2G Tele Spectrum Auction: Prashan Bhushan attacks Sibal

Saturday January 08, 2011 09:02:08 PM, IANS

New Delhi: In a blistering attack on Communications Minister Kapil Sibal for saying that the audit report on auction of second generation (2G) telecom spectrum was erroneous, senior Supreme Court counsel Prashant Bhushan Saturday said that it amounted to largely giving a clean chit to his disgraced predecessor A. Raja.

DMK leader Raja had to step down in November 2010 following allegations that second generation spectrum was sold to telecom companies at below market prices, causing huge losses to the government. Raja has denied charges of wrongdoing.

Bhushan said that Sibal's statement showed "the extent to which he is willing to go to defend the government and telecom companies, many of which were his clients and now his son's clients".

"This also shows the conflict of interest in the telecom ministry and he should have never been given the charge of it," said Bhushan, who led the legal battle seeking the apex court monitoring of the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) investigations into the scam.

"This shows the attitude of Sibal who appears to be batting for the telecom companies," he said.

Assailing Sibal, Bhushan said: "For him (Sibal) to say that the expansion of network means no loss to the government is falsified by the fact that the original companies (which were allocated 2G spectrum) sold their companies at huge profits to new companies which paid much more and are now offering the services."

Sibal Friday questioned the methodology adopted by the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) in arriving at the conclusion that the allocation of 2G spectrum in 2008 at 2001 prices caused the public exchequer a loss of Rs.1.76 lakh crores.

The minister said that the losses presumably suffered by the government were "utterly erroneous and without any basis".

The apex court bench of Justice G.S. Singhvi and Justice A.K. Ganguly in their Dec 16, 2010 order said: "The CBI shall conduct thorough investigation into various issues in the report of the central vigilance Commission... who have prima facie found serious irregularities in the grant of licences to 122 applicants."

The court said a majority of applicants were said to be ineligible and asked the CBI to inquire into the blatant violation of the terms and conditions of licences and the huge loss to the public exchequer running into several thousand crores (of rupees).

The court said that "the CBI should also probe as to how licences were granted to large number of ineligible applicants and who was responsible for the same".

The jugdes asked the probe agency to inquire why the telecom regulator and the department of telecommunications did not take action against those licencees who sold their stakes or equities and also against those who failed to comply with the conditions of the licence.
 

                                           Home | Top of the Page

Top Stories

Maha Minority Commission recommends withdrawal of cases against Muslim youth

Following the confessional statement of Swami Aseemanand published by Tehelka in its latest  »

'Withdraw cases against Muslim youth detained in Malegaon blast'

Aseemanand confesses his involvement in 2006 Malegaon blast: Report

A prelude to Malegaon bomb blasts

An Inside Narrative of Nanded Blast

Malegaon Blasts: Partisan approach and biased police

Malegaon 2006 blast witness turns hostile

Was Malegaon Blast really a handiwork of Muslims?

  Most Read

NRIs on electoral rolls soon, single card for diaspora: PM

India will merge the two visa facilitation cards that are issued to people of Indian origin and soon register non-resident Indians in the electoral rolls to help them exercise  »

Telangana protesters lay siege to ministers, MPs' houses

Protests continued in Telangana for the third consecutive day Friday with protesters laying siege to the houses of state ministers, MPs and state legislators of ruling Congress and Telugu Desam Party (TDP) to demand their resignations. Leaders and activists of Telangana Rashtra Samiti  »

  News Pick

Homeless man with golden voice becomes new US hero

The US has a new rags-to-riches hero - a homeless man who has been inundated with job offers after a video of him went viral this week. Even by the warp-speed standards of the internet age, the transformation of     »

Modern art in Kashmir reflects contemporary realities

The modern art movement in Jammu and Kashmir is once again on the move after a period of stagnation during the years of insurgency. The new artistic interpretations emerging from the troubled state speak of contemporary social   »

Agatha Sangma, family escape mob fury in riot-hit Assam areas

Minister of State for Rural Development Agatha K. Sangma, her brother and Meghalaya's Leader Of Opposition Conrad K. Sangma and their father and former Lok Sabha speaker Purno A. Sangma Friday had a narrow escape  »

Kerala's 50,000 teachers to get discounted laptops

As many as 50,000 teachers in Kerala will soon be able to buy either a laptop or a netbook computer at a discounted price, according to an official. The scheme has been initiated by IT@School, the technology   »

Sibal says $40 bn spectrum loss estimate 'utterly erroneous'

Communications Minister Kapil Sibal Friday said the methodology adopted by the official auditor was "utterly erroneous" while arriving at the   »