Ummid Assistant

Applications open for Manmohan scholarship at Cambridge

Opportunities for Indian students in US

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » Views & Analysis

Who Will Make Manik Sarkar PM?

Tuesday March 26, 2013 11:59:10 AM, Sazzad Hussain

Related Article

Manik Sarkar becomes Tripura CM for fourth time

Manik Sarkar assumed office as Tripura chief minister for a record fourth successive term at the head of India's only Communist government, the defender of the red bastion   »

As Tripura goes to polls, spotlight on 'poorest CM'

Left retains Tripura -- for fifth straight term

I

In the wild run for the post of the chief executive of our country the trials and heats have already been on. Right from the market research groups and survey conductors to the techno-glitz trendsetter analysts there has been a concerted effort to seat Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi at Delhi. The logic is that he is a chief minister who has won three consecutive assembly polls and become a symbol of growth and development as Gujarat has been made the favourite destination for big business.

 

Apart from the party big-wigs to the corporate leaders, celebrities and popular columnist are also endorsing Modi for the post of India’s Prime Minister after the 2014 Lok Sabha Polls. However these techno-savvy, urbane and neo-liberals awfully miss the same logic when it comes to state chief ministers of other political parties. Sheila Dixit, Navin Patnaik, Tarun Gogoi, Nitish Kumar all fall to the same rank of Nraendra Modi of wining successive assembly polls. Latest of them is the Tripura Chief Minister Manik Sarkar. Sarkar has won the assembly polls for fourth consecutive term on a camping of good governance and welfare of the people. Does this not make him eligible for the post of premiership on the same logic as attributed to Modi?

The giant billboards, LED big screens or online portals portraying the larger than life image of Narendra Modi is nowhere to be seen in Agartala or anywhere in Tripura if you try to gauge the popularity of its Chief Minister Manik Sarkar. There is no corporate houses in Tripura for Manik Sarkar to pour money for lavish publicity campaigns as we have seen in the case of Modi in last December’s assembly polls. Nor is there glass and chromed super malls and multiplexes, express highways of Gandhinagar, Vadodara or Rajkot representing the vibrant Gujarat of Modi in Tripura to showcase Sarkar’s success. Whatever he has is the people’s goodwill and support across the state comprising all ethnic groups for transforming a state from strife and insurgency and political corruption to a peace and development.

Tripura is a multi-ethnic state with different sub-tribes (upajatis) and East Bengali immigrants. The state witnessed the ethnic insurgency and secessionist militancy, a familiar phenomenon of all North Eastern states, for a long time. Economic development and business was hard as Tripura is a landlocked country with inhospitable terrain making it extremely difficult to connect by road with rest of India. The easiest possible way was to connect Agartala with Kolkata via Bangladesh. Since 1998, the year Manik Sarkar won the first election; there has been steady and upward development in all these sectors making Tripura as one of the most peaceful and developing state of India.

Celebrities often talk about Modi’s personal habits like vegetarianism and celibacy. Bollywood dream girl Hema Malini, a diehard fan of Modi, often showered accolades for him for his liking of Khichidi. However no one talks about Manik Sarkar as he takes Muri (puffed rice) along with party workers in his party’s office on a bench in the verandah. He never takes special food in the Tripura Bhawan when he is on official visits to Kolkata or Delhi and shares the common food along with his staff. Manik Sarkar is probably India’s only chief minister who does not own a home, car or bank balance worth mentioning. He does not even have a mobile phone and has never used the red beacon on his official car and washes his own clothes every morning. His wife, a government employee, commutes to her office by a rickshaw. What Chetan Bhagat would like to say on him?

 

On the other hand Narendra Modi’s wardrobe is filled with dresses designed by Gautam Adani, takes his entire secretariat to Kutch to follow his steps of yoga and other shows. While it is very difficult to find out Manik Sarkar as the chief minister of Tripura when someone visits his party office where he mingles without his personal presence being seen or felt among his fellow workers.

Like other NE states Tripura too have been hit by ethnic militancy and armed secessionist insurgency. However, unlike the terror hit states, Chief Minister Manik Sarkar never has opted for a military offensive. Like his predecessor Nripen Chakraborty, who had opposed extension of Disturbed Areas Act to Tripura and induction of army, Sarkar followed a different strategy of engaging only state police and central para-military forces in effectively dealing the anti-insurgency operations. The State took on the problems in a strategic and resolute manner formulating a multi-dimensional and fine-tuned construct to respond creatively to the situation.

 

The control mechanism was subsumed in counter-insurgency operations intent on swift area-domination and ascendancy, as well as psychological operations and confidence-building measures instead of an exclusive, hawkish, one-dimensional combat in the nature of conflict-management. Sarkar also brought tribal youth in the Special Police Officers for the operations which proved to be valuable in terms of gathering intelligence and keeping a tab on the activities and movements of the insurgents, collaborators and harbourers. The Central and State security forces were forged into a synergetic, coordinated and cohesive mode to derive optimal gains.

