Can't blame courts if they try to help poor: Apex court

New Delhi: The Supreme Court has slammed the political executive both at the central and the state level for tardy implementation of welfare schemes and raising the bogey of judicial activism when courts intervene and issues directions.

"In last 63 years, parliament and state legislatures have enacted several laws for achieving the goals set out in the preamble (of the constitution) but their implementation has been extremely inadequate and tardy...."

"The benefit of welfare measures enshrined in those legislations has not reached millions of poor, downtrodden and disadvantaged sections of the society and the efforts to bridge the gap between the haves and have-nots have not yielded the desired result," the court said.

The apex court bench of Justice G.S. Singhvi and Justice Asok Kumar Ganguly said this in their judgment pronounced Monday dismissing an appeal by the Delhi Jal Board challenging a Delhi High Court order.

The high court had directed it to deposit Rs.79,000 with the Delhi High Court Legal Services Committee in addition to Rs.1.71 lakh already paid to the family of sewer cleaner Rajan who died while working.

Speaking for the bench, Justice Singhvi said political arm of the State raises the bogey of judicial over-reach or activism when courts intervene and issue direction for the compliance of welfare laws.

"The most unfortunate part of the scenario" is that whenever judiciary issues direction for the implementation of the welfare statute so that the "right to equality, life and liberty no longer remains illusory for those who suffer from the handicaps of poverty, illiteracy and ignorance" the bogey of judicial activism and judicial over-reach is raised, the court said.

"...a theoretical debate is started by raising the bogey of judicial activism or judicial over-reach and the orders issued for benefit of the weaker sections of the society are invariably subjected to challenge in the higher courts", the judgment said.

"In large number of cases, the sole object of this litigation is to tire out those who genuinely espouse the cause of the weak and poor."

Upholding the high court verdict in the instant case, the judgment said: "What the high court has done by entertaining the writ petition and issuing directions for protection of the persons employed to do work relating to sewage operations is part of its obligation to do justice to the disadvantaged and poor sections of the society."

"We may add that the superior courts will be failing in their constitutional duty if they decline to entertain petitions filed by genuine social groups, NGOs and social workers for espousing the cause of those who are deprived of the basic rights available to every human being, what to say of fundamental rights guaranteed under the Constitution."

Remanding the matter back to the high court for further orders, the judgment said that the appeal by the Delhi Jal Board was also illustrative of how the state apparatus was "insensitive to the safety and well being of those who are, on account of sheer poverty, compelled to work under most unfavourable conditions and regularly face the threat of being deprived of their life".

While directing the listing of the case before the high court in the third week of September, the apex court enhanced the compensation for the family of Rajan by another Rs.3.29 lakh in addition to the amount already paid to his family.





 

 Tweet

Home | Top of the Page

Top Stories

Premature to name terror group behind blasts: Home ministry

The home ministry Wednesday said it would be premature to name the terrorist group behind the serial blasts in Mumbai that killed at least 10 people and left scores injured. "It would  »

Omar wants 'facts', 'not rumours' about Mumbai blasts

Electric circuit found on one dead in terror attack

  Most Read

17 killed in Mumbai blasts, no intelligence inputs: Chidambaram

At least 17 people died in the coordinated terror attack in Mumbai the day before, Home Minister P. Chidambaram said  »

Day after blasts, Mumbaikars venture out boldly

Blockade brings Telangana train traffic to standstill

Rail movement in the Telangana region of Andhra Pradesh came to a standstill Thursday as agitators demanding a separate Telangana state stopped several trains as part of a 12-hour long rail blockade that has virtually snapped rail links of south India with other parts of the country.  »

  News Pick

Gaddafi plans to blow up Tripoli if captured

Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi has a "suicide plan" to blow up the capital city of Tripoli if it comes into the hands of rebels, Russia's special envoy to  »

We know the importance of peace, say Kashmiris

For once, it was not in the news. The Kashmir Valley was quiet Thursday but for people who have seen strife for so many years, the serial bombings in Mumbai were another reminder that terror could achieve nothing   »

Notice to Tamil Nadu Police over daylight murder

The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) Wednesday issued notice to the Tamil Nadu Police over the murder of a man by four others in broad  »

Crowd watches as goons kill man on street

Spate of honour killings shakes up Punjab

Like the horrific honour killings in neighbouring Haryana, Punjab, one of the country's most affluent states, has in the last few months witnessed a surge in the murders of young boys and girls in the name of upholding family honour.  »

Picture of the Day

Defence Minister of Mozambique Filipe Jacinto Nyusi laying wreath at Amar Jawan Jyoti, in New Delhi on June 28, 2011.

(Photo: Fulchand)