More on Ummid: International l National Regional l Politics Business Religion l History l Culture l Education



New York Mayor defends proposed Ground Zero mosque

Israel rejects new drive for a nuclear free Middle East

West is unfair to Iran: Turkish PM

Andaman's 12 schools achieve 100% results in CBSE Exam

Istanbul: A city with skyline specked with minarates and domes

Gujarat governor seeks report on inflammatory posters

Gaza facing a humanitarian disaster: UN expert


Israel 'attacks' Gaza aid fleet, 16 killed: Israeli forces have attacked the international aid convoy Freedom Flotilla en route  ..... Read Full

Gaza facing a humanitarian disaster: UN expert

Muslims in India don’t vote effectively, so are the Muslims in United States: One of the many reasons behind the sufferings ..... Read Full

Country of Immigrants, United States is a WORLD in itself

World not a paradise like Washington: Courtesy, US Foreign Policy


Majority of Kashmiris against joining Pakistan: Only 2% of residents of Kashmir want to join Pakistan while less than half of them favor independence .... Read Full

Gaza facing a humanitarian disaster: UN expert: Gaza is facing a humanitarian disaster, the spokesman for UN Relief and Works Agency .... Read Full

Demand for Muslim graveyard in Margao remains buried in files: Decade-long demand for an appropriate burial ground in Margao by the Muslim community remains .... Read Full

Sibal, Khurshid differ over minority status to Jamia Milia Islamia: The Ministries of minority affairs and HRD are at loggerheads over .... Read Full



After Class 12, Gulf students excel in CBSE Class 10 exams too: Students from the Gulf region have outperformed their India counterparts in the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) exams  .... Read Full

Israeli warnings fail to stop Gaza ‘Freedom Flotilla’: Organizers of an eight—ship flotilla said on Friday they continued to head  .... Read Full

Critics of Iran should get rid of own nukes: Turkish PM: Nations criticizing an Iranian nuclear fuel-swap deal brokered by Brazil and Turkey should eliminate  .... Read Full

World's first: Brit scientist infects himself with computer virus: Dr Mark Gasson, a cybernetics expert at the University of Reading, has become the first human to be infected with  .... Read Full

Decks cleared for construction of a mosque near ground zero: After hours of contentious public comment, a New York City community board voted late  .... Read Full

Muslims should opt for civil services as mission: Shah Faisal: Muslim candidates should not opt for civil services as a job, rather a mission, said Shah .... Read Full

Jasmine Bano tops Tamil Nadu SSC Board Exams: A Muslim girl Jasmin Bano, daughter of Shaikh Dawood has created history and brought a pleasant .... Read Full

Family video shows suspect at wedding during Pune Blast: In yet another embarrassing development for the Maharashtra ATS, family of Abdul Samad .... Read Full

IIT-JEE results out,  Rahmani-30 struggles at 33%: Trying hard to repeat last year’s success, Rahmani-30 coaching centre for Muslim IIT aspirants has .... Read Full

Delhi doctors save Pakistani boy with stem cell transplant: Delhi doctors proved to be saviours for a one-year-old boy from Pakistan who was suffering .... Read Full


Caste based Census: India is divided

Monday, May 31, 2010 11:19:00 AM, IANS

Identity, Indian politics and caste census: The Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has assured the parliament that caste will be included in the current census..... Read Full

Caste based census: Lawyer files caveat in SC

RSS opposed to caste-based census

BJP differs with RSS on caste-based census

Caste based census will further divide society: Murli Manohar

Mulayam urges PM to issue immediate orders for caste based census

New Delhi: Is it good to ask the Indian his or her caste? The political class is divided although a vast majority of Indians carry their caste firmly etched in their names.

Ever since the Samajwadi Party and the Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) ignited a storm by demanding that caste identity be included in the national census, political parties have been locked in a war of words.

The government’s initial reported decision to bow to the demand and then ask a panel of ministers to study the issue — effectively keeping the caste-count from the mammoth national census now under way — has added fuel to the fire.

The Congress and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), the two biggest parties in parliament, are divided within their ranks.

But Samajwadi Party’s vocal MP Dharmendra Yadav knows his mind. “Various welfare schemes of the central government use caste as a yardstick to provide benefits to weaker sections,” Yadav told IANS. “It is important to get a proper enumeration of castes to get accurate data about their numbers.”

Those who want to put the caste back in the census — it was tabulated way back in 1931 when India was under British rule for the first and last time — say there is nothing wrong in counting the caste since Indians are asked their religion anyway.

Dissenting voices
Ajay Maken, a junior minister in the Congress-led United Progressive Alliance government, has warned that a caste-based census would lead to demands from communities to be categorized as OBCs (other backward classes) — to gain official benefits available to people who are socially backward. He is mobilising younger and progressive MPs to lobby as a pressure group against caste-based census.

India’s Hindu community is home to hundreds of castes and sub-castes. The caste system forms the basis of a strict hierarchical society where the lower castes have been economically and socially oppressed for long, though this division is disappearing among the surging middle class as it pursues expanding professional and economic aspirations and integrates socially.

Some of Maken’s ministerial colleagues, including Law Minister M. Veerappa Moily, want caste to be included in the headcount of India’s population.

MPs differ too
BJP leader Arjun Munda, a former Jharkhand chief minister, said any decision on a caste count should be taken after thoroughly analysing its impact on politics, especially the experience of the past 20 years. “Having caste census has its merits and demerits. I am against caste politics and feel that an enumeration will accentuate caste identities and hence will have a negative impact,” he said.

Madhu Goud Yaskhi, a Congress MP from Andhra Pradesh who left a flourishing legal practice in New York to join politics in India, argued that India was a caste-based society anyway.

“One cannot avoid the caste system. Political parties give ticket on the basis of caste. They look at caste equations in a constituency. Caste is a factor in giving job and education opportunities to weaker sections.”

Like others, he said lack of reliable data on castes was a problem.

So why was his party colleague Maken opposed to Indians being asked their caste? Yaskhi replied that the minister belonged to the upper caste and could be addressing his own constituency.

Cast away the Caste
Said Anup Kumar Saha, a Communist Party of India-Marxist (CPI-M) MP from West Bengal: “We are not free from the problem of casteism. A caste census will only complicate matters.”

Saha said even if the government wanted to get data on caste, such information should not be put in public domain as it would only strengthen caste identities.

A senior Congress leader said on the condition of anonymity that caste-based census would pose problems due to the possible clamour for inclusion among the OBCs. If more communities became OBCs, it could pose resistance from those sections already taking benefits of reservation.

Even as the government tries to buy time by referring the issue to a group of ministers, the debate rages on.






  Bookmark and Share

Home | Top of the Page

  Comment on this article


E-mail Address:

Write here...







 Home | Contact Us | Disclaimer | Terms of Use | About Us | Feedback

Ummid Business: Advertise with us | Careers | Link Exchange is part of Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and condition mentioned.