English or Konkani: Goa debates on what to use in schools

Sunday March 20, 2011 10:13:40 AM, IANS

Panaji: Lawmakers and parents in Goa are debating whether English or mother tongue Konkani should be the medium of instruction (MOI) in schools upto Class 8.

Education Minister Atanasio Monserrate told the Goa legislative assembly Friday that a policy decision on the MOI issue would be taken by April 8, when the budget session concludes.

The MOI debate has been slowly welling up in Goa over the last couple of years, after the central Right of children to Free and Compulsory Education Act envisaged that the mother tongue should be the medium of instruction for school children up to Class 8.

The issue was raised by Deputy Speaker Mauvin Godinho in the house Friday.

"The poor are sending their children to English medium schools because they believe that English will propel them to excel in their studies. Why, even the Chinese are learning English. Parents whose students are studying in (English medium) schools run by the Archdiocese (Church) are agitated. Why is the government disbursing grants only to Konkani/Marathi schools?" Godinho said.

As per the education department's policy, schools with English as MOI - which includes several privately-run educational institutions and other schools run by the church in Goa - are not entitled to government funding.

Godinho said the policy of debarring "English" schools from availing grants had failed.

"Is Konkani only for the poor to study? Let the parents be given the choice (of deciding which MOI to choose)," Godinho said, with legislators from the ruling Congress backing his demand.

Binar Barros, who has been articulating the concerns of parents and teachers in Goa, said that adoption of Konkani as MOI was like putting the future of their children in danger.

"Figures available between 1991 till date reveal that around two lakh children have suffered because of the imposition of Konkani as a medium of instruction. We aren't expressing apprehension about Konkani," he told IANS.

"If the mother tongue is made the medium of instruction from Class 1-8, it would be harming the future of our children," Binar told IANS.

Calangute legislator Agnelo Fernandes said that MOI politics was virtually an extension of subtle casteist subjugation.

"Should people come out on the streets? High caste people are sending their children for English education and are telling the poor to educate their children in Konkani. Give parents the choice, why should we impose it?" asked Fernandes.

Leader of Opposition Manohar Parrikar of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) said the issue needed to be examined by educationists and advised against a hasty decision.

"This issue is not so casual so as to discuss it during (assembly's) zero hour. It requires deliberation. The right to education must be implemented only after discussion. This is too serious an issue. The government should discuss with the PTAs (parent-teacher associations) and management," Parrikar said in the house.

Monserrate said the government would take a "policy decision on the issue, by the end of the budget session".


 

                                           Home | Top of the Page

Top Stories

Minority Panel chief says can't do much on release of Muslim youths; Khurshid silent

Even as the demand to release the Muslim youths was vociferously raised by Maharashtra State Minority Commission at   »

Maha minority panel to demand Muslim youths' release at National meet

  Jail Bharo Tehreek now looks certain in Malegaon

  Most Read

48 killed as Western forces target Libyan air defence, Gaddafi defiant

At least 48 people were killed and 150 others wounded in air strikes carried out by coalition forces to enforce a UN resolution imposing a no-fly zone over Libya, Xinhua reported Sunday   »

BJP faces WikiLeaks heat on India-US deal

The target of the latest WikiLeaks expose, the BJP Saturday dismissed reports that its leaders had adopted different stands in their public declarations and private conversations on the India-US nuclear deal, and demanded that the diplomatic cables relating to India be probed.   »

  News Pick

Sparks fly when Kashmir's two patriarchs meet in Delhi

It was rare in the two-decade-old troubled history of Kashmir - the two grand old men of the state's political divide sharing the dais for the first time. Predictably, former chief minister Farooq Abdullah and unabashedly   »

Enthusiastic Egyptians line up to vote on constitutional reform

Egyptians formed long queues outside polling stations in Cairo Saturday to vote, for the first time since president  »

 There would have been no revolution without internet: ElBaradei

How Gen Next assist MPs in policy making, research

Uthara Ganesh, 22, always thought being an MP in India was all about making speeches and winning electoral battles. Until she decided to work with one. Her mindset underwent a stark change once she landed up an   »

BJP's leadership vacuum will help Congress

Even as the Congress walks gingerly through a political minefield, fending off the Wikileaks exposures while partially defusing the crises caused by the financial swindles, the Bharatiya Janata Party's (BJP) ability to make full use   »

Can the burqa coexist with the bikini?

Does the burqa symbolise oppression? And the bikini signify liberation? Giving a different viewpoint, laced with humour, experts at a discussion here spoke about how the two do coexist and will continue to do so.  »

Picture of the Day

President of India Mrs. Pratibha Devisingh Patil addressing at the inauguration of the National Festival of Tribal Dances, ‘PRAKRITI’, in New Delhi on March 16, 2011. Union Minister for Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation and Culture, Kum. Selja, Union Minister for Tribal Affairs Kantilal Bhuria and Minister of State for Tribal Affairs Mahadev S. Khandela are also seen.

(Photo: Mukesh Kumar)