Ummid Assistant

Applications open for Manmohan scholarship at Cambridge

Opportunities for Indian students in US

Welcome Guest! You are here: Home » International

Throwing stones Palestinians’ birthright, says Israeli writer

Saturday April 06, 2013 10:58:46 PM, IINA

Jerusalem: A newspaper op-ed piece by an Israeli writer has revived an emotional debate surrounding Israel’s 45-year rule over the West Bank and east Jerusalem: Do Palestinians who throw rocks at Israelis exercise a “birthright” of resisting military occupation, as the author argued? Or is stone-throwing an indefensible act of violence?

The heated argument — along with a police complaint West Bank settlers filed against the author — was another sign of the deepening gulf between the two peoples after decades of conflict. The debate comes at a time when Israelis are watching for any signs of a third Palestinian “intifada,” or uprising, against the occupation that began in 1967, when Israel captured the West Bank, Gaza and east Jerusalem.


Palestinians want the three territories for a state. However, two decades of intermittent Israeli-Palestinian negotiations have come up empty and Israel — while withdrawing from Gaza in 2005 — has moved more than half a million of its civilians to the rest of the occupied lands during the four-decade occupation in what much of the world says violates international law.

In the past 25 years, Palestinians have launched two uprisings. The first erupted in 1987 and was characterized by large demonstrations, often accompanied by stone-throwing. Israeli troops responded with tear gas, live fire and mass arrests. The revolt led to negotiations that produced interim peace deals. The second intifada broke out in 2000, after failed talks on a final deal, and violence escalated on both sides. Palestinians used guns and bombs, including suicide attacks.


Israel retook parts of the West Bank earlier handed to partial Palestinian control and began targeting leaders in missile attacks from helicopters. In an op-ed piece in the Haaretz daily Wednesday, Israeli journalist Amira Hass wrote that Israel has engaged in systematic violence against the Palestinians as part of its well-oiled machinery of occupation.


“Throwing stones is the birthright and duty of anyone subject to foreign rule,” wrote Hass, who covers the Palestinians and lives in the West Bank. Limitations of that right could include “the distinction between civilians and those who carry arms,” she wrote.


Her words elicited a flood of angry reactions in Israel Thursday, including from the mother of a 3-year-old Israeli girl who was critically injured last month in a West Bank road accident triggered by stone-throwing. Another writer brought up the case of a 1-year-old boy who, along with his father, was killed under similar circumstances in 2011.

The Council of Settlements, the main umbrella group for Jewish settlers, filed a complaint with police against Hass and her employer, Haaretz, accusing them of incitement to violence against Israelis driving on West Bank roads. Haaretz declined comment Thursday.


Hass, a prize-winning journalist, has been fiercely critical of Israeli policy toward the Palestinians to an extent that places her far outside the Israeli political mainstream. She said Thursday that she believes those skewering her intentionally ignored her reference to the limitations of resistance.


“The choice not to read those very clear sentences is part of the Israeli culture of denial of its institutionalized violence against the Palestinians,” she said in an emailed response to questions.

Even Yossi Beilin, a former Israeli peace negotiator and longtime advocate of Palestinian statehood, joined the chorus of critics, an apparent sign of a broad Israeli consensus on the issue.


“Stone-throwing is not a “birthright and duty’ of those being ruled (by others), but an act of violence that can lead to death, disability and injury,” Beilin wrote in the Israel Hayom daily.


His comments, perhaps more than the more predictable reactions of West Bank settlers, illustrated the divide between Israelis and Palestinians after decades of conflict and growing Israeli-enforced physical separation between the sides, The Associated Press reported.

Ghassan Khatib, a West Bank intellectual who has served in Palestinian Cabinets, unequivocally defended the Palestinians’ right to resist occupation but said non-violence is preferable to guns and bombs. Palestinians gained worldwide sympathy during the first uprising, as the David to Israel’s Goliath, but lost it during the second intifada, when they unleashed suicide bombings and shooting attacks on Israeli civilians.


“I think the non-violent and non-military struggle is more useful to the Palestinian cause,” Khatib said.


Asked about stone-throwing, he said he considers it part of the non-military approach. Israeli government spokesman Mark Regev said stone-throwing throwing cannot be considered a legitimate form of protest because it is violent. “People are being killed, people are being injured,” he said.

While the political battle lines are drawn, the legal dimension is murky. Palestinians say the right to resist occupation stems from the right to self-determination, affirmed in various UN resolutions.


A 1974 resolution recognizes “the right of the Palestinian people to regain its rights by all means,” provided they’re in line with the UN Charter. Eliav Lieblich, who teaches international law at the Interdisciplinary Center Herzliya in Israel, said international law does not dictate exactly how they can claim that right.


