Ummid Assistant

Applications open for Manmohan scholarship at Cambridge

Opportunities for Indian students in US

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home Health

Chennai hospital to pay Rs.1 lakh for 1989 negligence

Wednesday February 06, 2013 02:21:42 PM, Rahul Chhabra, IANS

New Delhi: Twenty-three years after being operated on the wrong side for a hernia in a Chennai hospital, a 29-year-old man has been awarded Rs.1 lakh by a top consumer court that asked the private facility to compensate him for the "unnecessary suffering and agony".

Holding out some relief for Javeed, who was only six when the 'wrong' operation took place, the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission held C.S.I. Rainy Hospital guilty of medical negligence. It said in a recent ruling that the hospital "is directed to pay Javeed Rs.1 lakh as compensation for the unnecessary suffering and agony caused to him and his family".

Commission President Ashok Bhan and Member Vineeta Rai gave the hospital time till March 31 to pay the compensation to Javeed, a resident of the Tiruvottiyur area in Chennai.

"The facts clearly indicate that the required reasonable degree of care and caution was not taken by the hospital's doctors in the treatment of Javeed and, thus, the hospital was guilty of medical negligence, for which he should justifiably be compensated," the commission president said.

Javeed said in his complaint that he was admitted to the hospital with a complaint of temporary inguinal hernia and was operated upon Aug 12, 1989 after diagnostic tests.

During a follow-up visit, he said, a doctor at the hospital told him that he would have to go under the knife once again as he had been operated for left inguinal hernia and hernitomy instead of being operated on the right side.

The commission ruled: "What constitutes medical negligence is now well settled through a number of judgments of this commission as also of the Supreme of the principles to test medical negligence is whether a doctor exercised a reasonable degree of care and caution in treating a patient."

The top consumer court dismissed the hospital's defence that the patient's ailment was such that it required two successive surgeries on both the left and right sides and that the doctors informed his family that they would first attend to the left portion.

"The hospital has not been able to produce any evidence that Javeed's parents were informed that he was suffering with bilateral herniatomy or that just prior to the surgery they were informed that the surgery would be conducted on the left side and not on the right side," the commission said.

The national commission accepted Javeed's appeal against a Tamil Nadu State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission decision that gave a clean chit to the hospital.

Bhan said: "We are unable to agree with the finding of the state commission that as per the evidence on record there was no medical negligence in the treatment of Javeed."

"Clearly, Javeed was diagnosed for conducting a surgery on the right inguinal herniatomy...whereas this surgery was conducted on the left side without any evidence that it was this side which required it," said the national commission, slamming the hospital.

Dismissing the hospital's plea, Bhan said: "Had the hospital advised the patient's parents that he had bilateral herniatomy (which required surgery on both right and left side), then perhaps there would be some case for the hospital to explain how the surgery was conducted on the left side."

(Rahul Chhabra can be contacted at





Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS



More Headlines

Cabinet approves coal price pooling in-principle

India knocked out of Women's World Cup

Ahmadinejad ready to fly into space

'Stop Lankan president's visits to India'

Delhi's Chandni Chowk to be redeveloped

Tokyo most expensive city, Karachi cheapest

Dr. Yusuf Al-Qaradawi Scholar of the Year for second consecutive year

Court slaps cheating charges against Kalmadi, 9 others

Mumbai students make a 7,527 sq ft anti-tobacco ad

No special status for Bihar, says Ahulwalia

Snap polls after budget session: Mulayam


Top Stories

Government defends ordinance, promises debate as women protest

As women's groups decided to intensify their protest, the government Monday defended its ordinance on enhancing punishment for sexual crimes and said it was open to public   

Women activists urge president not to sign sexual crime ordinance

President's nod to sexual crimes ordinance


  Most Read

Religion goes digital: Saudi Arabia connects with instant Quran

The digital revolution is spurring a slow transformation in the spiritual classrooms of one of most conservative bastions of faith. More and more Muslims in India, South Asia and around   

Snap polls after budget session: Mulayam

The government could go for early Lok Sabha elections after parliament's winter session, Samajwadi Party chier Mulayam Singh Yadav said Monday. Addressing party workers here, Yadav said the  


  News Pick

Court slaps cheating charges against Kalmadi, 9 others

A Delhi court Monday formally slapped charges of forgery and cheating against former Commonwealth Games Organising Committee chief Suresh Kalmadi and nine others in a corruption case related to the 2010 Commonwealth Games  

Dr. Yusuf Al-Qaradawi Scholar of the Year for second consecutive year

The Islamic site launched the campaign as a token of appreciation to scholars and Muslims preachers, who did great efforts in 2012 to spread Islamic knowledge, promote Islamic values and  

'Stop Lankan president's visits to India'

The Tamil Eelam Supporters Organisaton (TESO) will protest here Feb 8 against the India visit of Sri Lankan President Mahinda Rajapaksa. DMK MPs would meet the envoys of 41 countries to impress upon    

Online petition demands NEET - 2013 papers in Urdu

A day after Jammu & Kashmir Congress Chief Prof Saifuddin Soz raised the issue with the government, a Maharashtra based activist on Sunday  


Picture of the Day

Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh presenting the award to the District Collector, Visakapatanam V. Seshadri for promoting social equity in MGNREGA implementation, at the 8th Mahatma Gandhi NREGA Divas Sammelan, in New Delhi on February 02, 2013.


Recommend the story to your friends



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us


The Funny Side

Education & Career Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.