More on Ummid: International l National Regional l Politics Sports Religion l History l Culture l Education



Zoya Hassan, three others  bag awards at Singapore Film Festival

Goa blast accused carried trials before their plan targeting Diwali

SC gives lifer to 6 for Dalit killings, urges to abolish caste system

Mausam Noor Cong MP from Malda weds classmate

AFMI Sir Syed award for 2009 goes to Mumbarak Kapdi

Eboo Patel, Obama's India-born adviser wins award

Anti Riots Bill: Left cautious, BJP objects some provisions

Babri Masjid Demolition: Alerts in states on Anniversary Day

On 25th Anniversary, Bhopal Gas Tragedy Survivors.....


Nationwide protests demanding punishment to Babri Masjid demolition culprits: Even.... Read Full

UK Indian Muslims urge British Govt. to declare Babri culprits persona non grata

Indian American Muslims demand action against Babri accused

Minaret message to Muslims in Europe: The Swiss people have voted: They do not want minarets in their landscape. The first reaction from the European..... Read Full

AMU off-campus centre in Maharashtra gets a new lease on life


Chidambaram’s ‘Hindu Terrorist’ remark in RS irks BJP: Indulging in hate campaign against Indian Muslims for years while taking political mileage out of the dirty propaganda.... Read Full

Liberhan report, demolition anniversary, but Ayodhya calm: The Liberhan Commission report might be creating ripples in the corridors of power in New Delhi. And preparations for the 17th anniversary of the demolition.... Read Full

Only Muslim lady in Maharashtra cabinet at work to bring surprising turnaround: Mrs. Fauzia Khan is the first Muslim lady who took the oath as a minister in Maharashtra Government.... Read Full

Listen To The Muslim Woman’s Voice:

India’s largest minority population lives in poverty and socio-economic exclusion even after 62 years of Independence....Read Full


More on ummid


Ishrat Killing: SC stays further proceedings in Gujarat HC: The Supreme Court (SC) on Monday stayed all further proceedings in the Ishrat Jahan case in the Gujarat High .... Read Full

Celebrating Bakra Eid in Mumbai: In the city of Mumbai, where Muslims number about 3 million, in a total Metropolitan population of 13.6 million, the difficulties that Muslim face in carrying.... Read Full

Book Review

Reformist Voices of Islam—Mediating Islam and Modernity: ‘Reformist Islam’, today an oft-heard slogan, is notoriously difficult to define, for it can mean different ....Read Full

Film Review

Shifting Prophecy: Countering the stereotypical image of Muslim women as silent victims of patriarchy, the award-winning film ‘Shifting Prophecy’ highlights..... Read Full

Role of Vajpayee in Babri Masjid demolition: civilised mukhauta of uncivil Sangh: Mr Atal Behari Vajpayee, the civilised mukhauta (mask) of the uncivil Sangh, has always had his way.... Read Full

A Vision for Muslim Empowerment: Having served for several years as the amir of the Jamaat-e Islami’s Kerala wing, Siddiq Hasan was appointed as the head of the Social Service.... Read Full



Babri debate: 'Liberhan Report baseless and biased'


Tuesday, December 08, 2009 09:48:39 AM, Agencies

BJP President Rajnath Singh

Protests, celebrations mark 17th Anniversary of Babri Masjid: In a charged atmosphere in the wake of the Liberhan Commission's findings on the .... Read Full

Nationwide protests demanding punishment to Babri Masjid demolition culprits

Lok Sabha to debate Liberhan report Monday, Tuesday

Liberhan Commission: Painful wait for Justice

New Delhi: The BJP on Monday said the demolition of the disputed structure at Ayodhya was a result of public anger and asserted that it would build a Ram temple at the same site for "national justice", as it slammed the Liberhan Commission report as "a political document" which is "biased".


Opening BJP's defence on the report which has indicted a number of its leaders, party chief Rajnath Singh said in the Lok Sabha that the Liberhan Commission report was "a bundle of grave errors" and its intent appeared to be "pre-decided" and aimed at "character assassination" of certain political leaders and parties.


The Commission has reached "bizarre" conclusions, he said during the debate and took strong objection to the adverse comments made against former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee and senior leaders L K Advani and M M Joshi.


He said the report was "not unbiased" and said it was a "political document of character assassinations" as legal criteria for indictment had been ignored.


"Whatever happened on December 6, 1992, was a result of public anger. There was no mosque at the site since 1936," he said, amid repeated disruptions caused by objections from Congress and some other parties like Samajwadi Party.


"The Liberhan Commission report is a bundle of several errors....even after spending 17 years it has not been able to bring out the truth," he said.


During the 17 years, Justice Liberhan or anybody else from the Commission had not visited Ayodhya even once, Singh said and likened him to Sanjay, an aide of Mahabharat's Dhrithrastra, who had a special vision and could give a blow-by-blow account of the Kurukshetra war without being there. "Who is that Dhrithrastra," he asked.


Singh said the indictment of Vajpayee and other BJP leaders was not based on facts but assumptions and the commission seemed to be "pre-decided" on whom to blame for the demolition and has thus reached "bizarre" conclusions.


Hitting out at the Commission for describing Vajpayee as "psuedo-secular", he said even Nehru had praised the BJP leader and Rao used to see him as a political guru.


"The report is totally baseless, prejudiced and is a deliberate attempt to target some persons and political parties," he charged.


"Building a Ram temple is not just religious justice, but also national justice. BJP reaffirms its commitment to build Ram Temple at the same site. When BJP, which was part of NDA, was in power, it could not deliver on its promise despite trying its best," the BJP said.


He insisted that no 'namaz' had been performed at the disputed structure since 1934 and the doors of the structure were opened for Hindus for 'puja' of the Ram Lala in 1949.


Hitting back at the Congress, he said then Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi had gone to have 'darshan' of Devraha Baba on November 6, 1989, before elections and had a meeting for 40 minutes. "The government should state what did they talk for 40 minutes," he said.


As Singh spoke about the events preceding December 6, 1992, Home Minister P Chidambaram intervened saying the issue of 'namaz' or 'puja' being conducted at the disputed structure in Ayodhya could not be discussed in Parliament as the matter was sub-judice.


"Whether namaz or puja was being conducted is part of the title suit. We are not here to debate a title suit. It is sub-judice and cannot be debated in this House," he said, adding that the debate should confine to the Liberhan report.


Chidambaram, who is expected to reply to the debate on Tuesday, said the Liberhan Commission was appointed only to "go into the circumstances leading to the demolition" so as to find out who demolished the structure.


Agreeing with Chidambaram, Speaker Meria Kumar said the members should be conscious of the fact that the matter is sub-judice and their statements should not prejudice the title suit. She asked the members to confine to the report.


At this, Murli Manohar Joshi (BJP) said the point was raised by the party to highlight inaccuracies. But Singh contended that as the matter was in courts, there was no point debating the report at all.


Defending the then Kalyan Singh government in UP, Singh said the Congress had in 1945 given a strong commitment not to allow country's partition but failed to keep the promise.


"Why questions are now being raised about Kalyan Singh's assurance to the Supreme Court on not allowing any damage to the disputed structure," he posed.








  Bookmark and Share

Home | Top of the Page

  Comment on this article

E-mail Address:
Write here...
 Home | Contact Us | Disclaimer | Terms of Use | About Us | Feedback

Ummid Business: Advertise with us | Careers | Link Exchange is part of Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and condition mentioned.