Urdu media doubts US claims on Osama killing

Tuesday May 03, 2011 07:53:02 PM, Mohammed Shafeeq, IANS

Hyderabad: India's leading Urdu newspapers Tuesday raised doubts over the manner in which United States claimed to have killed Osama bin Laden in Pakistan.

The Urdu media suspected Osama might have died long ago but the US claim now is an attempt by President Barack Obama to check his falling popularity graph and divert public attention from the weakening economy and domestic issues, including the controversy over his birth certificate.

A few newspapers opined that even after Osama's killing, the US will continue the so- called anti-terror war targeting Muslims around the world.

While most newspapers carried the story with the headline "Osama bin Laden halak (killed)", a few used the words "jaan bahaq (laid down life)".

"Osama bin Laden jaan bahaq" said the headline of Rashtriya Sahara, a leading daily published from 10 cities, including Hyderabad.

Munsif, one of the largest circulated dailies from Hyderabad, also carried the same headline. It went on to say "body dumped into sea, anger sweeps among Islamists".

"Osama bin Laden halak" said Siasat, another leading Urdu newspaper from Hyderabad. Inquilab of Mumbai had a similar headline. It went on to add "body thrown into sea".

Inquilab also carried an editorial titled "Questions over Osama's killing". It said the theory presented about Osama's killing in Pakistan has no logic and hence raised many questions. The editorial referred to many claims made in the past about the killing of Osama including the one made by then Pakistani president Pervez Musharraf.

"It appears Osama died a natural death in 2001 but the US did not announce it so that from time to time, it can take political advantage of his name, tapes and his alleged threats or it is also possible that Osama was killed during war imposed on Afghanistan but it was kept a secret as an alive Osama rather than a dead one was in the US interest," the editorial said.

It added that Osama had died natural or unnatural death much earlier but this was announced now in view of the weakening US economy and Obama's declining popularity.

Rashtriya Sahara carried an article titled "Is a dead Osama bin Laden more dangerous than an alive one?" It also referred to Osama's predictions: "He had said he would not be caught alive and he had also said many like him will born after him. While his first prediction proved true, it remains to be seen whether his second forecast will also prove correct."

"American officials may be happy that their number one enemy has been killed but they may also be worried that even after his death, Osama may get on their nerves.

"His personality was such that while many used to hate him, there were many others who used to call him a selfless hero. People may mourn his death or even get angry about it," the article added.

Etemaad, published from Hyderabad, in its editorial, referred to Obama's statement that the war against terror will not end. "It is obvious that it is aimed against Muslims."

Munsif, in its editorial, recalled that the US had blamed Al Qaeda for 9/11 without investigations and Afghan leader Mullah Omer had asked then US president Geroge Bush to provide evidence against Osama.

"The US never conducted investigations into 9/11 and attacked Afghanistan, which points the needle of suspicion towards the US that it is fighting a war against Islam in the guise of fighting terrorism," it added.

"Now that Osama is killed and Obama is saying the US is not waging a war against Islam, the US should pull out its troops from Afghanistan because it ravaged that country to get him," the editorial said.

(Mohammed Shafeeq can be contacted at m.shafeeq@ians.in)

 

                                           Home | Top of the Page

Top Stories

Osama bin Laden killed in Pakistan: Obama

The world's most wanted terrorist and Al Qaeda founder Osama bin Laden has been killed in Pakistan, US President Barack Obama announced, describing it as a most significant achievement   »

Profile: Osama bin Laden

Text of Obama's speech announcing Osama's killing

Pakistanis shocked over Osama death, angry at US

  Most Read

Live-tweeting on Osama raid, Pakistani becomes celebrity

An Information Technology consultant in a small town in Pakistan has become the latest Twitter celebrity following an all-night live-tweeting session on the sudden appearance of a  »

Aligarh varsity to conduct admission tests as per schedule

Notwithstanding the sine die, the Aligarh Muslim University has decided to conduct all the admission tests as per the notified schedule. In a consultative meeting with Deans of all the faculties   »

AMU campus peaceful, students leaving for home

  News Pick

Search for Arunachal chief minister narrows down

Indian authorities Monday zeroed in on three probable locations to track down the helicopter carrying Arunachal Pradesh Chief Minister Dorjee Khandu   »

35 hours later, Arunachal chief minister still missing

In virtual world, men support castration for rapists

After a judge suggested castration as an alternative punishment for rapists, a group of men in the virtual world have come out in full support through a forum called "Support castration" under the group "True World" on social  »

Fourth round of Bengal polls: Spotlight on Singur, Nandigram

Synonymous with intense peasant protests against the acquisition of farmland, Singur and Nandigram go to polls Tuesday in the fourth phase of West Bengal assembly polls, with the opposition Trinamool Congress seemingly having  »

Dilip Kumar to donate Rs.15 lakh for CINTAA Tower

Dilip Kumar is no more active in films, but ready to lend support for the welfare of the film industry people. The 88-year-old veteran has decided to donate Rs.15 lakh for the construction of one floor in the 16-storey building of  »

Muslim waiter at US hotel told not to reveal name

A Muslim waiter at a New York hotel has said he was told to work under a fake name so that guests would not be scared over his Islamic identity, a media report said. Moroccan-born Mohamed Kotbi, who works at the  »

Picture of the Day

Britain's Prince William and his wife Kate, Duchess of Cambridge (left) wave as they leave Westminster Abbey.

(Photo: AP)