More on Ummid:  International l National Regional l Politics Business Religion l History l Culture l Education



SSC results in Maha: Girls shine again, Mumbai top in 8 divisions

VHP trying to relaunch campaign for Ram Mandir

Israel will fall in 20 years, says a CIA report

14-year-old girl delivers in school toilet, expelled

'Will maintain law and order if Madani arrested'

Rains toll in Maharashtra rises to 46

Heavy rains lash Mumbai, claim 9 lives

IGNOU launches Participatory Development programmes

Bangalore Festival of Art in London from June 21


No reason to get upset if someone doubts your Indianness: IAS topper to Muslims: All India topper at UPSC civil services exam Dr  .... Read Full

Muslims should opt for civil services as mission: Shah Faisal


UP girls become Gujaratis: Symbolic or Zionist mindset at work?: No, not Amitabh Bacchan or Sanjay Datt. These are .... Read Full

Modi's pro-Muslim ad in Bihar: Website claims photos from UP


'Violence in Kyrgyzstan orchestrated and well-planned': The United Nation has found evidence of bloody intent behind the chaos in Kyrgyzstan  .... Read Full

DGP Maharashtra admitted lapses in Pune blast probe: Hours after German Bakery blast ‘prime suspect’ Abdus Samad Bhatkal granted bail by a .... Read Full

Saudi Arabia will not allow use of its territory for attack on Iran: Saudi Arabia today rubbished reports that it would allow its territory to be used by Israel to launch .... Read Full

Crucial amendment to Nuclear Liability Bill withdrawn: In the face of stiff opposition from BJP and Left, the government   .... Read Full



Court grants bail to Abdus Samad: A Sessions court today granted bail to the February 13 German Bakery bomb blast suspect Abdul Samad, arrested for  .... Read Full

Raj Thackeray gets Quran as birthday gift: In the line of fire from uncle Bal Thackeray, Raj Thackeray had unexpected visitors with equally surprising gift  .... Read Full

Saudi Arabia will not allow use of its territory for attack on Iran: Saudi Arabia today rubbished reports that it would allow its territory to be used by Israel to launch .... Read Full

Decision to establish special centres historic, has no legal hurdle, says AMU VC: The Vice Chancellor of Aligarh Muslim University .... Read Full

Jugglery of the Communists and the Indian Muslims: The recently concluded Municipal bodies elections in West Bengal seems to have brought firebrand Mamata Banerjee, whose Trinamool  .... Read Full

205 ancient mosques of national importance in India: There are 205 ancient mosques declared as of national importance within the jurisdiction of Archaeological Survey of India. Gujarat ..... Read Full

Thousands of Uzbeks flee ethnic riots in Kyrgyzstan: Mobs of rioters slaughtered Uzbeks and burned their homes and businesses in Kyrgyzstan's worst ethnic  .... Read Full

'Human rights abuses against Palestinians prevalent': The death toll in Israel and the occupied Palestinian territories was "much lower" in 2009  ..... Read Full


Mr. Minister! Jamia is our offspring

Thursday, June 17, 2010 12:20:25 PM, Tahir Mahmood

Sibal, Khurshid differ over minority status to Jamia Milia Islamia: The Ministries of minority affairs and HRD are at loggerheads over the issue of granting minority status to Jamia Milia Islamia. Minority affairs Minister Salman Khurshid and HRD Minister .... Read Full

MPs join teachers, students to demand Jamia Millia minority status

Mushawerat floats Front to protect Jamia Millia from OBC quota

Jamia staff to go on strike over minority status

On this last Sunday of May ,2010, I am holding in my hands the English daily Hindustan Times which l am addicted to read every morning since my boyhood  days. A headline on the front page reads: ‘Spar between ministers over Jamia’s  minority character.‘ The story says that the Union Minority Affairs Ministry has advocated minority character for Jamia Millia lslamia which the HRD Ministry is vehemently opposed to. lt further says that the Minority Affairs Minister, expressing, displeasure on the disclosure of these differences, said that the ‘Prime Minister would be the judge and added that ‘l wilt win’. My next fortnightly article for the ‘Rashtriya Sahara' was ready but the news in the Hindustan Times prompted me to defer it at the last moment and to express my views on this matter on priority.


The irony we face in this country is that evidence is demanded also for what is quite conspicuous. Official confirmation was required even for an extremely heinous crime committed -- thanks to television —— in full view of millions of people all over the world, and to furnish it a learned judge took 17 long years. Ignoring the historical facts about AMU and Jamia Millia lslamia and depriving them of their minority character is in my opinion more damaging than demolishing historical mosques or idly witnessing their demolition. Who had established the AMU and Jamia Millia lslamia, under what circumstances, with how strenuous efforts, and for whom, answers to these questions are irrefutable part of the history of this country. Sir Syed , Ahmad Khan toiled away to lift his co-religionists from the lowest ebb of educational backwardness, with a begging bowl in his hand travelled throughout the country, braved for months together hazards of sailing to far off London to determine directions of his educational mission, killed his self respect to bear tantrums of foreign rulers, became a victim of non-stop vituperation by his own people, digested continuous taunting by Akbar Allahabadi, faced a fatwa of kufr (heresy) procured from the Hijaz, nurtured the upcoming Madrasat-ul-Uloom buildings with his old-age sweat, then at last came into existence the institution which the world knows today as the Aligarh Muslim University. Who were Sir Syed’s comrades-in-arms in this crusade supporting him financially and by words and-deeds? Mohsinul Mulk, Wiqarut Mulk, Shibii Nomani; Altaf Husain Hali, the Nawab of Rampur, the Begums of Bhopal state, who else'? And, for whom was this palatial edifice of education built'? Obviously not for those fellow countrymen who neither suffered from educational backwardness nor lacked in material resources, but for those hard-working elders’ own community that was totally lacking in worldly comforts and to see whoso children holding the Quran in one hand and science in the other Sir Syed laid this garden of learning. And, what does the word ‘Muslim‘ in the nomenclature of the institution indicate, what do the engraved arches and ramparts of AMU speak of? Why is a Our’anic verse printed on top of the University degrees? Is there an iota of scope for denying that it were the elders of the present-day Muslim minority who had sweated blood to establish this institution and left it behind as their heritage for brightening the community’s future?.


