| 
            
              | 
              
              
              FDI vote win is victory of CBI, says opposition 
            
            
            
            Wednesday December 05, 2012 09:12:04 PM, IANS |  
              | 
               | 
 |  
              |  |  
              | 
              New Delhi: The 
              opposition Wednesday dismissed the government's Lok Sabha win on 
              the issue of FDI in multi-brand retail as "victory of the CBI over 
              FDI", targetting the SP and BSP over their respective walkouts.
 The opposition motion against FDI in retail was defeated in the 
              lower house with the UPA garnering 253 votes against the 
              opposition's 218 votes.
 
 Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) senior leader Murli Manohar Joshi 
              said it was a victory of the Central Bureau of Investigation 
              (CBI). Both Samajwadi Party chief Mulayam Singh Yadav and Bahujan 
              Samaj Party supremo Mayawati, who walked out of the Lok Sabha 
              ahead of the voting, have CBI cases against them.
 
 "It was all by arrangement... This is a victory of CBI not FDI," 
              said Joshi.
 
 BJP leader Sushma Swaraj, who spoke forcefully against allowing 
              FDI in multi-brand retail, said the motion's defeat "is a moral 
              victory for us".
 
 Targetting the BSP and SP for its walkout, she said: "The people 
              who gave speeches with us but voted with them, it exposes the 
              difference between their words and actions. They have supported 
              FDI indirectly," she said.
 
 Trinamool Congress leader Sudip Bandhyopadyay said: "It's not a 
              victory for the Congress but a defeat because it shows they are 
              much behind the majority mark. It shows once again that the 
              government is in minority. The SP and BSP helped the government, 
              they have helped earlier as well. But the Congress should not be 
              overwhelmed with their support."
 
 Communist Party of India leader Gurudas Dasgupta termed it a 
              "defeat of the government as it has no majority in the house. It 
              got the people absented in the house under influence," adding 
              "making a deliberate attempt to make people absent is a criminal 
              offence."
 
 RSP's Prashant Kumar Majumdar said: "The government managed to win 
              the vote on FDI due to CBI phobia. The SP and BSP who spoke 
              against FDI in the house have been exposed by walking out from a 
              vote."
 
 SUCi's Tarun Mandal said: "The speaker did not allow smaller 
              parties to speak in favour of the motion."
 
 Janata Dal-United leader and Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar 
              said in Patna that FDI in multi brand retail is neither good for 
              farmers nor for people of the country.
 
 "Farmers and people are not going to be benefited by the FDI in 
              multi brand retail. Small shopkeepers will be badly hit and it 
              will create more unemployment," Nitish Kumar said, adding that the 
              UPA was "hell bent on bringing FDI in multi brand retail to make 
              MNCs happy".
 
 
 
 
 
 
               
 
 
              
 |  
        | 
            
            
            Home |
            
            
            Top of the Page 
  |  
        | 
 |  
              |  |  
              |  |  
              |  |  
              |  |  
              | 
               |  
              |  |  | 
            
              | 
            
          
            
              | 
               |  
              | 
            
             |  
              | 
I |  
              |  |  |  
              | 
              
              More Headlines |  
              | 
            
              
              Independent MP withdraws FEMA motion |  
              | 
            
              
              India ranks 94 in list of corrupt nations |  
              | 
            
              
              Politics of hatred doesn't pay: Babri Masjid 
              demolition eyewitness Mark Tully |  
              | 
            
              
            The Babri morass: How did it all transpire
              
              |  
              | 
            
              
              20 
              years after Babri razing, India has moved on |  
              | 
              
              
              Lok Sabha disrupted over Lalu's remarks |  
              | 
              
              
              Declare Sir Syed birthplace a national heritage site: AMU alumni |  
              | 
            
              
              'Humans gobbling up Earth at alarming pace' |  
              | 
              
              
              
              Remove liquor vends from religious towns: 
              Haryana khaps |  
              | 
            
              
              US lawmakers back Zakia Jafri, other Gujarat 
              riot victims |  
              | 
            
              
              Post 'Love Jihad' caste assertion in Tamil 
              Nadu |  
              |  |  
              | 
              
             Top Stories |  
              | 
             
               
              
              
              FDI Debate: SP, BSP walk out of Lok Sabha 
              before voting 
              The Samajwadi Party (SP) and the Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) 
              Wednesday walked out of the Lok Sabha before the voting on foreign 
              investment in multi-brand retail.
              
              
              » 
            
            
             Government braces for vote on FDI in Lok 
              Sabha 
            
            
             Opposition, allies slam FDI in parliament 
              debate |  
              |  |  
              | 
              
             Most Read |  
              | 
             
             East Jerusalem settlements: World outrage against Israel on the rise 
            Australia on Tuesday became the latest country to summon its Israeli 
            ambassador to convey concerns over plans to build new settlements in 
            east Jerusalem and the West Bank. Australia  » 
            
            
             United Nations tells Israel to join NPT, let in nuclear inspectors 
             |  
              | 
              
              
              US 
              lawmakers seek US visa ban for Narendra Modi 
              Ahead of 
              the Gujarat elections, a bipartisan group of 25 lawmakers and the 
              Coalition Against Genocide have called for a continued visa ban 
              for Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi for his role in the 2002 
              Gujarat riots. The group, led by Republican House of 
              Representatives members 
            
            
            
             » |  
              |  |  
              | 
              
             News Pick |  
              | 
            
            
               Delhi hunger strike against arrests of Muslim youths suspended 
              An eight-day 
              hunger strike here to protest "victimisation of Muslim youths in 
              the name of fighting terrorism" was suspended on Prime Minister  » 
               |  
              | 
               Hold 
              cash transfer in Himachal, Gujarat: EC to government 
              Even as the Election Commission (EC) 
              Tuesday expressed its concern over the government's announcement 
              of direct cash transfer and asked it
              
            
            
               » |  
              | 
              
              
              Congress manifesto for Gujarat promises free 
              laptops, tablets 
              The Congress 
              Tuesday roped in Sheila Dikshit, its three-time Delhi Chief 
              Minister, as star campaigner for the crucial Gujarat assembly 
              polls and unveiled its manifesto with a series of promises, 
              including free laptops and tablets  » |  
              | 
              
              
              GMR row: Maldives minister calls Khurshid to pacify India 
              In an 
              outreach diplomacy aimed at pacifying India, Maldives' Foreign 
              Minister Abdul Samad Abdullah Tuesday rang up External Affairs 
              Minister Salman Khurshid and explained 
            
            
             » 
            
            
             India freezes aid to Maldives, ties under stress |  
              |  |  
          | 
                    Picture of the Day |  
          | 
                   |  
          | 
                  President Pranab Mukherjee, Prime 
                  Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh and Chairperson, National Advisory 
                  Council Mrs Sonia Gandhi with the winner of Indira Gandhi 
                  Prize for Peace, Disarmament and Development Luiz Inacio Lula 
                  da Silva, former President of the Federative Republic of 
                  Brazil, at Rashtrapati Bhavan, in New Delhi on November 22, 
                  2012. |  
              |  |  
              | Recommend the story to 
      your friends |  
              |  |  
              |  |  
              |  |  |  |