Ummid Assistant

Applications open for Manmohan scholarship at Cambridge

IIM-Trichy to offer short courses too at Chennai centre

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home Views & Analysis

Narendra 'Dabangg' Modi is his own worst enemy

Saturday December 15, 2012 06:49:27 PM, Amulya Ganguli, IANS

What is curious about the Gujarat elections is that although the outcome is not in doubt - the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) is expected to win - there is an element of tension related to its success.

The reason is the speculation about Narendra Modi's future. In this personality-centric battle, it is not enough for the BJP only to win; it has to secure more than 117 out of the 182 assembly seats, which was its tally in 2007.

If it crosses this number, then the conjectures about Modi's prime ministerial ambition will be strengthened. But, if the party merely reaches the figure or, worse still, falls short, then the Gujarat strongman's detractors in the BJP and outside will have a field day, claiming that his appeal has begun to fade.

Although, normally, 117 is a comfortable winning score, the scene in Gujarat is not a normal one. For a start, there is excessive hype about the chief minister to the exclusion of the party. However, since the central feature of this focus is the possibility of his emergence as the BJP's prime ministerial candidate, he has to outrun his political rivals by a considerable distance.

Hence the tension, which was evident in Modi's last-minute effort to play the Muslim card by inviting the well-known cricketer, Irfan Pathan, to be present by his side at a public rally. For a man who was wary of fielding a single Muslim candidate for the elections lest it annoyed his hard-core Hindu supporters, the courting of the cricketer betrayed a certain nervousness.

The uneasiness is explained by the fact that no one knows more than Modi about the restricted nature of his base. Both in Gujarat and the rest of the country, his appeal is confined primarily to the communal-minded Hindus of the urban middle class. The support which is invariably voiced for Modi in drawing room conversations is mainly from this group.

But those who are outside its ambit include liberal Hindus, the minorities - Muslims as well as Christians - and large sections of the backward castes and Dalits. Unlike Atal Behari Vajpayee, whose engaging personality crossed political and regional barriers, Modi's virtual equation of himself with Gujarat - any criticism of him is projected as an attack on the state's 'asmita' (pride) - further restricts his appeal.

Moreover, by cultivating an aggressive personality, Narendra "Dabangg" Modi, as he was called in a television programme, may impress his close followers, but it is a disadvantage for the pan-Indian image of a potential prime minister, which requires an element of sophistication. Instead, Modi comes across as the grumpy head of a patriarchal household.

He has also undermined his own cause by the coarseness he displayed by describing Shashi Tharoor's wife as a "Rs.50,000-crore girlfriend" for her supposed links to an Indian Premier League scandal before her marriage and by questioning Sonia Gandhi's travel expenses for her medical treatment abroad.

It is no secret that the 2002 riots remain the main stumbling block where his ambitions are concerned. Modi himself realised this soon after riding on a communal wave to his 2002 victory when the BJP won 127 seats - its highest ever tally.

The realisation was evident in his abrupt switch from the communal atmosphere to the need for industrial progress.

Since he is not an economist known for his pro-development views, the transition from the anti-minority politics of a saffron 'pracharak' (preacher) to that of development smacks of an artificial ploy.

It is as much a cynical manoeuvre as his 'sadbhavna' fasts in aid of social harmony during which he refused to wear the headgear offered by Muslim clerics.

It is the distrust of his pretensions to have turned over a new leaf which remains a weapon in the hands of his opponents in the BJP and the National Democratic Alliance (NDA). Of them, Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar has been the most vocal presumably because he knows that his appeal is much wider than Modi's since it encompasses the minorities.

On the other hand, Modi's use of the word, "mian", in describing Congress leader Ahmed Patel as Ahmedmian when the customary Gujarat term is Ahmedbhai, showed that his communal instincts remain intact.

Hence, Nitish Kumar's opposition to the BJP's idea of naming the NDA's prime ministerial candidate after the 2014 general elections since he suspects that the BJP will then spring Modi's name on the coalition's unwilling constituents. If the Bihar chief minister wants the issue to be clarified now, it is because he is aware that there is no way for the BJP to propose Modi at present since it will lead to the NDA's disintegration and thereby hand over an electoral victory to the Congress on a platter.

Moreover, to avoid this possibility, those within the BJP who nurture prime ministerial aspirations themselves - the never-say-die octogenarian L.K. Advani and the eloquent Sushma Swaraj - will then throw their hats in the ring.

In a way, therefore, it is immaterial whether the BJP gets 117 seats or more, since any boost to Modi's prospects of moving out of Gujarat will spell doom for the NDA.


Amulya Ganguli is a political analyst. He can be reached at





Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS



More Headlines

$45,500 to change last name

Jamia Millia Islamia to set up human rights cell

Two Mumbai University professors arrested for molestation

India announces $1 million to Myanmar's troubled Rakhine state

Palestinians celebrate the unity between Hamas and Fatah

Shooting reported at US school

Rajasthan official retains post in first right to recall vote

Moscow college to ask god for 'good reputation'

Government to give 25 million LED bulbs to BPL households

Anti-quota bill strike paralyses work in Uttar Pradesh

More reforms and some 'bitter medicine' on the anvil


Top Stories

Difficult steps needed to revive economy: PM

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh Saturday said that the steps the government had taken recently on the economic front were "only the beginning of a process to revive  

More clarity on FDI in pharma sector soon: PM

More reforms and some 'bitter medicine' on the anvil


  Most Read

Tearful Obama leads US mourning for 28 school terror deaths

US President Barack Obama wiped tears from his face, choked on his words and spoke of his grief as authorities  

School shootings in US claim over 100 lives in 20 years

UGC checks 53 private varsities, finds only five 'in order'

Only five of 53 private universities inspected by the University Grants Commission (UGC) had been found to be in order, Human Resource Development (HRD) Minister M.M. Pallam Raju said Friday. Fifty-three of the total 145 private universities had been inspected, the minister said while replying  


  News Pick

India announces $1 million to Myanmar's troubled Rakhine state

India Friday announced assistance of $1 million towards relief in Myanmar's Rakhine state which was rocked by widespread ethnic clashes leaving thousands displaced. The aid  

Rajasthan official retains post in first right to recall vote

In accordance with the Rajasthan Municipal Act, 2009 -- that gives the voter the right to recall -- people of Mangrol Nagar Palika (municipality) in Baran district, 300 km from Jaipur, voted in the  

Anti-quota bill strike paralyses work in Uttar Pradesh

Work at most state government offices was paralysed for the second day Friday as employees protested the move for reservation in  

Rehman Malik in India, new visa regime to begin

Pakistan Interior Minister Rehman Malik arrived here Friday on a long discussed three-day visit, the highlight of which is expected to be the implementation of a liberalized visa regime agreed 

Rehman Malik invites Indian PM to visit Pakistan

The business route to South Asian integration


Picture of the Day

Tri Service Chiefs paying homage at Amar Jawan Jyoti, India Gate on the occasion of Navy Day in New Delhi on December 04, 2012.


Recommend the story to your friends



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us


The Funny Side

Education & Career

    Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.