“There is full recognition that nations under occupation have the right to self-determination, but international law didn’t take the extra step to say that they are allowed to resist the occupying power using force,” he said.

Palestinians, along with Israeli and international human rights groups, charge that Israel’s military often uses disproportionate force against Palestinian protesters, such as live ammunition and rubber-coated steel pellets.


There has also been a sharp increase in settler violence against Palestinians and their property in recent years, rights groups have said. On Wednesday, two Palestinians were killed by army fire in a clash near a West Bank checkpoint. The Israeli military says Palestinians threw firebombs, while a Palestinian human rights group says they hurled stones and empty bottles.

Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas has accused Israel of overreacting to street protests. Abbas was one of the most outspoken opponents of the armed uprising a decade earlier. Instead, Abbas and his Fatah movement have called for “popular resistance,” or acts of civil disobedience. Abbas aide Nabil Shaath said this includes demonstrations, hunger strikes, a boycott of Israeli products and setting up protest tent camps to reclaim expropriated lands.

Shaath said the Palestinian Authority is not urging Palestinians to throw stones, but that “if they decide it’s the way to defend themselves against automatic weapons (of soldiers), then it’s up to them.”


Mustafa Barghouti, a leading Palestinian activist, said Palestinians have become more sophisticated in their protests over the years. He said a group that has set up protest camps on West Bank land earmarked for a settlement is training activists to stick to passive resistance. “Even when the army came, people did not throw stones,” he said.






Home | Top of the Page


Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of

Comments powered by DISQUS


More Headlines

British woman murdered in Srinagar houseboat, Dutchman held

Kejriwal: Voice of poor or eye on polls?

Indebted man, three family members found dead

Jamia Millia Islamia undergraduate private exams from May 1

Urdu, Sanskrit are India's culture, says Katju

Another case slapped on Raja Bhaiyya on witness's complaint

Government plans to give LPG subsidy in cash to beneficiaries

UP wins 'most improved state' award under health insurance scheme

British Library to archive billions of webpages

Can Rahul reform his party - and system?

Five Odisha students head to US for aero-design competition


Top Stories

Who make the list of most powerful Indians in GCC

The above facts are not just assumptions, they are real facts derived from the figures emerged after analyzing the list of one hundred powerful Indians in six GCC countries  »

Expatriate exposes pathetic condition of Indian Muslims living in Middle East

Indians in Middle East remit home over $35 billion every year


  Most Read

Government plans to give LPG subsidy in cash to beneficiaries

The government is planning to start transferring the subsidy for cooking gas in cash under the direct benefit transfer scheme, Finance Minister P. Chidambaram said Saturday. Addressing a media conference here, Chidambaram said he would  »

Thane building collapse: Death toll 48; two suspended

As the death toll in Thursday evening's seven-storey building collapse rose to 48, two officials were suspended Friday for not heeding complaints regarding the unauthorised structure. Civic and police officials told IANS that Deputy Municipal Commissioner Deepak Chavan and Senior  »


  News Pick

UP wins 'most improved state' award under health insurance scheme

In a first, Uttar Pradesh has been selected as the "most improved state" under the National Health Insurance Scheme (NHIS). The award would be handed over to Alok Kumar, the  »

BJP, Congress, JD-S announce Karnataka poll candidates

Karnataka's ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and main opposition Congress and Janata Dal-Secular (JD-S) Friday released first lists of their candidates for the May 5 state assembly poll. The BJP announced candidates  »

Punjab NRIs to get 10 percent quota in projects, plots

Announcing its aim to make Non-Resident Indians (NRIs) equal partners in Punjab's development, the Punjab government Friday announced a comprehensive plan to reserve 10 percent quota in projects and  »

Quit if you can't abide by constitution, Katju to Jayalalithaa

Taking serious note of the government's inability to comply with two PCI orders in the case passed in April and August 2012, Justice Katju directed the state administration to immediately suspend,  »


Picture of the Day

President of India Pranab Mukherjee released a Commemorative Postage Stamp on Late Yashwantrao Chavan, at the concluding ceremony of the birth centenary celebration of former CM of Maharashtra, Late Yashwantrao Chavan, in Mumbai on March 23, 2013. Union Minister for Agriculture and Food Processing Industries Sharad Pawar is also seen.


Recommend the story to your friends



RSS  |  Contact us


| Quick links



Subscribe to

Ummid Assistant



Science & Technology



About us




Government Schemes










Contact us


The Funny Side

Education & Career Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Advertise with us | Link Exchange is part of the Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and conditions mentioned.

© 2012 Awaz Multimedia & Publications. All rights reserved.