And, what is the Jamia Millia lslamia  - an offshoot of Aligarh’s temple of learning to plan whoso establishment a great Musiim leador Muhammad Ali Jauhar convened meetings with like minded people in a dingy room of Aligarh’s "Kachchi Barik," hostel whoso Foundation Committee included eminent religious scholars like Mufti Kifayatullah, Syed Sulaiman Nadwi, Shabbir Ahmad Usmani and Husain Ahmad Madni, which- was inaugurated by Maulana Mahmud Hasan of Dooband, which was later shifted to Delhi and placed in the care of Hakim Ajmal Khan, to keep which alive Dr. Mukhtar Ahmad Ansari and a number of nationalist Muslims made strenuous efforts, to serve which on returning home three brilliant youth of the community then studying in Germany together -  Zakir Husain, Muhammad Mujeeb and Aabid Husain -- committed their lives sacrificing a bright future otherwise awaiting them, where Urdu was adopted as the language of teaching and administration, where vice-chancellor was designated as ‘Shaikh-ul-Jamia' and registrar as ‘Musaijil,’ for such an institution one needs to be told as to who established it, why, and for whom?


Why Father of the Nation Mahatma Gandhi, the first architect of independent India Jawaharlal Nehru, and the right-hand man of both, Maulana Azad, had not acceded to the communalists‘ demand made during the dreadful post-partition days to delete the words ‘Muslim’ and ‘lslamia‘ from the names of AMU and Jamia Millia lslamia? Why the leaders of the community had rejected the offer made by the communalist lobby when communal politicians proposed that the AMU campus be exchanged with the DAV College of Lahore, why had these elders of the nation outrightly rejected the proposal — obviously since these great leaders were history-conversant, reality-conscious, champions of justice and far-sighted. Fully recognizing that both these institutions had been established for the Muslim citizens by their ancestors, and knowing well that in a democracy it often becomes difficult for the minorities to remain educationally at par with the majority, they never wanted to deprive   the community of this precious ancestral heritage.


When over two years after independence a National i Constitution for free India came in force, it unconditionally guaranteed to all religious and linguistic minorities a fundamental right to establish and run their own educational institutions and strictly prohibited any discrimination by the government against such institutions in matters of financial aid, etc. Obviously, it neither did nor could mean that a minority will be entitled to establish its own institutions in the future but will have no rights over the pre-existing institutions established by its ancestors and that such latter institutions shall be deemed to be excluded from the purview of this constitutional guarantee. In the first place such an interpretation of the Constitution shall be extremely absurd and ridiculous, and then internal evidence against such an interpretation is found in the Constitution itself. The name of Aligarh Muslim University in itself reveals the history and reality as to who had established it and for whom, and yet, it was mentioned with this very particular name in the Constitution at its inception and no change has ever been made in lt.


In fact, the Constitution did not grant to the minorities any s new right to establish their institutions; it just affirmed this right which was recognized even earlier both in the country and under international human rights law; and minority institutions established before independence cannot be excluded from the scope of this affirmation.


I have always endeavoured, both in my personal and all official capacities, to elucidate these historical facts and constitutional realities and emphasized that both AMU and Jamia are definitely minority institutions and cannot be deprived of such character. The recent report of Ranganath Mishra Commission, prepared by me, has also strongly recommended that by means of specific Parliamentary legislation both these institutions should be entrusted with specific and unrestricted responsibility of fulfilling educational needs of the Muslim minority, since I am convinced that this is the demand of justice.


lf the Hindustan Times report forming the basis of my submissions is accurate, the Minority Affairs Minister has certainly served the cause of constitutional justice by raising his voice in favour of the minority character of Jamia Millia Islamia, for which he deserves appreciation and greetings. And, if the news report is also true that the HRD Minister is opposed to recognizing the minority character of Jamie Millia lslamia, I would like to submit to him with due deference that Jamia Millia Islamia was conceived and nurtured by our ancestors and is the apple of our eye on which we have a historical and constitutional right  -- negating its minority character is tantamount to losing sight of historical facts and ignoring demands of constitutional justice. 


Translated from Urdu by The Milli Gazette

Prof Tahir Mahmood, Chairman, Amity University Institute Advanced Legal Studies, is a former Chairman of National Minorities Commission & Member Law Commission of India





  Bookmark and Share

Home | Top of the Page

  Comment on this article


E-mail Address:

Write here...







 Home | Contact Us | Disclaimer | Terms of Use | About Us | Feedback

Ummid Business: Advertise with us | Careers | Link Exchange is part of Awaz Multimedia & Publications providing World News, News Analysis and Feature Articles on Education, Health. Politics, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Industry etc. The articles or the views displayed on this website are for public information and in no way describe the editorial views. The users are entitled to use this site subject to the terms and condition mentioned.