Ummid Assistant

Applications open for Manmohan scholarship at Cambridge

Opportunities for Indian students in US

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home National

Rural employment guarantee scheme may have adverse impact: Study

Wednesday February 13, 2013 07:30:20 PM, IANS


Hyderabad: The Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act, enacted in 2005, may be destroying enterprise in rural areas and creating an army of unskilled labourers unfit for employment elsewhere, finds a new study.

The study, undertaken in 100 villages of Medak district in Andhra Pradesh and funded by the Consultative Group to Assist the Poorest (CGAP) of the World Bank and Ford Foundation revealed that casual labour, which the rural employment guarantee scheme is creating, may deter long-term growth.

While describing MGNREGA as a good scheme to put money into the hands of the very poor in the short run, the study advocated the need to implement it in a way that does not hamper enterprise.

It found that the higher wages under the Act had increased the cost of labour for many enterprises, including agriculture.

The conclusions were reached after a three-year-long Ultra Poor Programme (UPP) failed to show any impact in India, while similar pilot projects in countries like Pakistan, Bangladesh, Haiti, Peru, Ethiopia, Yemen, Ghana and Honduras funded by the same organisations yielded good results.

Under the UPP, aimed at lifting ultra poor households out of extreme poverty, $357 (about Rs.18,000) was spent on each of the 3,485 ultra poor members.

Shamika Ravi, an assistant professor in economics and public policy at the Indian School of Business (ISB) Wednesday shared with the media the outcome of the first complete evaluation study worldwide.

The NGO wing of Swayam Krishi Sangam implemented the scheme, under which targeted individuals chose micro enterprises like buffalo, goat or sheep rearing, and poultry farms, telephone booths, tailoring shops, grocery shop, tea stalls and horticulture nurseries.

The people chosen for such enterprises were offered all services, including training and stipend to meet the expenses.

"After three years we found that there is no net impact in terms of income, consumption and asset accumulation. What was worse, more than half of the people to whom such assistance was offered had sold their assets and gone back to casual labour under the government scheme," she said.

"Enterprise was not giving them anything over and above daily wages. Running an enterprise is not profitable anymore," Ravi added.

The implementation of the UPP started in 2007, around the same time when NREGS was launched; although the act was passed in 2005, it was implemented two years later.

National Sample Survey data also shows that between 2004-05 and 2009-10, real rural wages increased 27 percent across the country while in Andhra Pradesh, where NREGS implementation is far better, the increase is 38 percent.

"Doing casual labour can't be the way. People eventually want regular income," Ravi said, suggesting that NREGS be implemented in a way which allows enterprise to thrive.

Terming NREGS a political and not an economic decision, she, however, said the programme should continue as India has a very large number of very poor people.

"The problem is when it gets too political. There is too much upward pressure to increase number of working days and the wages, especially before elections," she said, and suggested that work under the programme should be restricted to 100 days a year so that rural poor who don't get work during the summer are provided employment.





Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS


More Headlines

Nursery admissions not under Right to Education purview, court told

Ex Maldives Pres Nasheed takes sanctuary at Indian High Commission

'Middle East has lost 144 cubic km of water'

India braces for BJP-Congress electoral battles

Valentine's Day market in India pegged at Rs.15 bn

India's universities crying for better leadership

Russian parliament passes anti-smoking bill

Global outrage against North Korea nuclear test

Afzal's family says no to Tihar visit, wants body back

SC fumes over sex tests, female foeticide

Italian chopper deal: India orders probe after CEO's arrest


Top Stories

Nasheed takes sanctuary at Indian High Commission

Former Maldives president Mohamed Nasheed, who once held a cabinet meeting under water to highlight global warming, took refuge at the Indian High Commission here   

Nasheed disappointed with India, says Maldives ex-foreign minister

Resigned almost at gunpoint, says ousted Maldives President Nasheed


  Most Read

Italian chopper deal: India orders probe after CEO's arrest

India Tuesday ordered a probe into the $750 million deal for 12 VVIP AgustaWestland helicopters following the arrest of the chief of its parent company - Italy's Finmeccanica on corruption charges in the contract.  

Antony seeks report on pay-off in Italian chopper deal

Why Sir Syed loses and Allama Iqbal wins in Pakistan

For every 19th century Muslim intellectual, including Sir Syed and the Allama, the outstanding challenge of the time was to understand the ascendancy of western civilisation and the apparently   


  News Pick

Global outrage against North Korea nuclear test

Highly secretive North Korea revealed Tuesday it had conducted a third nuclear test, drawing condemnation from around the world and prompting South Korea to put its  

North Korea conducts third n-test

As Tripura goes to polls, spotlight on 'poorest CM'

He washes his clothes every morning, has just over Rs.10,000 in his name and owns neither house, mobile nor car. Tripura's Manik Sarkar is probably India's poorest chief minister and that rare politician whose honesty is 

Scientists brace for a close peek at asteroid

Indian scientists will join their counterparts globally for a rare celestial event scheduled for the night of Feb 15-16 -- the passing of an asteroid very close to Earth, around 28,000 km away, and visible with ordinary  

Britain census shows 37% rise in Muslim population

The exact figure of Muslim immigration living in Britain has been revealed in new census figures. According to the census, in the past seven years the number of Muslims living in the UK has risen  


Picture of the Day

Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh presenting the award to the District Collector, Visakapatanam V. Seshadri for promoting social equity in MGNREGA implementation, at the 8th Mahatma Gandhi NREGA Divas Sammelan, in New Delhi on February 02, 2013.


Recommend the story to your friends



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us


The Funny Side

Education & Career Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.