More on Ummid: International l National Regional l Politics Sports Religion l History l Culture l Education


Indian Railways athletes notch top honors on opening day

Women activists protest ‘purdah’ misuse by criminals

Ishrat Killing: SC notice to Gujarat, CBI

Central Wakf Council discussed ways to establish university

'Bollywood, Media work to distort image of the Indian Muslims'

Government to introduce law to streamline Wakf boards

'If England can have Islamic banks, why not India?'

Malaysian athletes to be seen in Indian Open Athletics at Bhopal

In its third phase, Science Express to cover remote areas


Zakatul Fitr distribution made more effective: In an interesting development, Jamiat Ahle Hadees in Malegaon this year took it upon itself to collect the Zakatul Fitr – the Eid charity and then ..... Read Full

Eid Al Fitr  - A Distinct Moment Worth Experience

Goodbye Ramadan

'When London, Singapore and Tokyo can have Islamic banks, why not India?'': "When London, Singapore and Tokyo can have Islamic banks, why not Mumbai and Kochi", .... Read Full

The price of being kin of 'A Terrorist'


Mystery shrouds death of RSS activist during weapon worship: Mystery shrouds the death of a 50-year-old activist of Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, (RSS), who died of gunshot during “Shastra Puja” (weapon worship) in a school building in Kotra.... Read Full

A Muslim Gandhi?

Badshah Khan and the World’s First Nonviolent Army: This year marks the 75th anniversary of an unprecedented yet almost entirely unknown event in the history of nonviolent resistance. In the main square.... Read Full

Maharashtra Assembly Elections: Hundred seats in the state where Muslims call the shots: There are around hundred seats all across the state where Muslim population is in the range of minimum 10 to maximum 35 percent of the total. It can.... Read Full

Missing you Hemant Karkare: People of Malegaon say on blast anniversary: "We are miserably missing Hemant Karkare. The way the entire case is being handled after his unfortunate death is shocking to say the least ... Read Full


Forgotten Heroes: “I have always wondered how, the Muslims and the Hindus together, had decided to set a Mandir on fire”, said Dr. ftekhar Ansari recalling the....Read Full

A Masjid, A Mandir and Me: Malegaon, a town in India with more than 70% Muslim population has always been considered as a communally sensitive place....Read Full

Malegaon Pays Tribute to the Mumbai Martyrs: This year on January 26, 2009 the Republic Day function all over the country was adorned by the memories of those killed in the Mumbai terror attack on...Read Full

Post Blast-Malegaon Emerged Stronger: The immediate reasons for the ongoing terrorist attacks in the country are not very clear. However one thing is for sure. These strikes are the attacks onl.....Read Full

Confidence overruling the Fear: The returned figure of the references resulting after a keyword search about Malegaon at any search engine on the Internet is impressive enough to envy any place...Read Full

Mollywood attracts Global Media: After making the news in print and electronic media over the years at National level, the emerging film industry in Malegaon, popularly known as MOLLYWOO... Read Full

Malegaon Not the One you know

The Forgotten Heroes


The Pain in Malegaon


Sonia, Azad, Chavan admit there exists Pain in Malegaon: June 15 onwards, we had carried a series on highlighting the actual woes in Malegaon that according to a senior journalist “were earlier hidden.... Read Full

Tokenism ruling MMC as people cry for Action: Hence it is not surprising to see the Civic Body resorting to tokenism instead of addressing the real issues....Read Full

Pollution in Malegaon Hazardous emissions no case for MPCB: Blessings though these factories might be for their owners. But for the people living in this part....Read Full

Decisions and Implementations - The GAP widening day by day: Perform or perish. It was the warning given to the new Ministers who took the....Read Full

Dying Textile Industry: Govt. refusing to lend a helping hand despite repeated pleas: But their demand to delink the subsidy from the bank ....Read Full

A Living Hell: Established in 1863 Malegaon Municipal Council till a decade ago was regarded as one of the richest Council in Maharashtra. It was so....Read Full


More on ummid


Kapil's meeting on Madrasa board ended without result: The meeting with MPs which HRD Minister Kapil Sibal had called today lacked unanimity and ended without any results. The MPs will be sitting once again.... Read Full

Jinnah, Nehru and Partition paradox: History is about reconstruction of the past with anatomical precision. Jinnah’s tale is the greatest irony in the history of Indian subcontinent. Lucknow.. Read Full

Interfaith dialogue to strengthen the world peace and stability, Al-Turki: Highlighting the significance of the interfaith dialogue initiated by Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques King Abdullah, Abdullah Al-Turki, secretary-general of the Makkah-based Muslim...... Read Full