 

Their conduct was under close observation of the Governor and the Chief Minister, in order to check personnel from going berserk and being ruthless, trigger-happy, oppressive and violation of human rights. Counter insurgency operations were discreetly suffused with psychological elements, confidence-building measures and healing touches to achieve a sustained end to the conflict. Psychological interventions were focused on correcting the tribal person's negative perception about the state and the mainland, and inducing confidence in and credibility about the State's intentions. Confidence-building exercises and healing touches encompassed special recruitment to the security forces and other government services, especially in the insurgency-bound pockets. An accelerated development thrust, management of the media, civic action programmes of the security forces, and the political process were additional factors.

 

These observations were made by D.N. Sahaya, the ex-Governor of Tripura (2003-2009). Thus Tripura is a model of the most extraordinary success, bringing some of the country’s most virulent and bloody movements to a near complete end in an exemplary, police-led campaign that began to record major successes in 2004, and had brought the State to peace by late 2006. In the contrary, Modi has not taken up any steps to reach out the post-Godhra marginalized Muslim population of Gujarat who has been by-passed by his development mantra.

Manik Sarkar’s electoral ascendancy is also impressive. In 1998 state polls, when he got the mandate for the first time, CPM won 38 (49.43%) seats out of 60 in which its allies the RSP won 2 and the CPI got 1 seat. In 2003 polls the result was absolutely identical with similar wins. In 2008 Manik Sarkar led CPM to win 46 seats in the assembly securing 51.21% of the share. This time in 2013 the CPM increased its tally to 48 seats. Isn’t it sufficient to point this phenomenal electoral success of the Tripura Chief Minister to stake his claim (though he has not made any such claims unlike Modi) for Delhi? Will Chetan Bhagat, Gautam Adani, Amitabh Bachchan will say same words for Manik Sarakr?



The writer is a freelancer based in Assam. He can be reached at sazzad.hussain2@gmail.com






 

Home | Top of the Page

Comments

Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of www.ummid.com

Comments powered by DISQUS

i

More Headlines

21 UP districts declared sensitive for Holi

Muslim student expelled over hijab in Russia

Senior Delhi cop's son-in-law arrested for demanding dowry

Congress, BJP rebuff SP's third front vision

FDI in retail figures in Rajnath, US envoy meeting

Hopes raised over first Manmohan-Xi meet Wednesday

'New policy soon on amnesty to former militants'

First phase of Mataf expansion work will finish in Ramadan

Chidambaram to talk on BRICS bank with counterparts

Tired of hate attacks, Sri Lanka Muslims plead for protection

 

Top Stories

Special courts for Muslims an 'eyewash', say Muslim organisations

Muslims organizations have expressed skepticism over the home ministry's proposal to set up  »

Special courts soon for Muslims arrested in terror related cases: Rahman Khan

Personal law board demands compensation for Muslims acquitted in terror cases

 

  Most Read

In Andhra assembly, Akbar Owaisi accuses Cong of being communal, intolerant

The Andhra Pradesh assembly on Saturday witnessed a war of words between Chief Minister N Kiran Kumar Reddy and Akbaruddin Owaisi when the All India  »

Unrest in Africa

President flees, chaos in Central African Republic

Central African Republic slid into anarchy after its President Francois Bozize fled to Cameroon Sunday as rebels in his country seized capital Bangui. A helicopter of the presidency of the Central African Republic carrying Bozize landed  »

 

  News Pick

Cricket

India pay back Australia with 4-0 whitewash

In a payback, India whitewashed Australia 4-0 by winning the fourth Test comprehensively by six wickets with two days to spare to regain the Border-Gavaskar Trophy at the Ferozeshah   »

A 'Clean India' movement to begin from Kolkata

A movement of around 80 current and former Kolkatans from diverse professional backgrounds, GFI will be aided by the Kolkata Municipal Corporation (KMC), private companies and schools in starting cleaning drives  »

Lawyers in danger

Defense lawyer of Muslim blast accused provided security after threat

One of the defense lawyers of the Muslim accused arrested in the 2006 Mumbai train blasts and other terror related cases was on Saturday provided security after he complained to the Mumbai police that he was under the threat and there   »

Muslims in Russia's southern region migrating to save Hijab

A recent ban on the wearing of hijab in Russia’s southern region of Stavropol is squeezing the Muslim population in the area, forcing many  »

 

Picture of the Day

Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh being welcomed on his arrival, at King Shaka International airport, to attend the Fifth BRICS Summit, at Durban, South Africa on March 25, 2013.

 

Recommend the story to your friends

 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

RSS  |  Contact us

 

| Quick links

News

 

Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant

 

National

Science & Technology

RSS

Scholarships

About us

International

Health

Twitter

Government Schemes

Feedback

Regional

History

Facebook

Education

Register

Politics

Opinion

Newsletter

Contact us

Business

The Funny Side

Education & Career

 

 

Ummid.com: Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange

Ummid.com is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

© 2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.