Ummid Assistant

Indian students in Germany need not pay to study: Envoy

Microsoft offers tech courses to Indian academia

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home Views & Analysis

Telecom debacle: Caught between presumptive loss and affordable services

Wednesday November 21, 2012 12:50:20 PM, Arvind Padmanabhan, IANS

Related Article

SC slams centre over 2G auction

The government Monday came under fire for not complying with the Supreme Court's order to auction the entire spectrum that became available following the cancellation of 122 2G licences in 22 circles in February. "We were very unfairly 

Government, Congress question CAG over 2G loss

2G auction results not surprising: Frost & Sullivan

No scoring points, we'll auction airwaves again: Sibal

Muted response to 2G spectrum auction

The debacle witnessed in the latest round of auctions of precious airwaves for India's telecom sector where close to half the spectrum on offer went unsold is another rap on the knuckles of the country's official auditor and a lesson again for the government.

The question, naturally, being asked is: Where is that presumptive loss of Rs.1.76 lakh crore, or around $32 billion going by an exchange rate of 55 rupees to a dollar, which the Comptroller and Auditor General of India had so sensationally estimated?

There is no denying the fact that the government got it all wrong in the manner in which it handed out 122 licences and related spectrum to new telecom players in 2008 which was later ordered cancelled by the Supreme Court, as it found the process followed wanting.

But what the government actually got from the latest auction of the airwaves of 1,800 MHz spectrum in 18 circles was just Rs.17,343 crore ($3.14 billion) -- Rs.9,407.6 crore ($1.75 billion) and a one-time fee of Rs.7,936 crore ($1.44 billion).

Just 10 percent of that startling figure is mentioned as presumptive loss.

To be charitable to the official auditor, its report had presented several scenarios and said presumptive loss could be estimated at between Rs.57,000 crore ($10.3 billion) and Rs.1.76 lakh crore. But even the lower end of that estimate has proved to be fictional.

What has happened in the interim?

In the case of auction of airwaves two years ago for third generation (3G) telephony and broadband services, the government did get a whopping Rs.106,219 crore ($19.3 billion). But the high price took its toll on subscriber accumulation as the fee charged had to be high.

A report by Wireless Intelligence, a global authority on data related to the telecom sector, said India's 3G connection base was estimated at a mere 33 million in the first quarter of 2012, as compared to the total telecom subscriber base of around 900 million.

In the case of broadband, too, the subscriber base stands at a mere 15 million.

Clearly, it is the customer who has suffered. India has, indeed, come a long way since the 1980s when one needed proximity to someone in authority to get a telephone connection. None of that today. The subscriber base stands at 937 million, which is no mean achievement.

But a much better technology -- read 3G and broadband services, as opposed to second generation (2G) telephony -- at affordable prices is also something which telecom subscribers must be entitled to. Particularly when airwaves are scarce.

Therefore, in hindsight, the government has got it wrong this time as well.

Harping on the erroneous calculations of the official auditor will not help any longer, especially after the Supreme Court clearly said policy-making was the executive's sole preserve and that even the judiciary had no role to play in this regard.

The government, led by Communications Minister Kapil Sibal, says the combined value of unsold spectrum is Rs.62,000 crore ($11.2 billion) at this realised price. Even if half of that is secured, it will be close to the target of Rs.40,000 crore ($7.25 billion).

Is that the point? Not at all. The executive scored a point -- that calculations by the official auditor had no basis. But what is in store is a more glaring scenario. That is the threat of a 30-40 percent hike in telecom tariff due to high spectrum cost.

This will bode ill for telecom penetration in India where the bulk of the subscribers in terms of numbers are low-end users. At a larger level, it will affect growth, as studies show that a nation's output expands one percent if telecom penetration rises 10 percent.

The health of the industry is equally important -- millions of people are employed by the telecom companies and billions of dollars of public money is riding on them. There is also the question of nation's credibility among foreign investors.

Clearly, the high reserve price fixed for the latest auction has not worked. What else would explain an absolute lack of interest among telecom players for Delhi and Mumbai circles, the two most lucrative areas in the country for telecom revenues.

The government certainly needs to balance its policy, weighing the options between the need for resources and prevention of irrational bidding on the one hand, and ensuring market-led fair price for airwaves and affordable telecom services on the other.

The best part in all this is that the myth of high presumptive loss has been broken and even the Supreme Court has paved the way for the adoption of right policy, without the lingering fear of a future reprimand. But the government has to show maturity!


Arvind Padmanabhan is executive editor-business with IANS. The views expressed in this column are personal. He can be reached at





Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS



More Headlines

Powerloom weavers burn electricity bills, protest over tariff hike intensifies

Two Hamas TV cameramen killed in Gaza strike

Kasab hanged in Pune jail

BJP disapproves of Yashwant Sinha's remarks on Gadkari

Indian scientists unravel secrets behind hospital infections

Israeli Gaza operation to end Tuesday: Egypt

Israeli air raid on Gaza is state terrorism: Pakistan parliament

Nationwide protest, Parliament march to protest arrests of Muslim youths

Would jailing official make you work, HC asks Bangalore civic body

AIADMK to vote against FDI in retail

Speaker to decide on FDI debate: Kamal Nath


Top Stories

Kasab hanged in Pune jail

Ajmal Amir Kasab, the lone surviving Pakistani terrorist responsible for the 2008 Mumbai terror attack, was hanged at Pune's Yerawada Jail Wednesday morning, Maharashtra Home Minister R.R. Patil said.  

Had Kasab not been caught, terrorists might have passed as Indian Muslims: SC

Supreme Court upholds Kasab's death sentence

Kasab should be sent to gallows: Pak Interior Minister


  Most Read

INDIA: State legitimise a hate propagandist

Bal Thackerey is no more. His funeral attracted lakhs of people. Mumbai remained shut for so many days. It is time to sit and ponder over what  

Bal Thackeray: Identity Politics to the Fore

Action after Katju's reaction:

9 arrested for vandalising Palghar clinic

It was unfair, Shaheen Dadha who was arrested for posting a comment on Facebook after Shiv Sena 

CPI-M blasts Shiv Sena, demands action against Palghar police officials

Girls' arrest for questioning Mumbai shutdown: Katju e-mail forces govt. to order probe


  News Pick

Nationwide protest, Parliament march against arrests of Muslim youths

Backed by over a dozen NGOs and activists belonging to various student organisations, Students Islamic Organisation (SIO) is organising a nationwide  

Nearly 71 percent of Indian elders compelled to work: Survey

The survey, partnered with many other organisations, noted that 71 percent elderly work due to economic necessity and not by choice, and that there is a close link between current 

Free speech takes a back seat: Pro-Israel group demands Hamas tweet ban

A Christian pro-Israel group has kicked off an online campaign demanding that microblogging site Twitter ban members of Hamas from using the service, a media report said. The group, Christians United for Israel (CUFI), hoped to drum up support from more than its 1 million members amid an ongoing 

Congress, BJP in close contest for tribal votes in Gujarat

As Gujarat gets ready to go to the polls next month, the closest contest is going to be perhaps over the hilly and densely forested eastern 


Picture of the Day

President Pranab Mukherjee at the National Education Day 2012 function to commemorate the birth anniversary of Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, in New Delhi on November 11, 2012.

(Photo: Sanjiv Misra)


Recommend the story to your friends



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us


The Funny Side

Education & Career

    Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.