Ummid Assistant

Mumbai NGO, top experts join hands to train students for civil services exams

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » Views & Analysis

Secularism and BJP’s Dilemmas

Friday October 12, 2012 08:55:56 PM, Ram Puniyani

Putting on masks with changing times are the compulsions of electoral politics for many parties, more so with a party like Bhartiya Janta Party. BJP so far has been doing this with great amount of ease, but lately its dilemmas are increasing in intensity due to its track record in the political arena during last two decades. One such attempt to change gears or put on a new mask was attempted by L.K. Advani in the recently held BJP executive in Delhi (Sept 2012). Mr. Advani in the speech which was circulated had written about "re-projecting the party's commitment to secularism" in his valedictory function speech. While speaking he stumbled as he was face to face with something which BJP does not like in the real sense, secularism, and so he skipped this S word in his spoken speech.

To begin with recent things, it is from last few months that Neetish Kumar has been saying that NDA should have a leader with a secular image. His hint was to oppose the claims of Mr. Narendra Modi, who is a strong candidate for the post of PM, for BJP and thereby of NDA. Neetish Kumar with his own electoral compulsions has been avoiding Mr. Modi, not touching him even with a barge pole. Since Kumar and other allies are very crucial for BJP to come to power, BJP has been in two minds about projecting Modi as the PM candidate. As such also BJP had a complex calculation while dealing with the issue of secularism and Indian state.

BJP is at one level the political wing of RSS, in which RSS trained swyamsevaks are in the lead with some non-RSS background leaders also scattered here and there. Still the primary control of BJP is with the RSS trained swayamsevaks. In turn BJP’s political directions are controlled by the patriarch, RSS, which takes most of the crucial decisions about BJP policies. It is not too far back that Nitin Gadkari was imposed on BJP as the President, and then making exception to the rule he was ‘re-elected’ as the President mainly due to the dictates of RSS. Earlier also there are examples galore about the RSS determining the direction of BJP in the main. It’s also true that within the given parameters, BJP does have some autonomy also, but that relates to mundane affairs not in the major policy making.

The major brunt of campaigning for BJP is also done by the RSS volunteers, who are the major bulwark of BJP political electoral machine. All the top leaders of BJP, from Vajpayee, Advani, Murli Manohar Joshi, Narendra Modi, Arun Jaitly and Nitin Gadkari are the swayamsevaks trained in the RSS shakhas. For them, RSS has the primacy over any other thing and this gets reflected times and over again. Once Vajpayee, when he was Prime Minister, was speaking in the gathering of NRIs in Staten Island in US. He exhibited his primary loyalty to RSS by saying that he may be the Prime Minister, but more than that he is the swayamsevak of RSS, a right, which nobody can snatch from him. When Advani in an effort to make an image changeover from the Babri mosque demolisher to the potential PM candidate, went on to praise Jinnah and his 11th August 1947 Speech in Pakistan, RSS immediately put the reins of control and Advani was immediately marginalized from BJP leadership, a ground he has been trying to regain by various means, to no avail. Similarly when the previous avatar of BJP, Bhartiya Jansangh had dissolved itself to merge in the Janata Party, in the aftermath of dreaded emergency, its leadership broke the Janata party and re-emerged as Bhartiya Janata Party. The issue was that the socialists in Janata party had demanded that the Jana Sangh faction cannot have duel membership of Janata party as well as RSS. This faction rather than severing relation with RSS promptly broke the Janata party and came out.

RSS is primarily committed to the agenda of Hindu Rashtra, Hindu nation, a concept parallel to the concept of Islamic nation, which had become the base of Pakistan. Now the paradox for BJP is that it has to come to power through an electoral process, in a country with diversity in religion and culture. It does want to impose Hindu nation but that is not possible without capturing power in the centre. For capturing power they have to adopt the norms of electoral politics and play the ‘vote bank ‘politics as other parties do. The aim has been first to polarise the Hindu votes and then to appeal to votes of other sections of society. Polarization of section of Hindu votes has been achieved by BJP through Babri demolition, Post demolition riots and Gujarat carnage. Having achieved this, for winning over the dalits and other weaker sections the strategy is to co-opt them through mechanisms of social engineering through programs like “Samajik Samrasta (collaboration between castes) and Hindutvisation of Adivasis through programs like Ghar vapasi (returning home) for Adivasis, telling them they are Hindus who had to flee to the forests due to the intimidation of Muslim kings, so they must return to Hindu fold. In the same effort for winning over Adivasis, the tribal areas witnessed anti Christian violence.

