform or perish. It was the warning given to the new Ministers who took the....Read Full

SSA Funds in Malegaon - Whose purpose are they actually serving?: Instead most of these funds are either lapsed and lay unused or if at all they....Read Full

Such things happen only in Malegaon-Denied the wages, teachers are forced to work in powerloom factories during the night: The life has...Read Full

A Living Hell: Established in 1863 Malegaon Municipal Council till a decade ago was regarded as one of the richest Council in Maharashtra. It was so....Read Full

Tafawut ast mun-I-shunidam-I-man-o-to, Tu bastan-dar, o, man fatahe-bab me shunidam (What you and I hear are different: you hear the sound of closing doors, but I of doors that open)

A Persian couplet that Maulana Abul Kalam Azad choose to use while addressing a gathering of Muslim Youth at the Aligarh Muslim University in 1949. For young Muslims who want to break away from the siege mentality that plagues a bulk of the community, these words spur you on to work for a better tomorrow.

However reading about the ex-communication of five Muslims by a group of Maulvis in Malegaon made me think if the door that leads for a better tomorrow has been shut on the faces of this community. Malegaon over the past four years has become like a second home to me.


Inspite of its stereotyped image as a backward minority dominated town the literacy rate of the city at 65.77 per cent is way better than the Muslim communities literacy levels of 59.1 per cent.


I have met some of the best doctors, thinkers and sensible clerics in this town. The move by the clerics to ex communicates the five individuals for being “Murtads) however came as a huge shock.

Can a town which has regularly churned out SSC, HSC toppers and the largest number of doctors in North Maharashtra make such a mistake.

Interestingly I had met Sharief Cookerwala in 2006, a wiry man with a wispy beard Cookerwala, who runs a road side stall repairing gas cookers, is proficient in the verses of the Geeta as he is with the Koran. He has been holding discourses on the Geeta for sometime. Cookerwala in 2006 did complain about being hauled by the Maulvi’s for his views on Islam but he also claimed that he was living a fairly peaceful life without any trouble from the local community.


Cookerwala now claims that there is a threat to his life. It is indeed deplorable if a man cant speak or do what he feels is right in a free country like ours.

However It is also equally deplorable that a journalist should paint the whole town as being Talibanised without taking the effort to go on the ground and check the details.


Interestingly the same paper had in 2006 done a half-baked story alleging that people were afraid to get their sons or daughters married to residents of Malegaon.

This kind of selective reporting strengthens stereotypes. Malegaon with all its faults has the potential of leading the march of the state’s Muslims towards progress. Some of the best thinkers and academicians hail from this town, by deriding it without checking the facts media is helping in firmly jamming shut the door which leads to progress and a better tomorrow.


Ali Imran is a Mumbai based journalist working with a big media house. This article is his special contribution to that he has written in response to the reports coming in the section of media about the excommunication of 5 Muslims in Malegaon





  Bookmark and Share

Home | Top of the Page

  Comment on this article


E-mail Address:

Write here...







 Home | Contact Us | Disclaimer | Terms of Use | About Us | Feedback

Ummid Business: Advertise with us | Careers | Link Exchange is part of Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and condition mentioned.