Sorry state of Wakf lands

Outlook terms wakf misuse as the biggest land scam in Indian history: A vast majority of people in the country believe that if the Wakf properties - donated by Muslim .... Read Full



The Men Inspired by Debacles: If one intends to learn “how to invite a trouble and come out of it triumphant”, then one must meet Ashwin Shah aka Lalit Shah of an empire popularly known as Oasis.....Read Full

Skilled Hands converting couplets into portraits: The powerloom factories might have been the only available option for the Malegaonians, the deprived people....Read Full

"I believed, nobody could stop me this time", says Sufiyah Faruquie who not only successfully cracked the UPSC exams but also stood top in the list of the 31 Muslims who made their way to.... Read Full

Malegaonian represents India at International forum with four others: A journalist hailing from Malegaon, the Muslim dominated textile town in North .... Read Full

First Lady MPSC of Malegaon devotes herself to poor people: The First Lady Pediatrician and First Lady MPSC of Malegaon, Dr. Bibi Fatema has now been  appointed as Medical Officer at ....Read Full

Zafar Shaikh-Making Possible The Impossible: While working with Zafar Shaikh at Star Bottling Company in Jalgaon nineteen years ago, the fellow co-workers had never imagined... Read Full


RSS and Minorities

Wednesday, October 07, 2009 03:57:49 PM, Dr. Ram Puniyani

Mystery shrouds death of RSS activist during weapon worship: Mystery shrouds the death of a 50-year-old activist of Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, (RSS), who died of gunshot during “Shastra Puja” (weapon worship) in a school building in Kotra.... Read Full

A prelude to Malegaon bomb blasts

United States in the world and BJP in India responsible for Terrorism: Sharad Pawar

Arrested ISI agent Sudhakar names ‘moles’ in Army

The new RSS Sarsanghchalak, Mr. Mohan Bhagawat told Minorities (Sept 20, 2009) that they should join RSS and see that ‘our intentions are clear and our behavior is good’. As per him all Muslims in India were Hindus in the past. They have only changed their way of worship, and if they accept this fact there will be no clashes. He told Christians that they should not convert people, as that creates communal violence.


Mr. Bhagwat is partly correct in saying that Muslims have Hindu ancestry. Islam spread in India, by various ways, major being the attempt of Shudras to escape the tyranny of Landlord Brahmin, to quote Swami Vivekananda, "Why amongst the poor of India so many are Mohammedans?  It is nonsense to say that they were converted by the sword. It was to gain liberty from Zamindars and Priests..." (Collected Works-Vol 8-Page330). These conversions took place as dalits were not permitted to enter temples so they were visiting the shrines of Sufi saints and under the influence of the Humanistic aspect of Islam they took to Islam. There were other reasons like, anticipation of reward, interaction with Muslims, the least important factor being fear of Muslim kings. So he is partly right that most Muslims have local ancestry.


But is the change of religion mere change of mode of worship or is it a total change in religious belief system? We do recognize that syncretic traditions of Hinduism and Islam have drawn a lot from each other. But as far as Holy book, belief in one God, Allah, belief in Mohammad as the prophet, this is not just a change in mode of worship, it is much broader than that.


So, are there clashes because Muslims deny their ancestry, and culture. By no means! As far as culture is concerned for the extremist elements, for the clergy and for those using religion for politics, the culture is just a subset of elitist version of their religion. For average people culture is a broad category, it is affected by regional factors and by some aspects of religion. A large population of Muslims and Hindus both regarded culture as a meeting and mixing point, while elite traditions look down upon the culture of the ‘other’. In India Muslims and Hindus did live in peace, creating different facets of culture, Music, Poetry, clothes and food habits, architecture and religious traditions. We see Ustad Bismillah Khan creating his wonderful work, devoted to Hindu gods and goddesses while sitting on the pavements of Kashi temples, we see Rahim and Raskhan writing beautiful poetry in devotion of Lord Krishna, we see people taking to jalebi, Biryani and other food items coming from Iran and other places from where Muslims came. We also see the intermixing in the customs, festivals. To delineate a Hindu and Muslim component of our culture was difficult at a point of time. We have the lovely tradition of people from both religions following the teachings of Ramdeo Baba Pir and Satya Pir. We have that great Saint Kabir who was loved by both Muslim and Hindus.


