More on Ummid : International l National Regional l Politics Sports Religion l History l Culture l Education





Bargaining for Nothing

20 May, 2009 10:04:07 AM


A section of Ulema in Mumbai are demanding five seats from Cong-NCP in Maharashtra. How viable is their demand, assesses Aleem Faizee




Video: Message of Unity from Malegaon

'India Unity'

An English Play briliantly staged by Little Kids


More Videos on ummid

Mushairah on

National Integration in Malegaon

Kavi Sammlen on Communal Harmony in Malegaon

Inter College

Patriotic songs competition


More on Indian Muslims

Inquilab 1857 to Sacchar Report-Nothing has changed for Indian Muslims: Leaving behind the dark memories of the renewed terror and trauma for the Muslims in India... Read Full

Will Indo-Pak peace bring peace to

beleaguered Indian Muslims? While the secretary-level talks between India and Pakistan has commenced...Read Full

‘Advising Restraint, work for the Revival of the Community’: We should advise the Indian Muslims for observing total restraint so that the Anti-Muslim forces ...Read Full


Ummid Special on Terrorism

The Hidden Face of the Terrorism Exposed At last: A nation under the siege, innocent lives are at stake and the basic structure of the country in itself is at risk. Are we doing enough to combat the terrorism? With the investigations into Malegaon blast advancing rapidly, the hitherto hidden face of the terror is finally being exposed to the world and the assertion that the terrorism is a baby of only a particular community, in limelight after every act of terror, is now be....Full Story



Fascism and Terrorism: Two Sides of the same coin: “It seems that the fascist forces with a clear anti-Muslim agenda have infiltrated the security forces. Since the Indian... Read Full
Our terror, their terror: Shortly before LK Advani spoke at the HT Summit on Friday, I was chatting to Ajit Doval.  Though he is not yet a household name, Doval is a former director of the Intelligence...Read Full


Malegaon, a town in India with more than 70% Muslim population has always been considered as a communally sensitive place. However, there is a place in Malegaon where a Mosque and a Mandir exist side by side with Muslims and Hindus, both living there in peace since last many years. Same is the case with the whole town. Except for the...Full Story



Related Election News

A People’s Manifesto for the

15th Lok Sabha Polls: The present UPA government promised to take firm initiatives to address Muslims' backwardness and insecurity issues in its common minimum...Read Full

UPA could get 257 Lok Sabha seats-Survey: The UPA could get 257 seats in the forthcoming Lok Sabha polls, putting it within 15 seats of the 272 required for majority in the 543-member House. But that includes the ...Read Full

Hills have eyes on BJP: Politics in Himachal Pradesh veers largely around regional faultlines that thread through the old and merged areas of the mountainous state. Caste has never been a factor in the elections here...Read Full

The election season as always is the best suitable time to bargain for something. The chances of getting your demands accepted are more profound if you have a certain sizeable vote with you. Hence it is not surprising when we see people demanding for the heavens from the political parties for their communities during the election season. It is altogether a different matter that depending on their support base and how brilliantly they project their strength, they settle for either a Ministerial berth or a Rajya Sabha seat or sometimes on just a bagful of hard cash.


However there are some people in the country who come with such a demand that neither serves any purpose for their community nor for themselves. The result is that they gain absolutely nothing in this potential season also. In the same line are the demands by a section of Ulema in Mumbai. These Mumbai Ulema have gone to the extent of issuing the ultimatum to the Cong-NCP leadership to declare five seats out of the total forty-eight in Maharashtra for Muslim candidates. Failing which, they say, they will not only work for the candidates belonging to secular parties other than Congress and NCP but will also work to defeat the alliance’s candidates.


While no one today would like to question the importance of their demand, the timing and viability of their demand surely need a deliberation. The basis of their demand, which unfortunately finds quite a few number of supporters from some other parts of the state and the country as well, is that in Maharashtra since the Muslim population is 12% hence proportionally they should be given five seats in the state. They are even listing the places like Malegaon, Bhiwandi, Aurangabad, Akola and Washim where a sizeable number of Muslims live in Maharashtra as the potential constituencies that can win Muslim MPs.


