Ummid Assistant

Exploring Ramadan: A complete guide in video with English translation

IGNOU trains teachers to develop online courses

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » Views & Analysis

Anna's hyperboles may yet produce a strong Lokpal

Saturday August 20, 2011 11:42:58 AM, Amulya Ganguli, IANS

Related Article

Can a Lokpal Bill end corruption?

People talking about corruption in India usually take a cosmetic approach. The three draft Bills by the Government, Anna Hazare and Aruna Roy represent various hues of that cosmetics. Foe corruption in India is a little deeper than   »

Although the Manmohan Singh government has been battered and bruised by its inept handling of civil society activists, the latter's claim of being harbingers of a second independence movement has also begun to wear thin.

The terms to which Anna Hazare agreed while negotiating with the government while in Tihar Jail - that he will not undertake a fast-unto-death and that his hunger-strike will be medically monitored - represent a climb-down. It is too early to say whether a conditional fast will affect his reputation. But there is little doubt that some of the hype associated with his movement will be deflated.

Not only that. After an initial spell of enthusiasm - the gathering of thousands in various cities, the candlelight processions - contrary voices are gradually being heard. It isn't the politicians alone who have voiced their disquiet over the denigration of parliament, with Lalu Prasad making the point most emphatically. There are a number of others, too, who can also be regarded as members of civil society and are speaking out against Anna Hazare's holier-than-thou attitude even if they endorse his anti-corruption plank.

Again, it is too early to say how all this will pan out if only because India has never seen this kind of popular upsurge earlier. The only comparison can be with Jayaprakash Narayan's movement in 1975, but since it was quickly crushed by the Emergency, there was no knowing how much of a success it would have been.

At the same time, its indirect achievement in ensuring the Congress's defeat in 1977, and especially those of Indira Gandhi and Sanjay Gandhi personally, the two prime movers of the Emergency, was evidence enough of its mass base. But Indira's and Sanjay's return to power in 1980 suggested that the people might have overreacted three years earlier.

The JP story, therefore, was an incomplete one. Whether the Anna Hazare story will be the same or turn out to be different cannot be said for certain. However, two things are clear. For one, the Congress is different today from what it was in the 1970s. Hence its willingness to admit that it made a mistake in treating the activists rather roughly.

For another, India today is also different. Four decades ago, the snail-paced, two-to-three percent 'Hindu rate of growth' made the country a dull and depressing place. The middle class was a silent, minuscule group, which was largely apathetic politically. Presumed by the rest of the world as virtually a Soviet satellite and with the economy in doldrums, the country lacked prestige externally and a sense of direction internally.

Now, the scene is totally different. The middle class - who have enjoyed the fruits of the path-breaking reforms initiated by Manmohan Singh in 1991 as finance minister under then prime minister P.V. Narasimha Rao - is a large, vibrant section comprising 300 million and is hugely active politically as the vociferous support for Anna Hazare by many of its members shows. It is also eager for change because it feels that the government's corrupt image is undermining its external prestige. Since Indian passport holders are now treated far more deferentially abroad than before, the middle class has become conscious of upholding and burnishing the country's reputation.

The third point is somewhat tricky. Although both the Congress and the country have changed from their earlier avatars, the same cannot be said about the images of JP and Anna Hazare. The two reflect one another in their impractical otherworldliness. Just as JP favoured partyless democracy - a phrase which is a contradiction in terms in the context of modern functioning democracies - Hazare, too, does not seem to have much time for elections, the lifeblood of a democracy.

Besides, he is openly contemptuous of them, describing the voters as bikaau or purchasable, who can be bought over with liquor and saris by the MPs and MLAs. This disdain for democracy perhaps explains why the Jan Lokpal of his dreams is a gargantuan institution virtually above parliament, government and judiciary since it will have the authority to investigate and punish all and sundry, from a peon to the prime minister.

Arguably, for all these laudable intentions, Anna has overreached himself and, thereby, given the government an opportunity to trip him up. The reticence of the opposition MPs on Hazare's version of the ombudsman even as they pilloried the government's "draconian" handling of the activists was a noteworthy feature of the parliamentary debate.

However, Hazare's hyperboles may still have their uses, for they are bound to make the government firm up its own Lokpal bill, now before a parliamentary standing committee. This is the salutary outcome of the current tussle since it is likely to produce an effective ombudsman - something which the political class has avoided doing since a Lokpal bill was first introduced in 1968.

(Amulya Ganguli is a political analyst. He can be reached at



Bookmark and Share

Home | Top of the Page



Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS




Top Stories

Hazare leaves jail after three days; Cheers, slogans outside Tihar

ivil society leader Anna Hazare Friday left the Tihar Jail after three days to be welcomed by cheering crowds who had been waiting for hours outside. Hazare, 74, is on day four of   »

Can a Lokpal Bill end corruption?

Anarchy is not the option

Activists divided: For and against Hazare


  Most Read

Shehla Masood murder: MP Govt. agrees for CBI probe

Bowing to the overwhelming demand of Central Bureau of Investigations, (CBI), inquiry into the gruesome broad   »

Needle of suspicion points towards IPS officer

US to let illegal students stay and work

In a move to reform the US immigration system, Washington will stop deporting many students and other illegal immigrants who are not a public safety threat and permit them to work legally. A new federal group will review the 300,000 backlogged deportation cases with an eye toward prosecuting criminals and other high-priority cases  »


  News Pick

Venezuela to pull gold reserves out of US, Europe

Venezuela will remove its international gold reserves from the US and Europe and place them in countries with "solid" economies like China, Russia   »

Kerala to reactivate state-run overseas recruitment arm

After a near-dormant existence for over three decades, the Kerala government has decided to reactivate its overseas recruitment consultancy to tap the lucrative market, Labour Minister Shibu Baby John has said.  »

Dr. Swamy, Friends and Limits of Freedom of Expression

It is not a very easy task to decide as to where the freedom of expression ends and Hate speech begins. A lot of perception about this depends on one’s convictions about the underlying ideologies which are being talked about   »

Can a Lokpal Bill end corruption?

In a move to reform the US immigration system, Washington will stop deporting many students and other illegal immigrants who are not a public safety threat and permit them to work legally. A new federal group will review the 300,000 backlogged   »


Picture of the Day

An artist's impressions of the new expansion of the Grand Mosque in Makkah. The project is launched by Saudi King Abdullah - the Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques, August 19. Regarded as the largest ever expansion of the Grand Mosque of Makkah and costing a whopping SR80 billion, the project after completion will increase the mosque's capacity to more than 2.5 million worshippers. The King dedicated the new expansion to the Islamic world.



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant






About us




Government Schemes










Contact us





      Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

© 2010 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.