The problem begins with the communal historiography, looking at History through the prism of religion, introduced by British to pursue the policy of divide and rule. This version was picked up by the communal streams of Muslim League and Hindu Mahasabha-RSS, and aided in the communalization of society and rise of communal violence, more so from the decade of 1940s. To think that clashes are there because Muslims deny their common ancestry is wrong. Also Islam is a religion with its own spirituality and to reduce any religion to just a mode of worship is not correct. In post Independence India the clashes were brewed by this communal thinking, by political motivations not because of religions. Those who deny that Sufis are a part of Indian culture, or Urdu is and Indian language or that the contributions of Muslim Kings, poets, artisans, are the one’s who have created divisiveness leading to clashes. Those who deny that Bhakti tradition was part of tradition which was respected by a section of Muslims, or that celebrating Holi, Divali or Muharram and Id is part of Indian culture are the cause of the political thinking which leads to clashes.


Coming to Christians, it is not they came here with the British. Christian community in India is over 1500 years old. While their may be some aggressive proselytizers, mainly the conversions take place because of social interaction and genuine charity work. If conversions were a forced phenomenon, how to explain that there are merely 2.30% Christians in India toady? How do we explain that during last four decades the all India percentage of Christians has fallen down, 1971-2.60%, 1981-2.44%, 1991-2.34% and 2001-2.30%? One concedes that some dalits taking to Christianity may not be getting registered as Christians to keep availing the job reservations, but surely this cannot tilt the population percentage to a very great extent.


Wadhva Commission, which investigated the burning of Pastor Graham Stains by Bajrang Dal’s Dara Sing and is facing the jail term for that, concluded that Pastor Stains was not involved in any work of conversions and that the percentage of Christians in Keonjhar of Manoharpur district in Orissa, did not go up. Even recently the anti Christian violence was launched on the pretext of murder of Swami Laxmananand. It was a clear pretext to scare the Christian missionaries away from the Adivasi areas, where they are involved in the work of education and health care of Adivasis, something which empowers Adivasis. It was a clear pretext as Maoists had owned the murder of Swami.


Most of the organizations at the core of communal politics are manned on one side by Muslim Communalists and on the other by the RSS trained swayamsevaks working and controlling BJP, VHP, Vanvasi Kalyan Ashram or Bajrang Dal. Minorities want a safety, and freedom to follow their own religion. Indian Constitution does give us the liberty to practice and preach our own religion. Also RSS is not the representative of Hindus at large. We have diverse traditions of Hinduism ranging from the one of Gandhi to the other ones which are like those of Bajrang dal etc.


RSS has tried to co-opt and win over sections of minorities for enhancing its agenda. RSS progeny BJP keeps doing it, trying to win minorities, so often for electoral purpose. But over all the minorities have experienced at heavy cost of loosing lives, that RSS is like a wolf trying to put on sheep’s clothing. It is unlikely that after what has been done by its pracharks, Swayamsevaks through its progeny, Vanvasi Kalyan Ashram, Bajrang Dal and vishwa Hindu Parsishad etc. that minorities can ever be fooled by the language being used by Mr. Bhagwat. By now it is also well known that the second Sarsanghchalak of RSS, M. S. Golwalkar had ordained that minorities “the non-Hindu people in Hindustan must either adopt the Hindu culture and language, must learn to respect and revere Hindu religion, must entertain no idea but the glorification of Hindu nation i.e. they must not only give up their attitude of intolerance and ingratitude towards this land and its age old traditions, but must also cultivate the positive attitude of love and devotion instead; in one word, they must cease to be foreigners or may stay in this country wholly subordinated to the Hindu Nation claiming nothing, deserving no privileges far less any preferential treatment, not even citizen’s rights.(We or our Nationhood Defined, 1938, p. 27)


RSS is no representative of Hindus. It stands for values which are opposed to the human rights of weaker sections of society, Dalits, workers, adivasis, women and minorities. It stands for values of birth based hierarchy of caste and gender as ordained in Manu Smriti. Its primary goal is to establish Hindu nation, i.e. nation with primacy of Hindu elite men, rather than the nation envisaged by the Indian people during the freedom movement, the values which are an amalgam of the principles of Bhagat Singh, Ambedkar and Gandhi. One wishes RSS rather than deceiving others, learns the lessons of freedom movement and makes Gandhi’s Hinduism as its base rather than pursuing Godse’s Hinduism. One knows this is a practical impossibility as RSS is the organization of those who are not elected beings; they are self-appointed guardians of Brahmanical Hinduism, who neither represent Hindus nor the Humanistic aspects of Hinduism. Let’s wish RSS clan can be retrained to think as Indians rather than just as Hindus with Brahmanical values!








  Bookmark and Share

Home | Top of the Page

  Comment on this article

E-mail Address:
Write here...
 Home | Contact Us | Disclaimer | Terms of Use | About Us | Feedback

Ummid Business: Advertise with us | Careers | Link Exchange is part of Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and condition mentioned.