Absolutely true and they have every right to demand for this. But when one asks them of the ‘winnability factor’ if at all their demand is accepted they are completely noncommittal. So the question one needs to ask these Ulema is that when they are not sure of the winning capacity of a Muslim candidate, the one and the only criteria considered by every party nowadays, why they are pressing so hard for these seats. To be very certain they don’t have any answer to this question. But the ground reality and the past history do suggest why they are evasive about the winning capacity of a Muslim candidate in elections.


Take for example the case of South Central Mumbai. The constituency has a large number of Muslim populations but a Shiv Sena candidate is winning the seat since last four elections. The reason for this is that the secular (read Muslim) votes in this constituency are so divided in every election that the Shiv Sena candidate always finds an edge over the others and easily wins the seat that should have surely sent a Muslim MP. In one of these four elections Samajwadi Party (SP) candidate Sohail Lokhandwala had a good chance but lost against the Shiv Sena candidate just by a meager 153 votes. Ditto is with Aurangabad where since last two elections a Shiv Sena candidate is winning the Parliamentary elections. Despite a sizeable number of secular votes, in Aurangabad the division is so deep that even former Maharashtra Chief Minister Vilasrao Deshmukh is reportedly not willing to contest from there. Same is the case with Bhiwandi. The Muslim dominated textile town should have sent Abu Asim Azmi as its Member for the State Legislative Assembly but the division of the Muslim votes helped the rival Shiv Sena candidate and he easily won the 2004 Assembly elections.


Furthermore it is not the division of the Muslim votes alone the reason for the defeat of the Muslim candidates. Polling percentages will reveal that whenever there is a powerful Muslim candidate in winning position, non-Muslim votes are polarized in favor of a non-Muslim candidate (read belonging to the communal parties) making it sure that the Muslim candidate is defeated. It shows nothing but the clear fact that the secular parties do not intend to give the party tickets to Muslim candidate in the first place and if they do, their chances of winning are reduced as they fail to transfer the non-Muslim party votes in his or her favor. Shawwal Seth, a sitting Congress corporator in Dhule Municipal Corporation is right when he says that to get the non-Muslim votes for a Muslim candidate is hardly possible.


So when this is the scenario then why the Ulema are so eagerly bargaining for something that is going to bring them nothing. Sure the Muslims need their representation to be increased in the Parliament if they want their issues to be heard. What then the solution is. Part of the solution lies in the decision taken by the Ulema in itself. Their decision to work for the secular candidates so that they win the elections is certainly part of the solution. Their extending the support to Abu Asim Azmi-in Mumbai North West and Mohd Ali-in Mumbai South Central also makes sense. But their assertion that they will work for the defeat of the Cong-NCP candidates is nothing but suicidal. Instead it is time the Mumbai Ulema bargain with the political parties to make it sure that the constituencies where the Muslim population is more than 30% be reserved for the Muslims. Of course there is every possibility that this demand will be turned down terming that religious based reservation will open a Pandora’s Box in the country, replacing the word Muslim by Minorities will surely make it viable. If the Mumbai Ulema are really worried about the Muslims as they claim, they should bargain for the reservation of the Minorities in the same lines as the government had done for the SCs and STs. Work on this now and you will get double of what you are demanding today in the next round of elections.

























 Home | Top of the page      




  Comment on this article


E-mail Address:
Write here...

Sare Jahan Se Accha

Hindustan Hamara

In 1905 more than 100 years from today, when Iqbal was a lecturer at the Government College, Lahore he was invited by his student Lala Hardayal to preside over a function. Instead of making a speech, Iqbal sang Sare Jahan Se Accha Hindustan Hamara in his style. Iqbal compiled this poem in praise of India and the poem preaches the communal harmony that had unfortunately started ceasing in India by that time. Each and every word in this poem depicts an Indian’s respect and love for the motherland and the values the Indian society inherited for long...Read Full




Ummid.com: Home | Contact Us | Disclaimer | Terms of Use | About Us | Feedback

Ummid Business: Advertise with us | Careers | Link Exchange

Ummid.com is part of Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and condition mentioned.