Freedom of speech must not extend to right to
offend: Tewari
Tuesday January 29, 2013 06:13:28 PM,
IANS
|
|
|
|
New Delhi: "Democratisation" of the information sector, with easy access to
news and social media platforms, should take into account
implications on social ethics and norms, and freedom of speech
should not extend to the right to offend, Information and
Broadcasting Minister Manish Tewari said here Tuesday.
Addressing a function of the Broadcast Engineering Society, Tewari
said media should take to self-regulation "as an instinct".
"With the democratization of the information paradigm, it has to
take into account what are the implications on social ethics,
social milieu, social norms... Freedom of speech should not extend
to the right to offend", he continued, adding that a "remedy"
should be found to the issue.
Referring to social media, Tewari said there is "need to make a
distinction between right to privacy and the right to know".
"The right to anonymity can be corrosive to social order," he
said.
The minister's comments can be seen in reference to many postings
critical of the government by anonymous accounts as well as
imposter accounts posing as the Prime Minister's Office or poking
fun at the prime minister on the social media network Twitter.
The minister said the broadcasting space has seen a huge expansion
in the past two decades, from one broadcaster in 1990 to over 850
television channels, while FM radio has also expanded in the past
five years. The social media has also expanded with around seven
crore users.
This posed a question "whether regulation has been able to keep
pace with the march of technology," said Tewari.
"For orderly development of any sector, it is a prerequisite that
enabling regulations of statutory architecture should keep pace
with the changes as it unfolds," he added.
On TRPs and sensationalism in TV media, Tewari said the issue
needs to be deliberated whether it is due to the "skewed revenue
model or an addiction that people have got into".
Taking a dig at the media and civil society, he said it was an
"oxymoron" that while parliament and judiciary were
"self-governed" institutions, the media "resents" any regulations
and civil society "self-governs every truth". But both feel "the
government should be regulated".
This, he said, comes in the way when the government needs "a
little latitude and flexibility for risk taking" which is
important to "build societies, renew institutions".
Information and Broadcasting Secretary Uday Kumar Varma, on the
occasion, pointed out the need to come up with "universalized" set
top boxes which could accept the signal of any service provider.
Varma said while medium wave radio frequencies have been
digitalized, enough has not been done to procure radio signal
receiving sets.
"We are waiting for the radio sets to hit the market," he said,
and added that digital medium wave "is the only alternative to an
efficient radio system".
He also said the "measurement of TRPs" was an issue of concern.
"When TRPs becomes the reason for determining content, it is legal
ground for the government to intervene," Varma said, and added
"there was no fair deal from the existing system of TRPs".
Varma wondered why India needs to import the TRP mechanism. "Why
is our country not able to have our own TV viewing measurement
system? Why import a measurement system that is far from
accurate"? he stressed.
Prasar Bharati - which controls national broadcaster Doordarshan -
has been critical of the present system of recording television
rating points (TRP), saying that TAM (global rating agency) data
"completely under-represents the terrestrial and rural reach of
Doordarshan".
|
|
Home |
Top of the Page
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
I |
|
|
More Headlines |
Gandhi's saintly value system |
The how and why of Shia killings in Pakistan |
Texas to execute woman murderer, first in US
since 2010 |
Now, a crowdsourced version of national anthem |
India's K-15 launch: Defence scientists do nation proud |
New US citizenship plan could help 200,000 Indians |
A web site that makes others' dreams come true |
India, Bangladesh ink extradition treaty, new visa regime |
Resignations, Telangana protests back in Andhra Pradesh |
The conflict in Mali: Time India spoke, acted |
NHRC begins open hearing of cases |
|
Top Stories |
Dhule firing victims demand SIT probe, file
PIL in SC
Demanding a probe into the police firing by Special Investigation
Team (SIT) and adequate
compensation for those killed, Dhule riot victims on Monday filed
a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) in Supreme Court. »
It was a police action, not riot: Maharashtra legislator
Upset by son's death in Dhule firing, Dy
Tahsildar to resign from post
|
|
Most Read |

Muslim scholars rebut media report about Rushdie debate
Convenor of
the seminar called on Prophet Mohammad here on Sunday
Prof Ibrahim Khalil Abedi and Dr Shakeel Samdani who was one of
the speakers refuted, and distanced them
»
|
Resignations, Telangana protests back in Andhra Pradesh
Resignations and protests for a separate Telangana state returned
to haunt Andhra Pradesh Monday, a day after the central
government, ignoring its own one-month deadline, indefinitely
»
Government defers Telangana decision; BJP, TRS
slam betrayal
|
|
News Pick |
Yashwant Sinha backs Modi as BJP's PM candidate
Bharatiya
Janata Party (BJP) leader Yashwant Sinha Monday endorsed Gujarat
Chief Minister Narendra Modi as the prime ministerial candidate
from the party.
»
Why Narendra Modi cannot be a National
Leader?
|
Would have led mobs to demolish Taj Mahal: Azam Khan
On a day when
Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Akhilesh Yadav expressed his
admiration for the Taj Mahal to foreign delegates at the Jaypee
Palace hotel in Agra, his cabinet member and Parliamentary Affairs
and Urban
»
|
US-based linguist Warsi discovers a new dialect in
Bihar
Mohammad Warsi, who teaches linguistics and Indian languages at
the Washington University in St. Louis, said the main language for
communication in Darbhanga, Madhubani, Samastipur, Begusarai and
Muzaffarpur, is
»
|
N.Koreans eating own kids in famine-hit
country?
A terrible
famine in North Korea has killed up to 10,000 people, and amid
increasing reports of cannibalism, a man has been executed for
allegedly murdering his two children for food, the Daily Mail
reported Monday. According to undercover reporters from Asia
Press, one man dug up his grandchild's corpse
»
|
|
Picture of the Day |
 |
Pradeep sings “Ae Mere Watan Ke Logon” before prime minister
Jawaharlal Nehru at R.M. School, Mumbai, March 21, 1963. It is a song
that is sung on every patriotic occasion, had moved India's first
prime minister, Jawaharlal Nehru, to tears and its strong
morale-boosting words provided solace to a nation agonized by the
defeat in the 1962 India-China war. |
|
Recommend the story to
your friends |
|
|
|
|
|