More on Ummid: International l National Regional l Politics Sports Religion l History l Culture l Education



Kerala to set up Islamic bank shortly

Bhai Tej Singh calls Dalits & Muslims to join hands to wrest power

Ishrat killing Central government stands by terror link affidavit

Maharashtra Govt. trying to rewrite history : Munde

Activist wants MHA to apologize for filing affidavit against Ishrat

Malegaon Blast 3 yrs on: 'Shoot them in public if they are guilty'

'Ishrat encounter a cold-blooded murder', probe report

Tension prevails in two Maha towns, Munde detained at airport


Exploring Ramadan Part IV Revelation of Quran and fasting in Ramadan: Holy Quran is closely associated with.... Read Full

Part I Fasting is prescribed so that you may learn self-restraint

Part II Offer prayers in Ramadan nights to seek forgiveness

Part III 'Fasting is Mine and it is I who give reward for it'

Obama would have liked to have dinner with Gandhi: President Barack Obama, whose hero is Abraham Lincoln, said Tuesday.... Read Full

Manmohan, Mulayam, Rajnath, Thackeray play together here


Supreme Court stays CBI investigations into Hari Masjid firing case: The Central Bureau of Investigations (CBI) investigating into the Hari Masjid Firing case stopped the probe Tuesday after they learnt from the Special Task Force that the Supreme ... Read Full

Government rejects Sachar recommendation on Wakf boards: The government has rejected a recommendation of the Sachar Committee to create Indian Wakf Services on the lines of the civil services to appoint officers to boards that manage Muslim religious and community properties..... Read Full

Manmohan, Mulayam, Rajnath, Thackeray play together here: Here Jayalalithaa takes Bal Thackeray on her lap when he sobs, Manmohan Singh is fond of riding on Mulayam Singh's shoulders, while Kalyan ..... Read Full

Dilemmas of Defeat: Whither BJP?: The humiliating electoral defeat continues to dodge the BJP. In quick succession lot of things are happening, old pillars are crumbling..... Read Full



Ayesha Ashmin in Sri Venkataramana Swami College!: In Kannada there is a very popular saying “as connected as Imam Sabi is to gokulashtami". Which in other words means what does a Muslim .... Read Full

Overwhelming response to Hajj Committee UPSC coaching center: The Hajj Committee officials in Mumbai received a timely shot in their arms when the proposed IAS & Allied ... Read Full

Book Review:

Muslims and Media Images: News versus Views: The question of the Muslim identity is indeed complex and in India it is further complicated by the diversity of Indian society and the large Muslim .... Read Full

Supreme Court granted bail to Moulana Naseeruddin: In a decision dated September 04, 2009 Supreme Court granted bail to Moulana Naseeruddin who was languishing in Gujarat jail for the past five years. "On the facts of the case, we direct that the  petitioner shall be.... Read Full



The only Hindu Unani doctor in Maharashtra learnt Urdu to crack BUMS exams: There are five BUMS colleges in the state and an estimated 300 Unani doctors graduate......Read Full

"No Muslim child in India to be left behind for education”:  Presently I work as a Scientific Officer in Bhabha Atomic Research Centre, Mumbai, India, since 1998. My contribution.... Read Full

Mumbai Muslim girl takes Urdu route to IAS: Sarah Rizvi has done her bit to issue a blow to the stereotype of the Muslim woman, moderately educated and...Read Full

A Trip to Globe on Handcart: There are few in this world who are recognized by the good deeds. Bhavarlalji Jain, of course,  is one among the coveted few....Read Full

First Lady MPSC of Malegaon devotes herself to poor people: The First Lady Pediatrician and First Lady MPSC of Malegaon, Dr. Bibi Fatema has now been  appointed as Medical Officer at ....Read Full


