More on Ummid: International l National Regional l Politics Sports Religion l History l Culture l Education



BJP's Muslim members set off internal debate on Hindutva

UP Ulama council to contest assembly polls in Maharashtra

HRW in Gujarat to investigate Sabarmati Jail beatings

AMU to establish centers in various parts of the country

Muslim girl creates history by topping PMT 2009

Kasimji case: SHRC directs State Govt to reply for CBI probe

Sundered Hindu-Muslim, Indo-Pak-Kashmiri Family....

Brand classes for new IITs on block

Kapil Sibal salvo on faculty quota




Restoring Green in the Valley: On 29th May night (2009) in Shopian in Kashmir, two girls Nilofer and Asiya were raped and murdered. The administration tried to prove that it was a case of death due to drowning. The valley erupted into severe protests. The favorite slogan of the protesters from last several years has been....Read Full


Ten year plan for Education of the Muslim Youth



'India Unity', a play performed by little kids

Kavi Sammlen on Communal Harmony in Malegaon


Reaction has

no place in Islam


Rahman conferred honorary doctorate by AMU: Oscar-winning music maestro A.R. Rahman was Sunday conferred an honorary doctorate by the Aligarh Muslim....Read Full

Overwhelming response to Career Fest Vision 2015



The Men Inspired by Debacles: If one intends to learn “how to invite a trouble and come out of it triumphant”, then one must meet Ashwin Shah aka Lalit Shah of an empire popularly known as Oasis.....Read Full

A Trip to Globe on Handcart: There are few in this world who are recognized by the good deeds. Bhavarlalji Jain, of course,  is one among the coveted few....Read Full




BJP's Muslim members set off internal debate on Hindutva

Saturday, June 27, 2009 06:03:39 PM, Amulya Ganguli, IANS


HRW in Gujarat to investigate Sabarmati Jail beatings: A team of two researchers from Human Rights Watch (HRW), an international non- governmental organization to protect the human rights of the citizens all over the world, is currently on an assignment.....Read Full

Torture on Muslims in Gujarat jail

Maulana Naseeruddin on indefinite hunger strike in Sabarmati Jail of Gujarat

Gujarat’s Mundra port sees import of Quran objectionable

Kasimji case: SHRC directs State Govt to reply for CBI probe

VHP accused of terrorising Kathat Muslims in Rajasthan

Bajrang Dal involved in Christian attacks: Witnesses

An idea of the seriousness of the crisis faced by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) following its electoral setback can be gauged from the stirrings among its Muslim members.


Normally, they remain very much in the background, so much so that their presence in the party is often derisively described as an example of its tokenism towards the country's multicultural ethos.


The fact that Muslim members like Sikandar Bakht earlier, and Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi and Shahnawaz Hussain in recent years, remained in the BJP when the Babri Masjid was demolished or the Gujarat riots took place underlined an acquiescence which was at variance with the community's customary antipathetic attitude towards the party.


However, for the first time, both Naqvi and Hussain are known to have sought clarifications during the BJP's recent national executive meeting on what its reassertion of the ideology of Hindutva means for India's largest minority group. It was Varun Gandhi's diatribes against Muslims during the election campaign which evidently provoked them, leading to a sharp exchange of words between them and Varun's mother, Maneka Gandhi, at the meeting.


What was worth noting, however, was the support which Naqvi and Hussain received from influential leaders like Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan, Bihar Deputy Chief Minister Sushil Kumar Modi and former Maharashtra deputy chief minister Gopinath Munde.


Of the three, Chouhan made the telling point that Muslim women voted for the BJP despite their husbands' objections because of the state's development agenda. Therefore, "Muslims must not go off the party's radar," he said.


It is rare for leaders in such positions to openly favour courting Muslims in view of the BJP's widely perceived anti-minority world-view, which goes back to its pre-1977 days as the Jana Sangh.

Although the party always formally claimed that it was not against Muslims, it was never articulated in so forthright a manner as Chouhan, Modi and Munde did. Instead, it was always a formal observation which carried little conviction because of the words and deeds of some of the party's members and affiliates.


For instance, the anti-Muslim comments of Varun Gandhi, B.L. Sharma "Prem" and Ashok Sahu (of Kandhamal) during the electioneering reaffirmed the party's communal outlook. Similarly, the burning of churches in Kandhamal in Orissa, which made the BJP's ally in the state, the Biju Janata Dal (BJD), part company with it, served the same negative purpose.