As for as Muslim, the biggest religious minority is concerned they have given mixed signals. Having given the signal to section of Hindus, the challenge has been to win over the Muslims’ votes as well, as all Hindus will not vote for BJP at any time. So the first effort was to project Vajpayee as the leader, as Vajpayee was a most suitable mask. It was very part of his persona, to the extent of people went on to say that he is the ‘right man in the wrong party’. To oppose Congress Advani coined the word pseudo secularism for the policies of Congress. Surely Congress is no secular angel, as it has compromised with communal forces and in the game of vote bank politics, has played the role of ‘opportunist communal’ party. This is in contrast to BJP which is party programmed for Communalism. After Vajpayee period BJP has been trying to put on a secular mask. But the job is not easy and they have to play the role close to that of a trapeze artist. Not to lose polarised vote bank of Hindus and at the same time to win over Muslims votes.

It is in this direction that Bangaru Laxaman once said that Muslims are the ‘blood of our blood and flesh of our flesh’. Advani tried this by offering secular Jinnah comments and now this gem from him is again an attempt in that direction. Same Advani in part of his speech, which he did not read, said, “We should, with full conviction, reassure our brethren belonging to the minority communities that we brook no discrimination or injustice in dealing with different sections of our diverse society.” Who will believe that except the novice!

Whether such a new mask will cut any ice with the Muslim community, who by now has realized that irrespective of its utterances BJP is anti minority to the core, and makes secular noises just for effect. Even their formulation of secularism ‘justice to all and appeasement of none’, gives a clear message that Muslims cannot expect any affirmative action, which a battered community needs for its upliftment.

Today while the communal parties have polarized the communities along religious lines, what is needed is a principled politics along secular lines. Those tied to the apron strings of the organization with the ideology which wants to bring in Hindu Nation cannot be secular. Their masks are a mechanism to put wool in people’s eyes. We need to recall the Hindu values of father of the nation, Gandhi. Despite holding Hinduism as his religion he never indulged in the politics of Hindu religious identity. BJP indulges in issues like Babri mosque, holy cow, Ram Setu, Amarnath Yatra, etc. something which is the basic hallmark of Advani and company. It is the use of religion’s identity for political goals. Gandhi followed religion as morality and BJP is using ‘religions’ identity for political goals’, this is what communalism is, and this is what the hallmark of BJP is.





Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS



More Headlines

Number of women in Indian parliament lower than global average: UN

BJP wants memorial for innocents killed in Punjab terrorism

British village blacklisted after postman bitten by fleas

Congress MP flaunts gun at toll plaza, party seeks report

Briton held for plotting terror attack on airport

Schoolkids to embark on roller skates marathon

Parliament lost 151 hours during monsoon session

45,000 British students to retake exams

PM-appointed panel favours lifting curbs on sugar sector

PM for maintaining fine balance between RTI, privacy

A non-stick chewing gum that is biodegradable

India, China slowdown pulls down Asia


Top Stories

New policy should not make medicines costly: SC

Protecting the people's interest, the Supreme Court Thursday told the government that medicines should continue to be available at reasonable prices even after   »

Decision on new drug pricing policy by mid-November

US pushing India to hike cancer drug price


  Most Read

Parliament lost 151 hours during monsoon session

Sloganeering, boycotts, walkouts and disruptions in the monsoon session of parliament led to 151 of the scheduled 206 work hours being wasted, according to responses to a Right to Information  »

PM for maintaining fine balance between RTI, privacy

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh Friday called for fine balance between right to information and right to privacy, an issue that cropped up after Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi sought details of Congress chief Sonia Gandhi's foreign travel bills, which include those for health reasons  »


  News Pick

Congress MP flaunts gun at toll plaza, party seeks report

Congress MP from Porbandar, Vitthalbhai Radadiya is facing the heat for brandishing a gun at a toll plaza in Vadodara Thursday night. The party's central leadership Friday sought a report on »

BJP wants memorial for innocents killed in Punjab terrorism

While the controversy lingers on over construction of a memorial for those killed inside the Golden Temple complex in the 1984 Operation Bluestar, the BJP Friday demanded a memorial  »

Fond of sharing porn online, MMS? Get ready to land in jail

Sharing porn or obscene videos online or through multimedia messaging services (MMS) may soon attract a prison term up to seven years and a maximum fine of Rs.500,000, the government proposed Thursday. These stringent punishments are part of the amendments proposed  »

Setback for riot victims, Britain ends no contact with Modi policy

In a severe blow to the victims of the 2002 Gujarat riots who are fighting for justice since more than a decade, Britain has ended its official no-contact policy with Gujarat after the 2002 riots and will  »


Picture of the Day

Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh presenting the trophy for the best branch of CBI to M.S. Khan, SP, CBI, ACB, Bhubaneswar at the 19th Conference of CBI and State Anti-Corruption Bureaux, in New Delhi on October 10, 2012.



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us




    Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

© 2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.