Maulana Azad and partition

Thursday, September 10, 2009 05:13:30 PM, Asghar Ali Engineer

Abul Kalam Azad

'Jinnah not responsible for Partition' He was demonized by India, says Jaswant Singh, admits Indian Muslims are treated as aliens: In what is certain to stir up a hornets' nest, senior BJP leader Jaswant Singh says in his biography on the founder of Pakistan Mohammad Ali Jinnah ..... Read Full

My Hero, Your Hero - The War Goes On

Nehru, Jinah and partition

In the current debate on partition started by Jaswant Singh’s book every one is talking about the role of Jinnah, Nehru and Sardar Patel in partitioning of India but hardly anyone has mentioned what Maulana Azad, an important leader of Indian National Congress and an eminent scholar of Islam who held post of President of the Congress for six long years before partition, had done to avert partition.


It is true that Maulana was also party to the Congress Working Committee (CWC) resolution accepting partition but besides this Maulana Azad had never accepted partition and had warned Jawaharlal Nehru of certain of his acts which politically were not wise and may result in alienation of Jinnah or in partition. Pandit Nehru was not for weak centre and hence he consciously contributed to contribution but Azad had no such interest in partition and wanted to prevent it. He supported it only as something inevitable.


To understand Maulana Azad’s viewpoint his own book India Wins Freedom and the 30 pages which were published 30 years after his death. About partition Maulana had definite point of view that cannot be ignored if we have to understand the genesis and causes of partition. Maulana Azad was an important leader of the Congress, on one hand, and on the other, an important leader of Muslims and a great religious scholar. Hence his views and role assume added significance.


Maulana Azad had passionate commitment to freedom of India and as youngest president of the Congress in Ramgarh session had said, in his presidential address that if an angel descends from heaven with gift of freedom of India and declares from Qutub Minar that India is a free country I would not accept it unless Hindus and Muslims are united as if India does not get freedom it is India’s loss but if Hindus and Muslims do not unite it is entire humanity’s loss. Thus Maulana Azad was passionately committed to Hindu-Muslim unity and would in no case agree to partition for personal reason, whether centre remains weak or strong.


It would be interesting to mention here Maulana’s views on Pakistan. Maulana writes in India Wins Freedom:


“I must confess that the very term Pakistan goes against my grain. It suggests that some portions of the world are pure while others are impure. Such a division of territories into pure and impure is un-Islamic…Furthermore, it seems that the scheme of Pakistan is a symbol of defeatism and has been built up on the analogy of the Jewish demand for a national home. It is a confession that Indian Muslims cannot hold of their own in India as a whole and would be content to withdraw to a corner specially reserved for them….”

Over 90 million in number, they are in quantity and quality a sufficiently important element in Indian life to influence decisively all questions of administration and policy. Nature has further helped them by concentrating them in certain areas. In such a context, the demand for Pakistan looses all force. As a Muslim, I for one am not prepared for a moment to give up my right to treat the whole of India as my domain and share in the shaping of its political and economic life. To me it seems a sure sign of cowardice to give up what is my patrimony and content myself with a mere fragment of it.

The Maulana then examines the consequences of partition quite objectively. Thus he says:


“Let us consider dispassionately the consequences which will follow if we give effect to the Pakistan scheme. India will be divided into two states, one with a majority of Muslims and the other of Hindus. In the Hindustan State there will remain three and half crores of Muslims scattered in small minorities all over the land. With 17 per cent in U.P., 12 per cent in Bihar and 9 per cent in Madras, they will be weaker than they are today in the Hindu majority provinces. They have had their homelands in these regions for almost a thousand years and built up well known centres of Muslim culture and civilization there.


They will awaken overnight and discover that they have become alien and foreigners. Backward industrially, educationally and economically, they will be left to the mercies to what would become an unadulterated Hindu raj.


On the other hand, their position within the Pakistan State will be vulnerable and weak. Nowhere in Pakistan will their majority be comparable to the Hindu majority in the Hindustan States.