In addition, the anti-Muslim utterances of the BJP's allies like the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) and the Shiv Sena have made the minorities keep the party at an arm's length. It was this attitude which made Naqvi and Hussain tell the BJP meeting that Varun, rather than Rahul Gandhi, won votes for the Congress in Uttar Pradesh by antagonising Muslims.


There is little doubt that the second successive defeat in a general election has made the BJP realise that it can no longer bank on support only from the Hindus and from an apolitical middle class to come to power at the centre. Even after its defeat in 2004, the party was more or less sure that it would be able to return to power. A string of victories in state assembly elections in the intervening period confirmed this view.


But the reverses which started last November, when the BJP lost the Delhi and Rajasthan assembly polls, and which were again evident in the April-May general elections have robbed the party of its earlier self-confidence. Although it has reiterated its commitment to Hindutva, L.K. Advani has had to say after the national executive meeting that it should not be interpreted as a narrow, anti-minority theory.


However, given the stranglehold of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) on the BJP, it is unclear to what extent it would be able to reassure the minorities that it pursues a "tolerant, inclusive" policy, as Advani has said. But it is worth noting how the views of people like Chouhan and Sushil Kumar Modi have assumed importance because of their experience in power.


In view of the BJP's status as a ruling party in Madhya Pradesh and Bihar, the two men have realised that political success depends on reaching out to all sections of people. A segmented, illiberal approach not only alienates the minorities, but puts off even others because of its mean-mindedness.


The BJP may witness, therefore, a struggle not only between the old-fashioned RSS-inspired hardliners like Rajnath Singh and doubters like Jaswant Singh who sought clarifications on Hindutva, but the party's Muslim members and their supporters like Chouhan are also likely to enter the fray.


If the BJP did not experience any ideological ferment of this nature earlier, the reason was that it was cocksure that it had found a magic mantra in Hindutva, which had brought it from the margins of politics (two Lok Sabha seats in 1984) to centrestage in the 1990s. But now the roadblocks of the defeats in 2004 and 2009 seem to have induced second thoughts. It remains to be seen whether the internal debates will refashion its outlook or the party will continue to be its old crusty self, as favoured by the RSS.


Amulya Ganguli is a political analyst.

He can be reached at





  Bookmark and Share

Home | Top of the Page

Your Ad Here

  Comment on this article

E-mail Address:
Write here...

Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) Who devised a Secure World

France's Encounter with Pharaoh Ramesses

In 1905 more than 100 years from today, when Iqbal was a lecturer at the Government College, Lahore he was invited by his student Lala Hardayal to preside over a function. Instead of making a speech, Iqbal sang....Read Full

Maulana Abul Kalam Azad - Preacher of the Peace and Harmony

Saudi King calls for Interfaith Dialogue: The Saudi king has made an impassioned plea for dialogue among Muslims, Christians and Jews — the first such proposal from a nation with no diplomatic ties to Israel and a ban on non-Muslim religious services and...Read Full

Introducing Islam




Taliban’s Jizya is Extortion, Nothing to Do with Islam: Indian Muslim religious leaders have unanimously condemned in strongest terms the Pakistani Taliban’s kidnapping, extortion of huge amounts....Read Full

Our terror, their terror: Doval’s response was that the term ‘Hindu terror’ worried him. There were, he said, two dimensions to any battle against terror. The first was law and order. You should treat all terrorists as murderers regardless of their....Read Full

Fascism and Terrorism: Two Sides of the same coin: “It seems that the fascist forces with a clear anti-Muslim agenda have infiltrated the security forces. Since the Indian... Read Full


The storm sweeping south Asia: “Afghanistan has been known over the years as the graveyard of empires” stated  General  David H. Patraeus, head of the US Central Command, in an attempt to.....Read Full

The Hidden Face of the Terrorism Exposed At last: A nation under the siege, innocent lives are at stake and the basic structure of the country in itself is at risk. Are we doing enough to combat the terrorism? With the....Read Full

Terrorist vs Terrorism

Victims of Terror

 Home | Contact Us | Disclaimer | Terms of Use | About Us | Feedback

Ummid Business: Advertise with us | Careers | Link Exchange is part of Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and condition mentioned.