In fact their majority will be so slight that it will be offset by the economical, educational and political lead enjoyed by non-Muslims in these areas. Even if this were not so and Pakistan were overwhelmingly Muslim in population, it still could hardly solve the problem of Muslims in Hindustan.”


Also, the fear that if Pakistan is not formed the Centre with Hindu majority will interfere in Muslim majority provinces, Maulana counters by the argument (which was what the Cabinet Mission Plan was about) “The Congress meets this fear by granting full autonomy to the provinces. It has also provided for two lists of Central subjects, one compulsory and none optional so that if any provincial unit so wants, it can administer all subjects itself except a minimum delegated to the Centre. The Congress scheme, therefore ensures that Muslim majority provinces are internally free to develop as they will, but can at the same time influence the Centre on all issues which affect India as a whole.”


Thus Maulana was not opposing partition only as a congress leader but also with full conviction as a wise Muslim who could foresee far reaching consequences. Maulana Azad, unlike other politicians, was a far sighted leader both of Muslims and of whole of India also. What Maulana has said in his opposition to Pakistan is clearly borne out in post-partition period.


Actually Indian Muslims as a whole lost much more than others. They were fragmented and divided. Had Pakistan not been formed today there would have been more than 33 per cent Muslims, a huge number in any democracy. In any case they would have formed their own government in the Muslim majority provinces and would have had stake in whole of India. Several Muslim leaders could have become prime minister of India.


Maulana says, according to the numbers of Muslims than in India that Pakistan will result in only 9 crores of Muslims in Hindustan, scattered throughout the country. Today there are about 15 crores of Muslims but are still a minority and face several problems as minority and also have to carry the guilt – wrongly of course – of having partitioned the country. Ironically there are more Muslims in India than in Pakistan and yet they constitute only 14 per cent minority.


Also, Pakistan could not remain united and feel into two pieces as Bengali Muslims could not carry on with West Pakistani Muslims for more than 25 years. Thus whole sub-continent got divided into three parts. Had partition not taken place in 1947, what is Bangla Desh today would also have been part of united India. Also, democracy has eluded Pakistan in post-partition period and it has become totally dependent on American aid and military has remained, and will remain for foreseeable future, politically influential even if democracy lasts longer in Pakistan.


Though Maulana Azad does not mention it as that problem had not arisen then, there would have been no Kashmir problem either. Kashmir either would have become independent or would have enjoyed autonomy like other Muslim majority areas and thousands of Kashmiris would not have lost their lives as they did due to dispute between India and Pakistan today.


Also, both India and Pakistan spend astronomical sums on maintaining their armies. What for? Only due to fear of each other. There would have been only one army for the whole country and we would have spent much less on our army and could have faced external threats, specially from china much more effectively. What is much more important thing is that we would not have faced terrorism as both Pakistan and India are facing today. Terrorism alone has consumed thousands of life and huge amounts on armament.


Maulana Azad, in those thirty pages which were published thirty years after his death blames both Nehru and Sardar Patel. According to the Maulana, Nehru made a mistake by refusing to take two Muslim League members as cabinet ministers after provincial elections in 1937 in U.P. It made Jinnah distrustful of the Congress leaders whom he began to describe as ‘Hindu’ leaders.


Second mistake committed by Jawaharlal Nehru was his statement to the press in July 1946 after taking over as president of the Congress in which he said Cabinet Mission Plan could be changed. Muslim League and Congress both had accepted the Plan and to give such statement in an atmosphere of distrust and mutual suspicion was certainly a mistake. That finally drove Jinnah to insist on partition. And British could achieve what they had wanted.


What Muslims in what is Pakistan today?



  Bookmark and Share

Home | Top of the Page

  Comment on this article

E-mail Address:
Write here...
 Home | Contact Us | Disclaimer | Terms of Use | About Us | Feedback

Ummid Business: Advertise with us | Careers | Link Exchange is part of Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and condition mentioned.